

To the Celebrities that Thanked Biden for Standing with Israel
The Issue
To All the Artists Who Signed the Letter Thanking Biden,
We would like to thank you for the candor that you have expressed in openly signing a letter to our President thanking him for standing on the side of Israel. While seeing some of the most beloved names in the industry get published on this list has been devastating to millions of fans who were rooting for you, the way you have used your voice and your platform has provided for us a much needed clarity.
Art has always been the best part of humanity because it provides us so many different mediums within which we can express the most profound parts of our existence. Truth, justice, love, the pursuit of liberation are all constant themes in some of the most timeless pieces of art that have managed to strike a chord across the generations. Unfortunately, the world we are all living in has morphed itself into a veritable machine of exploitation to the point where even the artists of our time find themselves drawn to produce the art that sells the best. And because of this we have become deluded into believing that the messages that reside within the art that you produced are potentially ones that you personally believe in despite the underlying understanding that money is a powerful incentive.
But in recent decades more and more people have found that they are not so comfortable separating the art from the artist, and supporting terrible people who do and think terrible things. In coming to that realization, millions of people have determined that it is important for the artists they look up to to use their voice and stand on the right side of history. Standing on the right side of history, by default, became the profitable thing to do. So when Black Lives Matter established itself as a movement to dismantle the racist systems that continue to oppress Black folks across the globe, you stepped up to the plate and had your PR team post a black square on your social media pages so that the world could see that you proudly stood with the Black activists fighting for equality. And when society shifted again, pushing for the progressive inclusion and uplifting of trans folks because we were getting more and more disturbed to learn about the violence they were facing, you stepped up to the plate again and pleasantly incorporated a rainbow somewhere in your PR image, or at the very least, you kept silent about your true feelings when it comes to Trans folks, and that was considered enough for millions of fans to hold out hope and come to the conclusion that you might be a good person.
It’s true that these PR stunts are notably empty because any activist can tell you that true change comes from advocacy work and policies that are passed into legislation as a means to protect minorities that were otherwise facing discrimination. But profound, generation altering shifts can only occur when artists and activists come together to guide society forward into a new age where, hopefully, more people feel seen, heard, and loved. And while these gestures may seem to have been enough to create a sturdy image of principled inclusivity, allowing you to continue conning your fans into believing you are a decent and talented human being, I’m sure none of you recognized the true litmus test of your time: Palestine.
Regardless of what your PR teams initially must have believed, we as a collective majority are actually not that dumb. Despite the astonishing lengths that mainstream media will go to to silence the narratives of Palestinians that have been facing oppression and ethnic cleansing over the past 70+ years, living in an age of connection and having direct access to the horrors the Palestinians are facing as we speak has been a sobering wake up call. We recognize who is the oppressor and who is the oppressed in this crisis as easily as we recognize your face in a perfume commercial. And with that recognition, came the expectation that you also saw the horrific conditions the Israeli government was inflicting upon millions of Palestinians, and you too, would use your voice to stand up for the oppressed. Of course, because this letter is addressed to you, you failed those expectations with flying colors, and in doing so placed the entirety of your stance into question.
How much do you actually care about Black lives being protected from police brutality if you are supporting the state that trains our police to inflict that same violence on our fellow Americans? How genuine in your concern for Trans lives if you manage to find the time to thank our President for supporting Israel, but can’t find the time to condemn politician after politician for passing laws that have forced Trans people to become political refugees in their own country? How many works of art have you cosigned because you claim to have been drawn to those messages and themes of freedom, revolution, and humanity?
You failed the litmus test, and willingly, publicly signed your name onto the wrong side of history. And I cannot be more grateful to you for it because in doing so you have shattered the illusion of celebrity. What is there to celebrate about you if you cannot tell the difference between right and wrong? How wonderful is your art and talent if your actions and words manage to be so empty and careless at best and violently oppressive at worst. But again, I thank you. You have released us from the chokehold we allowed you to have on us. And you have allowed us to recognize that, in the end, we should all be placing our faith and hope in each other. True change will not be lead by a handful of beautiful faces in Hollywood, but by the masses that stand together in the millions across the globe, their faces blurred into obscurity that history will never remember, but their voices, our voices all collectively rising to say the same thing: Free Palestine.
