STOP the 180 FT Cell Tower
STOP the 180 FT Cell Tower
The Issue
OPPOSITION TO SPECIAL USE PERMIT APPLICATION SUPMAJ-2025000029
Proposed 180-Foot Monopole Cell Tower — St. Thomas Island Parkway, St. Johns County, Florida
We, the undersigned residents, property owners, and stakeholders of the community surrounding St. Thomas Island Parkway, respectfully oppose Special Use Permit Application SUPMAJ-2025000029. The application, filed by NexTower Development Group II, LLC with Verizon, seeks to construct a 175-foot monopole antenna tower with a 5-foot appurtenance (180 feet total) on a 6,400-square-foot leased portion of a 153.7-acre tract owned by White’s Ford Timber, LLC, north of St. Thomas Island Parkway. Established residential development lies directly across the roadway.
We base our opposition on specific, fact-based grounds, and we do not raise radio-frequency or health concerns, which we understand are a federal matter.
Grounds for Opposition
• It is incompatible with our residential community. A 180-foot industrial monopole would tower over established single-family neighborhoods designated Residential-B and Residential-C. The applicant’s own photo simulations show it rising above the treeline from nearby homes, and the trees now screening it are a planted-pine timber crop subject to harvest. St. Johns County recently denied a comparable 170-foot tower in St. Augustine Shores (5–0) on these very grounds — a case argued by the same attorney representing this applicant, where the tower was set even farther from homes than here.
• Studies link tower proximity to lower home values. Peer-reviewed research in The Appraisal Journal (Bond and Wang 2005; Bond 2007, a Florida study) associates close proximity to a cell tower with reduced residential values — by as much as roughly 20% for the nearest homes, diminishing with distance. Residents are retaining a licensed appraiser to quantify the impact here.
• The applicant has not looked for a less-intrusive site. The application contains no genuine collocation or alternative-site analysis — required under the County’s tower rules (LDC §§ 2.03.26, 6.08.12) — showing that no existing tower can serve the need or that the area cannot be served from outside our neighborhood. Verizon’s own materials list several existing towers nearby.
• The landowner controls ample alternative land. Per County and State records, the site owner, White’s Ford Timber, LLC, is the same entity — through The Hutson Companies — that owns and develops the entire SilverLeaf community (planned for about 16,300 homes). There is no demonstrated reason this tower must sit at the edge of existing homes when the same developer controls vast acreage farther away.
• Our community has only one road in and out. Tower construction — cranes, drill rigs, and dozens of concrete and flatbed truck trips — would funnel onto that single access road, disrupting daily traffic and potentially impeding fire, EMS, and hurricane-evacuation access, with no alternative route. The application includes no construction traffic or emergency-access plan.
• It will get noisier over time. The equipment at the base of the tower needs constant cooling, and these sites run a backup generator for testing and outages. The tower is engineered for four carrier platforms, but only Verizon is proposed now; as more carriers are added — as on the applicant’s other towers — the noise next to homes and the adjacent wetlands grows. The application includes no noise study or equipment specifications.
• It is a collapse risk that has not been verified. The 180-foot tower is designed to a 128 mph wind in a hurricane-prone region; its foundation rests on “presumptive,” untested soil with no geotechnical report; and the engineering is marked “NOT FOR CONSTRUCTION.” The applicant’s 40-foot “fall zone” is a fraction of the tower’s height — a failure or storm debris could reach the property line and the community’s only road.
• The application is also incomplete in other respects. There is no wetlands jurisdictional determination or FDEP / Army Corps permit despite wetlands flagged next to the access easement, and no written Comprehensive Plan consistency analysis has been provided.
Therefore, We Respectfully Petition the County to:
• Deny the application as incompatible with the established residential character of the area, consistent with the County’s recent denials of comparable towers.
• Require a genuine collocation and alternative-site analysis — including the extensive land the landowner controls within SilverLeaf — before any approval.
• Require final, signed-and-sealed engineering, a site-specific geotechnical report, and certification of the tower’s failure mode and collapse margins (under hurricane winds and full four-carrier loading), plus the required wetlands determinations and a written Comprehensive Plan consistency analysis.
• Weigh the community’s single point of access against approval and require a construction traffic management and emergency-access plan keeping that road open during construction.
• Require a noise study and full equipment/generator specifications addressing both residential and adjacent-wetland impacts and the cumulative noise of a fully co-located four-carrier tower.
• Confirm 180 feet AGL as the binding maximum height of the completed structure if any approval is granted.

