Justice for Sawyer and family

Petition Closed

This petition had 1,979 supporters

The Issue

UPDATE: ON 2-16-21 judge Masson granted my petition for an emergency PFA against this man for sawyer and I. On 2-23-21, we have a court hearing to show our evidence and let the defendant defend himself. This day will determine if the PFA will stay in place permanently. This is one day before sawyers daddy in heaven death anniversary. This would truly be the ultimate victory as I know Austin wouldn’t want our son around the man that caused so much anguish in his life. This is a tiny step in the right direction. I will never give up on my baby. 


First and foremost, we want an internal investigation done on the city of st marys police department. We have now had several well known patrons of our community come forward with their stories. Some of these officers have already saw our posts and say “I don’t care what they think” well sir, you work for US. We don’t work for you. You are a PUBLIC SERVANT. And I think you know just as much as I know, SMPD is corrupt. In my opinion of course. I have friends that have also been involved with an officer. When victims like this are coming forward, I’d be afraid too.

Hi, my name is Michelle Aiello. My husband is Andy and together we have 5 children. Minus one. We lost our 4 month old son on 12/14/2020, due to sids. It has been devastating. For those of you that know us, know for the last 5 years my family and I have been a target (our opinion)of the police in st marys, Pennsylvania. My husband adopted our 5 year old, Sawyer after his biological father, Austin tragically passed away in a car accident. After this happened, Austin’s father who was also employed by the St Marys area police department, filed for custody of Sawyer and tried to get 50/50 custody. Falsely claiming to the courts that he had him for 90 consecutive days. At this time, we were struggling very bad financially. He knew that. And made a comment telling me “remember who I work for” which I still have all the messages for proof. So we went to court, he tried to get partial custody but didn’t. We offered every other weekend because we were afraid and had no attorney during this proceeding. His attorney, whom acted like he was trying to help us, tricked us into signing something we had no idea about. And his attorney, who is now our DA, LIED to us about what we were signing! The reason he filed in the first place was because we wouldn’t let Sawyer go to his house whenever he asked for him. He wanted him EVERY DAY. We were trying to build a life and normal family for our children. He didn’t like that. Austin also didn’t have a relationship with his father (Austin has told this to me personally and has told his mother along with many other people) because he was just plain rotten. His own wife, has personally told me that he’s gotten very “nasty” with her and he has very serious anger issues. He didn’t like the choices Austin made and mentally abused (again I have this in letters from Austin) him throughout his childhood. Which I also have proof of. I have Austin’s journal that he used to write in when he was alive. And it honestly is the most heartbreaking thing I have ever read. Austin considered his step dad Chris, his father more than his blood father. The stories he told me about his childhood were awful and I never believed that it was as bad as he said it was, until I started living the very same life. Sawyer started getting really upset a few months into the visitation. He begged, screamed, kicked and cried to not go with his grandfather. I have videos of his grandfather ripping him out of our car using force that actually left bruises on his arms. Sawyer was hitting him. Screaming telling him he didn’t want to go and he didn’t like him. You’d think any normal grandparent wouldn’t force a child to go with them but this man did it with a smile on his face. It was disturbing. Sawyers behavior progressively got worse over the next few months. We had to rip his little fingers off of our door, just to get him out of the house. He’d come home so upset and not even speak to us for the next two days. There was a particular visit that Sawyer came home with a swollen, bloody face. No one called us to tell us what happened. So we only found out when we picked him up. I took him to his doctor and his doctor felt very uncomfortable and reported it to CPS. CPS came and saw what happened to sawyer. She told me his injuries weren’t severe enough for anything to be done. So we went to a forensic psychiatrist, that specializes in children. She diagnosed sawyer, at the time he was 3, with trauma, anxiety and an adjustment disorder. She told me I needed to take action and believed Sawyer shouldn’t go back there again. She said she would write a recommendation to the court a well stating this.  