Sincerely,
Just Another Face In the Crowd
5,876
The Issue
To All the Artists Who Signed the Letter Thanking Biden,
We would like to thank you for the candor that you have expressed in openly signing a letter to our President thanking him for standing on the side of Israel. While seeing some of the most beloved names in the industry get published on this list has been devastating to millions of fans who were rooting for you, the way you have used your voice and your platform has provided for us a much needed clarity.
Art has always been the best part of humanity because it provides us so many different mediums within which we can express the most profound parts of our existence. Truth, justice, love, the pursuit of liberation are all constant themes in some of the most timeless pieces of art that have managed to strike a chord across the generations. Unfortunately, the world we are all living in has morphed itself into a veritable machine of exploitation to the point where even the artists of our time find themselves drawn to produce the art that sells the best. And because of this we have become deluded into believing that the messages that reside within the art that you produced are potentially ones that you personally believe in despite the underlying understanding that money is a powerful incentive.
But in recent decades more and more people have found that they are not so comfortable separating the art from the artist, and supporting terrible people who do and think terrible things. In coming to that realization, millions of people have determined that it is important for the artists they look up to to use their voice and stand on the right side of history. Standing on the right side of history, by default, became the profitable thing to do. So when Black Lives Matter established itself as a movement to dismantle the racist systems that continue to oppress Black folks across the globe, you stepped up to the plate and had your PR team post a black square on your social media pages so that the world could see that you proudly stood with the Black activists fighting for equality. And when society shifted again, pushing for the progressive inclusion and uplifting of trans folks because we were getting more and more disturbed to learn about the violence they were facing, you stepped up to the plate again and pleasantly incorporated a rainbow somewhere in your PR image, or at the very least, you kept silent about your true feelings when it comes to Trans folks, and that was considered enough for millions of fans to hold out hope and come to the conclusion that you might be a good person.
It’s true that these PR stunts are notably empty because any activist can tell you that true change comes from advocacy work and policies that are passed into legislation as a means to protect minorities that were otherwise facing discrimination. But profound, generation altering shifts can only occur when artists and activists come together to guide society forward into a new age where, hopefully, more people feel seen, heard, and loved. And while these gestures may seem to have been enough to create a sturdy image of principled inclusivity, allowing you to continue conning your fans into believing you are a decent and talented human being, I’m sure none of you recognized the true litmus test of your time: Palestine.
Regardless of what your PR teams initially must have believed, we as a collective majority are actually not that dumb. Despite the astonishing lengths that mainstream media will go to to silence the narratives of Palestinians that have been facing oppression and ethnic cleansing over the past 70+ years, living in an age of connection and having direct access to the horrors the Palestinians are facing as we speak has been a sobering wake up call. We recognize who is the oppressor and who is the oppressed in this crisis as easily as we recognize your face in a perfume commercial. And with that recognition, came the expectation that you also saw the horrific conditions the Israeli government was inflicting upon millions of Palestinians, and you too, would use your voice to stand up for the oppressed. Of course, because this letter is addressed to you, you failed those expectations with flying colors, and in doing so placed the entirety of your stance into question.
How much do you actually care about Black lives being protected from police brutality if you are supporting the state that trains our police to inflict that same violence on our fellow Americans? How genuine in your concern for Trans lives if you manage to find the time to thank our President for supporting Israel, but can’t find the time to condemn politician after politician for passing laws that have forced Trans people to become political refugees in their own country? How many works of art have you cosigned because you claim to have been drawn to those messages and themes of freedom, revolution, and humanity?
You failed the litmus test, and willingly, publicly signed your name onto the wrong side of history. And I cannot be more grateful to you for it because in doing so you have shattered the illusion of celebrity. What is there to celebrate about you if you cannot tell the difference between right and wrong? How wonderful is your art and talent if your actions and words manage to be so empty and careless at best and violently oppressive at worst. But again, I thank you. You have released us from the chokehold we allowed you to have on us. And you have allowed us to recognize that, in the end, we should all be placing our faith and hope in each other. True change will not be lead by a handful of beautiful faces in Hollywood, but by the masses that stand together in the millions across the globe, their faces blurred into obscurity that history will never remember, but their voices, our voices all collectively rising to say the same thing: Free Palestine.
Sincerely,
Just Another Face In the Crowd
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on October 27, 2023