Abolish Qualified Immunity for Law Enforcement

The Issue

Too many instances have arisen where law enforcement officers, shielded by qualified immunity, have violated the rights of individuals. This immunity often protects officers from accountability, even when they are clearly in the wrong. It's a significant flaw in our justice system that needs immediate correction.

I am particularly concerned about the countless individuals whose lives have been severely impacted due to officers who, whether through ignorance or deliberate action, misuse their power. Qualified immunity acts as a barrier to justice for victims who seek redress for their grievances. It undermines public trust in law enforcement, as citizens feel unprotected when those meant to serve and protect can act without accountability.

A 2020 Yale Law Journal study found that qualified immunity frequently leads to cases being dismissed before they even reach trial. Furthermore, the concept of qualified immunity is not a law passed by Congress but rather a judicial doctrine that the Supreme Court has adapted and extended far beyond its original intent. According to a Reuters investigation, police departments often use the doctrine to avoid settling civil rights lawsuits and to minimize liability.

Removing qualified immunity does not mean removing protections for officers who act within the law. It means holding accountable those who abuse their power. Other professions, where lives are also at risk, do not enjoy such immunity. Doctors, teachers, and firefighters, for example, can be held liable for their professional actions, yet law enforcement is often insulated from similar accountability.

Reforming this doctrine is paramount to focusing on a fair legal system where everyone is truly equal before the law. Join me in calling upon our legislators to address this urgently and restore trust in law enforcement by subjecting officers to the same legal standards as the ordinary citizen. Sign this petition to demand change, justice, and accountability. I am pro police but qualified immunity makes it nearly impossible.to weed out the bad apples.

10

The Issue

Too many instances have arisen where law enforcement officers, shielded by qualified immunity, have violated the rights of individuals. This immunity often protects officers from accountability, even when they are clearly in the wrong. It's a significant flaw in our justice system that needs immediate correction.

I am particularly concerned about the countless individuals whose lives have been severely impacted due to officers who, whether through ignorance or deliberate action, misuse their power. Qualified immunity acts as a barrier to justice for victims who seek redress for their grievances. It undermines public trust in law enforcement, as citizens feel unprotected when those meant to serve and protect can act without accountability.

A 2020 Yale Law Journal study found that qualified immunity frequently leads to cases being dismissed before they even reach trial. Furthermore, the concept of qualified immunity is not a law passed by Congress but rather a judicial doctrine that the Supreme Court has adapted and extended far beyond its original intent. According to a Reuters investigation, police departments often use the doctrine to avoid settling civil rights lawsuits and to minimize liability.

Removing qualified immunity does not mean removing protections for officers who act within the law. It means holding accountable those who abuse their power. Other professions, where lives are also at risk, do not enjoy such immunity. Doctors, teachers, and firefighters, for example, can be held liable for their professional actions, yet law enforcement is often insulated from similar accountability.

Reforming this doctrine is paramount to focusing on a fair legal system where everyone is truly equal before the law. Join me in calling upon our legislators to address this urgently and restore trust in law enforcement by subjecting officers to the same legal standards as the ordinary citizen. Sign this petition to demand change, justice, and accountability. I am pro police but qualified immunity makes it nearly impossible.to weed out the bad apples.

The Decision Makers

Donald Trump
President of the United States
James Vance
Vice President of the United States

Petition Updates

Share this petition

Petition created on May 1, 2025