120
The Issue
OPPOSITION TO SPECIAL USE PERMIT APPLICATION SUPMAJ-2025000029
Proposed 180-Foot Monopole Cell Tower — St. Thomas Island Parkway, St. Johns County, Florida
We, the undersigned residents, property owners, and stakeholders of the community surrounding St. Thomas Island Parkway, respectfully oppose Special Use Permit Application SUPMAJ-2025000029. The application, filed by NexTower Development Group II, LLC with Verizon, seeks to construct a 175-foot monopole antenna tower with a 5-foot appurtenance (180 feet total) on a 6,400-square-foot leased portion of a 153.7-acre tract owned by White’s Ford Timber, LLC, north of St. Thomas Island Parkway. Established residential development lies directly across the roadway.
We base our opposition on specific, fact-based grounds, and we do not raise radio-frequency or health concerns, which we understand are a federal matter.
Grounds for Opposition
• It is incompatible with our residential community. A 180-foot industrial monopole would tower over established single-family neighborhoods designated Residential-B and Residential-C. The applicant’s own photo simulations show it rising above the treeline from nearby homes, and the trees now screening it are a planted-pine timber crop subject to harvest. St. Johns County recently denied a comparable 170-foot tower in St. Augustine Shores (5–0) on these very grounds — a case argued by the same attorney representing this applicant, where the tower was set even farther from homes than here.
• Studies link tower proximity to lower home values. Peer-reviewed research in The Appraisal Journal (Bond and Wang 2005; Bond 2007, a Florida study) associates close proximity to a cell tower with reduced residential values — by as much as roughly 20% for the nearest homes, diminishing with distance. Residents are retaining a licensed appraiser to quantify the impact here.
• The applicant has not looked for a less-intrusive site. The application contains no genuine collocation or alternative-site analysis — required under the County’s tower rules (LDC §§ 2.03.26, 6.08.12) — showing that no existing tower can serve the need or that the area cannot be served from outside our neighborhood. Verizon’s own materials list several existing towers nearby.
• The landowner controls ample alternative land. Per County and State records, the site owner, White’s Ford Timber, LLC, is the same entity — through The Hutson Companies — that owns and develops the entire SilverLeaf community (planned for about 16,300 homes). There is no demonstrated reason this tower must sit at the edge of existing homes when the same developer controls vast acreage farther away.
• Our community has only one road in and out. Tower construction — cranes, drill rigs, and dozens of concrete and flatbed truck trips — would funnel onto that single access road, disrupting daily traffic and potentially impeding fire, EMS, and hurricane-evacuation access, with no alternative route. The application includes no construction traffic or emergency-access plan.
• It will get noisier over time. The equipment at the base of the tower needs constant cooling, and these sites run a backup generator for testing and outages. The tower is engineered for four carrier platforms, but only Verizon is proposed now; as more carriers are added — as on the applicant’s other towers — the noise next to homes and the adjacent wetlands grows. The application includes no noise study or equipment specifications.
• It is a collapse risk that has not been verified. The 180-foot tower is designed to a 128 mph wind in a hurricane-prone region; its foundation rests on “presumptive,” untested soil with no geotechnical report; and the engineering is marked “NOT FOR CONSTRUCTION.” The applicant’s 40-foot “fall zone” is a fraction of the tower’s height — a failure or storm debris could reach the property line and the community’s only road.
• The application is also incomplete in other respects. There is no wetlands jurisdictional determination or FDEP / Army Corps permit despite wetlands flagged next to the access easement, and no written Comprehensive Plan consistency analysis has been provided.
Therefore, We Respectfully Petition the County to:
• Deny the application as incompatible with the established residential character of the area, consistent with the County’s recent denials of comparable towers.
• Require a genuine collocation and alternative-site analysis — including the extensive land the landowner controls within SilverLeaf — before any approval.
• Require final, signed-and-sealed engineering, a site-specific geotechnical report, and certification of the tower’s failure mode and collapse margins (under hurricane winds and full four-carrier loading), plus the required wetlands determinations and a written Comprehensive Plan consistency analysis.
• Weigh the community’s single point of access against approval and require a construction traffic management and emergency-access plan keeping that road open during construction.
• Require a noise study and full equipment/generator specifications addressing both residential and adjacent-wetland impacts and the cumulative noise of a fully co-located four-carrier tower.
• Confirm 180 feet AGL as the binding maximum height of the completed structure if any approval is granted.

The Decision Makers






Supporter Voices
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on June 28, 2026