Virginia Found a Physical Therapist Safe to Practice. Why the Indefinite Restrictions?

339

Let’s get to 500 signatures!
Petitions with 1,000+ supporters are 5x more likely to win!

The Issue

FOUND SAFE AND COMPETENT. STILL PLACED ON INDEFINITE PROBATION.

TODAY, ONE THERAPIST. TOMORROW, ANY LICENSED PROFESSIONAL.

THE CONTRADICTION EVERY VIRGINIAN SHOULD KNOW

What happens when a government licensing board declares a healthcare professional safe and competent to practice, yet imposes indefinite restrictions that interfere with patients' ability to choose their care?

My name is Scott Roberts. For 20 years, I practiced physical therapy in Virginia, providing more than 110,000 patient treatment sessions without a prior disciplinary complaint.

On February 7, 2022, the Virginia Board of Physical Therapy summarily suspended my license following allegations involving recommending pelvic floor therapy.

My career, reputation, business, and financial security were devastated.

But what happened afterward raises questions that should concern every healthcare professional and patient in Virginia.

THE FACTS THAT SHOULD CONCERN EVERYONE

1. NOT ONE PATIENT WHO ACTUALLY RECEIVED PELVIC FLOOR THERAPY FROM ME FILED A COMPLAINT ABOUT THAT TREATMENT.

The two complainants involved in the original proceedings never received pelvic floor therapy from me.

Pelvic floor therapy was discussed or recommended as a potential treatment option based on clinical findings. Neither complainant underwent that treatment with me.

I dispute the Board's characterization of those recommendations and the treatment actually provided.

2. A COURT REJECTED PORTIONS OF THE BOARD'S ORIGINAL DECISION.

In March 2023, the Henrico County Circuit Court vacated portions of the Board's decision involving pelvic floor therapy, consent, and referral requirements.

The court remanded the case for reconsideration of the sanction.

Yet the Board subsequently imposed the same sanction.

Later courts upheld the Board's action, but the underlying dispute about the evidence, professional standards, and fairness of the proceedings remains central to my call for independent oversight.

3. THE BOARD EVENTUALLY FOUND ME SAFE AND COMPETENT TO PRACTICE.

On December 19, 2025, nearly four years of being unable to earn a living, the Board reinstated my physical therapy license.

Its order concluded that I had demonstrated I was safe and competent to resume practice.

The Board also determined that Findings of Fact 2 and 3 in the reinstatement proceeding were established by the evidence but did not constitute violations.

4. YET THE BOARD IMPOSED INDEFINITE RESTRICTIONS.

Despite its finding of safety and competence, the Board imposed:

  • Indefinite probation, lasting no less than two years.
  • Mandatory Board-approved chaperones for every pelvic floor therapy session.
  • No option for patients to decline the chaperone while receiving that treatment from me.
  • Additional consent, waiting-period, monitoring, and documentation requirements.
  • Continuing oversight and financial obligations associated with probation.

These restrictions apply specifically to my practice.

But the precedent they could establish reaches far beyond me.

THE MOST DISTURBING QUESTION: WHO CONTROLS YOUR MEDICAL CARE?

Imagine seeking treatment from a licensed healthcare professional you know and trust.

You understand the proposed treatment. You provide informed consent. You are comfortable with your clinician.

But a government licensing board requires an additional person to be present during your intimate medical treatment.

Even if you do not want that person present, you cannot decline the chaperone and continue receiving that treatment from your chosen clinician.

That is the situation created by the Board's restrictions on my practice.

Chaperones can serve legitimate patient-safety purposes. But mandatory, non-declinable chaperones also raise serious questions about patient privacy, autonomy, and access to care.

Who determines whether such restrictions are necessary?

What evidence must support them?

And what protections exist against inconsistent or disproportionate requirements?

Patient safety and patient autonomy should not be treated as mutually exclusive.

THIS IS BIGGER THAN ONE PHYSICAL THERAPIST

My case raises fundamental questions about government accountability.

DUE PROCESS:

  • Can licensing boards impose or maintain severe restrictions without adequately addressing evidence that contradicts their conclusions?

EQUAL TREATMENT:

  • What safeguards ensure that professionals performing comparable treatments are evaluated under consistent standards?

PATIENT AUTONOMY:

  • When may a licensing board override an informed patient's preference concerning who is present during treatment?

FREEDOM OF SPEECH:

  • How can professionals challenge government decisions without their criticism being improperly treated as evidence of professional unfitness?

PROPORTIONALITY:

  • What evidence should be required to justify indefinite restrictions after a Board finds a professional safe and competent to resume practice?

These are not questions that should be answered by one licensing board operating without meaningful independent scrutiny.

They concern the integrity of Virginia's entire professional licensing system.

WHAT WE ARE ASKING VIRGINIA TO DO

We call upon the Virginia General Assembly and appropriate oversight authorities to:

  1. Conduct an independent review of the Virginia Board of Physical Therapy's disciplinary and reinstatement proceedings in my case, including the evidence supporting the restrictions imposed.
  2. Review mandatory chaperone requirements to ensure that individualized conditions are justified by documented safety concerns, are proportionate, and appropriately consider informed patient choice.
  3. Strengthen due-process protections so licensing boards must meaningfully address material contradictory evidence and explain the legal basis for disciplinary decisions.
  4. Ensure consistent professional standards and prevent the improper retroactive application of unpublished requirements.
  5. Establish meaningful accountability when licensing boards exceed their lawful authority or fail to follow required procedures.

These reforms would not weaken legitimate professional regulation.

They would strengthen it by ensuring that licensing decisions are fair, transparent, consistent, and supported by evidence.

WHY YOUR SIGNATURE MATTERS

For nearly five years, I have fought to defend my career, professional reputation, and the patients who depend on my care.

I have exhausted enormous financial and personal resources pursuing legal remedies.

But this petition is no longer simply about what happened to me.

It is about whether the government agencies entrusted with protecting the public are themselves subject to meaningful oversight and accountability.

If licensing boards can impose extraordinary restrictions without adequately explaining their necessity, every licensed professional has reason to be concerned.

If those restrictions unnecessarily interfere with informed patient choice, every patient has reason to be concerned.

TODAY, ONE PHYSICAL THERAPIST. TOMORROW, ANY LICENSED PROFESSIONAL.

PLEASE SIGN AND SHARE THIS PETITION.

Help us demand independent oversight, evidence-based regulation, meaningful due process, and respect for patient autonomy.

Government must follow the law when it enforces the law.

Scott Roberts, PT, MPT

#RestorePTJustice

 
Supporting documentation includes the Board's disciplinary and reinstatement orders, hearing testimony, circuit court decisions, professional education records, and other materials relevant to the disputed findings and restrictions.

avatar of the starter
Scott RobertsPetition StarterFor more than 20 years, I dedicated my life to helping others through compassionate, evidence-based care, while spending countless evenings and weekends pursuing advanced training to better serve my patients.

Supporter Voices

Petition Updates