Petition updateSupport Historic Eden Cemetery - Let's Preserve its HistorySt. Lucie County's Statement Quoted in TC Palm's Eden Cemetery Article
Brandon WestonUnited States
Oct 27, 2025

The information and opinions in this update are shared in good faith and based on public records. I do not claim that every legal or historical detail is exact, and there may be errors or interpretations that differ from official sources. My goal is to raise awareness and create discussion about the condition of Eden Cemetery and what can be done about it. The information in this petition is not intended to provide legal conclusions.     The TCPalm article brought some attention to the cemetery and recognized it as one of the notable abandoned, historically significant cemeteries on the Treasure Coast. It mentions that Florida law authorizes local governments to maintain and secure abandoned cemeterys, but it does not specify which agency is  responsible or what happens if that authority is not used.                                                                      Here is St. Lucie County's statement on the Eden Cemetery:                                                                      "Eden Cemetery presents a complex situation due to its age and unclear ownership."  "County staff are reviewing historical and property records to determine the site's legal status." "The county is considering logistics, liability, and any long-term obligations or precedents such action could create." "The county will determine the appropriate steps."             Well, I have to say they covered every angle they could think of with that statement. It sounds thorough, but when you look closer, it really just creates the appearance of progress. 1. "Eden Cemetery presents a complex situation due to its age and unclear ownership." This language makes the cemetery issue sound uncertain or complicated. "Unclear ownership" is misleading. The reality is, under Florida law (497.284), once a cemetery has been abandoned for six months, the county already has the authority to act, and the county's responsibility under Florida law is not dependent on who owns the land. The parcel is listed in county records as "Eden Cemetery,"  meaning it is recognized in official documentation as a cemetery. 2. "Reviewing historical and property records." This statement gives the appearance of action but functions more as a stall. The cemetery's history and location are already established in St. Lucie County's own Historic Resources Survey ID-8SL1634,  3. "Considering  logistics." Sounds like they are being careful and responsible, but really looking for a reason to hold off. Logistics is not a problem, Florida law already tells them exactly what to do once a cemetery is found to be abandoned. 4. "Liability." is another one to throw in there to sound cautious, but the Florida law already protects the county when they are doing their job in good faith. They can not be sued for following the law. 5. "Long-term obligations or precedents."  Most common reason given to justify inaction. It has been addressed and confirmed that counties may act without creating ongoing financial obligations or setting precedent for other properties. 6. "The county will determine the appropriate steps" This statement is misleading. Florida law determined the appropriate steps to take with a parcel that has been recognized and abandoned for more than six months. If the county continues to delay this issue, the State of Florida could step in and open an investigation through the Division of Historical Resources or Department of Financial Services. The State would request county records, inspect the site, confirm its abandoned status, and ask the county to secure and maintain the cemetery. This would remove local discretion entirely and place the matter under state control. This is an opportunity for St. Lucie County to take voluntary action, acknowledging and maintaining Eden Cemetery. Acting now would show respect for local history and demonstrate compliance with Florida law.      This update on the St. Lucie County's statement on the Eden Cemetery is for public awareness, not for legal advice or interpretation.

Copy link
WhatsApp
Facebook
Nextdoor
Email
X