Stop Simulated Trauma Intruder Drills in PUSD Schools

268

Let’s get to 500 signatures!
Petitions with 1,000+ supporters are 5x more likely to win!

The Issue

This petition has been created to help instigate change to the PUSD lockdown drill protocols, so as to not ever have the incident described below happen again.


THE INCIDENT

  • On the morning of November 9th, 2022, a lockdown drill was conducted at Eliot Arts Middle School, in Pasadena. Lockdowns can be triggered due to police action in the neighborhood, a potentially violent intruder, online threats, or other perceived immediate dangers.
  • In this case, the students were deliberately NOT told it was drill, in order to simulate the actual trauma of that potential situation, and according the school, ‘make sure they take it seriously’, and 'pressure test the system'.
  • This is a school that within the past year had a threat of gun violence on campus, and many students stayed home from school for a day or two.
  • A large number of teachers working the day of the incident were also unaware it was a drill. They were given a calendar at the beginning of the year with the drill dates, and this was assumed to be enough communication for them to know this was happening. There are reports of teachers telling the students that 'they would die for them' etc, unaware that it was a simulated situation.
  • The parents were not told there was going to be a drill.
  • Middle schoolers have phones, and many parents received extremely distressing messages from their children with cries for help. Saying that they were in lock down, hiding under their desks... that they could 'hear someone in the out there', and were 'very scared'.
  • Someone was going through the school rattling the doors. Potentially to make sure they were locked? You can only imagine how terrifying that was for those who were intentionally put under the impression this was a real situation, and potentially thinking that someone threatening was on the school grounds with a weapon.
  • A number of parents experienced 10 minutes of hell, dropped everything, walked out of meetings, left clients, and their jobs, and made their way towards the school ready to do whatever it took to save their kids, only to find out it wasn’t real.
  • But the trauma that was caused was extremely real.
  • The principle was not even present on the property when the drill was conducted. And exactly as it was happening she was sending out a benign fundraising email to the school community about wreaths and Christmas trees.
  • Some kids were pulled out of school for the day.
  • The teachers had to somehow transition the students from that disruptive and disturbing situation back into a regular work day.
  • Many parents reached out to the school via phone or email, and if answered at all, their concerns were completely dismissed and told, in an extremely condescending manner, that this was just routine. Zero accountability has yet been taken by anyone.
  • This has led to a deep lack of trust in the school. The serious breakdown of communication, as well as the level of disregard for the mental and emotional well-being of the community that has been demonstrated during, and after this drill is unfathomable in this day and age, when sadly, these threats are a real and daily presence in this country.
  • Other parents reached out to PUSD directly, who are now doing an investigation, but stated it was not their policy to tell the students when a lockdown was just a simulation. In fact there is no public lock down drill policy in place for this type of intruder threat on the school grounds.
  • While practicing emergency procedures can be important, deliberately simulating a real threat without telling the students it’s not real, so that they 'take it seriously’, and they can 'pressure test their system' clearly has far reaching negative consequences and not only demonstrates an extreme lack of foresight & compassion, but is potentially very dangerous.
  • There is potential for parents to show up at the school with guns, ready to do what it takes to save their kids. Also under these conditions kids will often end up jumping out windows. An:d this did take place in at least one classroom, where panicked students were climbing out the second story windows onto the balcony to hide outside. 
  • This incident has obviously had a huge impact on many kids, parents, and staff's mental and emotional health, and in order for healing to take place, and trust to be re-established, the leadership of the school needs to make a public apology to the school community, take accountability for all mental & emotional damage caused, and offer counseling and support to those who need it.  

 

A SAFE APPROACH

The following resource has been offered by a family therapist, and valued member of the school community, on how to mitigate the psychological effects of a lockdown, from the National Association of School Psychologists.

Resource:  Mitigating Psychological Effects of Lockdowns

Here are a couple of highlights ...

" Always announce lockdown drills. The message should say something such as, “This is an emergency drill, not an actual emergency. This is a drill. We are now practicing how to keep safe in the event of an emergency. This is a drill.”

