USMMA Historical Painting Defense

The Issue

On January 20, 2023, an historic painting at Kings Point with religious symbolism was covered with a curtain as it was deemed offensive to a small group of individuals who complained. The painting depicts sailors lost at sea as well as an image of Jesus. The decision to cover the painting was made with no opportunity for discussion. The artwork was completed in 1944 during World War II and the first days of the Academy. It is an historic painting that has conveyed hope and inspiration to nearly every class of midshipmen to come through the Academy. The painting is part of the legacy of the institution and has been present in Wiley Hall undisturbed since 1947. In addition, the decision to add a covering is against legal precedent set by the Supreme Court for historic displays which include religious symbolism. The midshipmen, alumni and community of the United States Merchant Marine Academy who sign this petition are requesting that any form of covering be removed to allow the original artwork to be viewed and that a plaque describing the historic significance of the painting be placed alongside it.

This petition had 4,854 supporters

The Issue

On January 20, 2023, an historic painting at Kings Point with religious symbolism was covered with a curtain as it was deemed offensive to a small group of individuals who complained. The painting depicts sailors lost at sea as well as an image of Jesus. The decision to cover the painting was made with no opportunity for discussion. The artwork was completed in 1944 during World War II and the first days of the Academy. It is an historic painting that has conveyed hope and inspiration to nearly every class of midshipmen to come through the Academy. The painting is part of the legacy of the institution and has been present in Wiley Hall undisturbed since 1947. In addition, the decision to add a covering is against legal precedent set by the Supreme Court for historic displays which include religious symbolism. The midshipmen, alumni and community of the United States Merchant Marine Academy who sign this petition are requesting that any form of covering be removed to allow the original artwork to be viewed and that a plaque describing the historic significance of the painting be placed alongside it.

Petition Updates

Share this petition

Petition created on January 24, 2023