Install Platform-Edge Doors on All Crossrail Platforms

The Issue

Construction on Crossrail – London's £15 billion new railway – is well underway and from 2019, the railway will transport 200 million passengers a year.

The trains will be automated, but are not equipped with collision avoidance systems capable of detecting objects or persons on the track (they will have sensors to detect other trains). 

It is therefore essential that platform-edge doors are installed on all platforms served by Crossrail trains. Platform-edge doors ensure the safe separation of passengers from the danger of falling on to the railway track. These doors are already a fixture of the Jubilee Line extension on the London Underground, and are utilised in modern railways in at least 23 countries.

However, not all stations on the Crossrail network will have platform-edge doors installed, a decision that railway design experts have labelled "curious". Neither Custom House or Abbey Wood, stations currently under construction, will have these doors installed, even though the cost to outfit a station with these doors is estimated by Transport for London to cost less than £800,000.

Platform-edge doors do not only prevent passengers from falling onto railway tracks. They have important functions in preventing the spread of fire. In Taipei, a simulated fire in a station with platform-edge doors installed restricted the fire from reaching the tunnel, enabling the situation to be controlled in under 6 minutes (a similar incident in the Baku Metro, which did not have platform-edge doors, killed 337 people in 1995). In addition, trains can travel faster and maintain tighter schedules when operators can be certain there are no intruders on the tracks. The doors also make it cheaper to climatise railway stations, as only platforms - and not tunnels - need be air conditioned.

There would be complexities associated with introducing platform-edge doors intro existing platforms on the London Underground. But there is no compelling reason why a new railway station built in London, projected to see 100,000 commuters a day, should not be future-proofed and built with platform-edge doors.

It is unthinkable, in the 21st century, that a driverless railway could be built in a city as densely populated as London without platform-edge doors installed on every railway platform. Such a decision poses an unacceptable risk to human life and must be changed.

avatar of the starter
N APetition StarterI am a London-based policy expert interested in media policy, internet governance, e-commerce, and matters concerning the telecommunications sector. In addition, I am always open to helping social enterprises formulate their public policy positions. Before making the move to the UK, I had called Buenos Aires, Jakarta, Perth, and Vancouver home.
This petition had 11 supporters

The Issue

Construction on Crossrail – London's £15 billion new railway – is well underway and from 2019, the railway will transport 200 million passengers a year.

The trains will be automated, but are not equipped with collision avoidance systems capable of detecting objects or persons on the track (they will have sensors to detect other trains). 

It is therefore essential that platform-edge doors are installed on all platforms served by Crossrail trains. Platform-edge doors ensure the safe separation of passengers from the danger of falling on to the railway track. These doors are already a fixture of the Jubilee Line extension on the London Underground, and are utilised in modern railways in at least 23 countries.

However, not all stations on the Crossrail network will have platform-edge doors installed, a decision that railway design experts have labelled "curious". Neither Custom House or Abbey Wood, stations currently under construction, will have these doors installed, even though the cost to outfit a station with these doors is estimated by Transport for London to cost less than £800,000.

Platform-edge doors do not only prevent passengers from falling onto railway tracks. They have important functions in preventing the spread of fire. In Taipei, a simulated fire in a station with platform-edge doors installed restricted the fire from reaching the tunnel, enabling the situation to be controlled in under 6 minutes (a similar incident in the Baku Metro, which did not have platform-edge doors, killed 337 people in 1995). In addition, trains can travel faster and maintain tighter schedules when operators can be certain there are no intruders on the tracks. The doors also make it cheaper to climatise railway stations, as only platforms - and not tunnels - need be air conditioned.

There would be complexities associated with introducing platform-edge doors intro existing platforms on the London Underground. But there is no compelling reason why a new railway station built in London, projected to see 100,000 commuters a day, should not be future-proofed and built with platform-edge doors.

It is unthinkable, in the 21st century, that a driverless railway could be built in a city as densely populated as London without platform-edge doors installed on every railway platform. Such a decision poses an unacceptable risk to human life and must be changed.

avatar of the starter
N APetition StarterI am a London-based policy expert interested in media policy, internet governance, e-commerce, and matters concerning the telecommunications sector. In addition, I am always open to helping social enterprises formulate their public policy positions. Before making the move to the UK, I had called Buenos Aires, Jakarta, Perth, and Vancouver home.

The Decision Makers

Boris Johnson
Prime Minister
Responded
Dear Petitioner Thank you for your petition of 18 September about installation of platform-edge doors on all Crossrail platforms. When fully operational in 2019, Crossrail will serve 40 stations across London and the south east. Platform Screen Doors (PSDs) will be incorporated at all of the new sub-surface stations. Thirty stations are on the existing network. Their platforms will be shared by different rolling stock, including both freight and passenger trains. The specification of these trains, for example door alignment, means it would not be possible to install PSDs at these stations. The Crossrail platforms at Abbey Wood and Custom House, while serving only Crossrail trains, are above ground. Analysis undertaken by Crossrail Ltd has concluded that the cost of installing PSDs, would be £8m per station. As these stations are above ground the installation of PSDs does not mitigate the risks associated with fires or aid air conditioning, benefits which were mentioned in your petition. All stations will be staffed from first to last train and a number of other solutions have been incorporated into the designs of the stations to minimise risks such as trespassers on the tracks. Yours sincerely Public Liaison Officer Greater London Authority
Terry Morgan CBE
Terry Morgan CBE
Chairman of Crossrail
Andrew Wolstenholme OBE
Andrew Wolstenholme OBE
Chief Executive Officer of Crossrail
Michèle Dix
Michèle Dix
Managing Director, Crossrail 2
Mike Brown
Mike Brown
Head of Operations at Crossrail
Petition updates
Share this petition
Petition created on 17 September 2015