" Ensure that a school administrator is present during a lockdown drill." 

"Communicate clearly during the lockdown whether or not there is imminent danger to the school. Conveying factual information as quickly as possible will minimize anxiety and fear."

"Communicate clearly with families via a pre-established system and social media as appropriate. As soon as possible, reassure families that their children are safe. Having two types of Lockdown responses will help with this."

 

THE REQUESTED RESULTS

1) This incident needs to be addressed and dealt with in a serious manner by Pasadena Unified School District, in the hope that this will help bring positive change to the larger American school system. We, as parents, grandparents, kids, teachers, experienced professionals, and human beings who care about the welfare of others, would like to see responsibility taken for the trauma caused, and counseling offered to anyone that feels they need it. 

2) Most importantly, we call for a safe Pasadena Unified School District lockdown drill policy to be created. We must put in place a structured, calm and clearly communicated system for practicing these emergency procedures, for the sake of the whole community’s mental and emotional well being. 

 

Please sign this petition to have accountability taken for the trauma inflicted. And to advocate for a safe protocol to be created, with respect to lock down drills within Pasadena Unified School District, reflecting the approach set forth by the National Association of School Psychologists, as in the article linked above. 

 

Footnotes:

1) From the document ‘Best Practice Considerations For Armed Assailant Drills in Schools’ taken from the California Department of Education website…

“Potential lawsuits… The manner in which some armed assailant drills (e.g., unannounced) have been conducted in the workplace has led to lawsuits imposed on employers due to the psychological and physical harm sustained by participants (Frosch, 2014; Sawchuk, 2020). Schools need to determine to what extent sensorial armed assailant drills are even necessary. If sensorial drills are to be conducted, they need to be carefully constructed to avoid physical and psychological harm. Regardless of the projected benefits and perceived concerns, the fact remains that there is a lack of empirical research to support the use of sensorial armed assailant drills with students and/or staff in schools. Schools that decide to conduct a drill should use a multidisciplinary safety team (including parents) that educates and trains all participants in relevant curricula and protocols. With careful planning, data collection, and continual review of these programs, schools can begin to develop an approach that minimizes negative effects and improves preparedness.”

Reference:  Best Practice Considerations for Armed Assailant Drills in Schools

2) There are no official policies posted on the PUSD website concerning active shooter drills and procedures. It would be listed in article 3 under  “Emergencies and Disaster Preparedness Plan 3516” Which contains fire drills, bomb threats etc. in the Index of PUSD Policies 

Reference: PUSD Policies, Regulations & Bylaws

3) BP 0100 item 6 of the PUSD PHILOSOPHY
“A safe, nurturing environment and positive school climate are necessary for learning, academic achievement, and student development.”

Reference: PUSD Philosophy

4) If you are one of the Eliot parents whose child doesn't know anything about this, it's because they were one of the lucky ones in the classrooms where the intercom wasn't working, and those classes didn't know there was a lockdown. Despite that, and all listed above, at the end of the day, the principal declared the drill a major success. 

 

The Decision Makers

Eliot Arts Magnet
Principal : Dr Scheckel
Responded
“Dear All, Thank you for letting us know your thoughts and feedback on our monthly drill procedures. We absolutely can always make improvements to our safety protocols. In reviewing some of the comments and concerns shared in this petition, and other communication from parents, I am currently reviewing the opportunities for improvement with my team. It is such a fine line between being prepared and not eliciting fear in our students. As a school leader, I so wish this were not a reality of our times, but unfortunately this is where we are. If you would like to know more about our comprehensive school wide safety plan or would like to have a productive discussion on how to further improve our systems, please join us at our monthly PT(S)A, School Site Council, ELAC, or AAPC meetings. Our next meeting is Tuesday, January 10 @ 6pm at Altadena Arts Magnet. You may also always contact me directly at the school, 626-396-5680 or by email at scheckel.benita@pusd.us I wish everyone a pleasant weekend. Dr. Benita Scheckel Principal of Altadena Eliot Arts Magnet PreK-8 School”
Pasadena Unified School District.

Petition Updates