Petition updateTrucker Gun RightsSBTC Calls for Comments in Support of its Class ELD Exemption Application Published by FMCSA

James LambWashington, DC, United States
Jun 4, 2018
CALL TO ACTION: It is time to comment in support of SBTC's ELD Exemption application...
The FMCSA has published the SBTC's ELD Exemption application.
Here is the revised application we submitted on Feb 1st:
http://truckers.com/files/126741535.pdf
Here is the FMCSA notice and invitation for public comment.
https://www.regulations.gov/docket?D=FMCSA-2018-0180
Click "Comment Now" to file your comment in support.
When commenting, here are the bullet points we recommend you address (you may cut and paste these into your comment if you agree):
The ELD Rule is not a stand-alone safety regulation per se; that is, it is meaningless unless it is attached to the actual relevant safety regulation: the hours of service rule. If the requested exemption is granted, the hours of service regulation still remains in full force and effect and drivers are still required to comply. At issue, is simply the mechanism to track hours of service compliance. Paper record of duty status (RODS) remain the tool to show drivers' compliance and have sufficed as a mechanism to ensure public safety since the 1930s. Mandating ELDs is therefore excessive and more extensive than necessary to ensure compliance.
The FMCSA ELD rule did not take into account the impact on the smallest operators, especially owner-operators. It lumped one may carriers into the same category as carriers with annual revenues of $28.5 million. The burden on the smallest businesses is proportionally higher to the mega carriers who can more easily absorb the increased costs. This has an anti-competitive effect not considered by FMCSA. The rule is therefore contrary to the national transportation policy codified at 49 USC 13101 in which Congress directed national transportation ensure fair competition.
While MAP-21 mandated that vehicles be equipped with ELDs it did not specifically direct FMCSA to create a rule to eliminate the use of paper RODS. The exemption would enable small carriers to elect either RODS or ELDs as a matter of choice.
Implementation of ELDs has disrupted the supply chain in that many drivers have left the industry, causing a capacity crunch and a temporary increase in rates due to increased freight volumes and market forces as a matter of supply and demand, costs that are ultimately borne by the American consumer in terms of increased products for goods.
FMCSA must under 49 USC 13541 grant the exemption if there is evidence that ELDs are not necessary to carry out the transportation policy of 49 USC 13101, not needed to protect shippers from the abuse of market power and is in the public interest.
FMCSA has arbitrarily granted exemptions to certain applicants suggesting it is already aware that continued use of RODS is a mechanism that will ensure public safety.
The US Government regularly exempts the smallest businesses from regulations to lessen the burden on these businesses including but not limited to COBRA, FMLA, Affordable Care Act, and OSHA regulations.
Support now
Sign this petition
Copy link
WhatsApp
Facebook
Nextdoor
Email
X