Grandfather ended up filing contempt charges because we refused to send sawyer back without knowing why he was so terrified of this man. At this hearing, he asked the judge to order us to give him Sawyers psychiatrist name. Once again, afraid and in fear of being put in jail we did. So the day I went down to the psychiatrist to get the letter for court, she started crying and said she wouldn’t write it anymore because she was afraid. This was days after grandfather got her contact info. We believe she was threatened. So, we sadly had to resume visits. After this, things got bad. Really bad. Because he was a cop, he could do things to my family and get away with it. We were constantly followed. Everywhere we went. One day I was pulling into a gas station and saw him driving the cop car. I knew then I was screwed. So I came out of the store and sure as hell, there was a cop sitting across the road. But it wasn’t him. He was covering his ass. I ended up being pulled over for not using my signal in the parking lot. Which I don’t believe is a valid reason. I called this cop out and he ended up letting me go. I told him I knew what was going on and I’m sick of it. But, it gets worse. Two years ago, grandfather filed WIRETAPPING charges against us for a video that was recorded of sawyer screaming he didn’t want to go with him. The video was completely black. Grandfathers wife claimed they could hear her talking in the background while she was OUTSIDE of our home. Talking about potty training. These are felony charges. So, he had one of his cop buddies, officer smith file charges against us. In the report it says that grandfather contacted him because he believed this was an issue. They didn’t even make these guys go to the station to file a report like a normal case! And to top it off, grandfather wasn’t ever here that day! We get a knock on the door one evening and it’s a detective with a shotty search warrant to take all of our electronic devices in our home. Which, they already had the video on grandfather’s phone so why did they need ours too? They never took his phone in for evidence but took ours. This detective scared us into thinking we had to give him the password for all devices or we’d be in trouble. Then he asks, “so what am I gonna find in here? Drugs or anything illegal?” Now why would he ask that? Well because grandfather thought they’d find something juicy. Trooper Reiner also told us only a cop who was experienced and wanted to hurt someone, would even think about filing these charges. He said he’d never heard of anything like this. He told us to tread carefully. Because it seemed to him this man was out to get us. Then proceeds to tell us that if we ever brought any of this up in court, he’d plead the 5th. So basically he’d lie. He asked if he could record our conversation and we said no. That’s when we saw the true side of the cops. But guess what, they found NOTHING. Trooper Reiner, who mysteriously quit working up here after all of this, point blank told us this man is out to get you. You need to be careful and that he’s NEVER heard of someone being charged for something so stupid like this. I actually called the police and asked them if I could press charges on someone for this same thing and they laughed and said no way. It would never hold up. But it gets worse. While this is all going on, we were followed everywhere. My life was threatened by this man. The cops drove by our house several times a week. I called the FBI, DOJ, everywhere I could think of and still, nothing was done. We finally got lawyers from out of town. Good lawyers. One of them was in the top 10’in the nation! At our criminal hearing, which my lawyer recorded, they had to stop and ask grandfather if he was okay to proceed because he seemed to be under the influence of something. The judge literally said nothing about this. They also asked the judge why grandfather still had his police issued phone bc it contained evidence to our cases again, they blew it off. He forgot I was Sawyers mother. The woman claiming she was maliciously recorded, admitted that she saw nothing in anyone’s hand that day. But because trooper Reiner lied and said Andy admitted to it, they bound the charges over to court. Our lawyers were mind blown. They said this is the most corrupt county they’ve ever dealt with. The judge and the DA ended up recusing themselves. They knew what was going on and wanted no part of it. Then all of a sudden “grandfather” takes an early retirement. We knew something was up. Once again, we didn’t have the money to keep our lawyers. They were expensive. Because grandfather filed both of these cases within months of each other. He told me “you’ll run out of money before I do. And it doesn’t matter what sawyer wants. It matters what the judge says.” That made me sick. So once again, we had to plea to something we didn’t do. Neither of us had criminal records. And we were fined over $3,000. And put on probation. During this entire thing, Sawyer still had to go there. We have all the videos of him telling his grandfather how much he hated him and he was afraid of him. One of grandfather’s family members reached out to me and confirmed everything I believed was going on. He got in trouble at work and was given the option to retire early or get fired. So he retired. Would you or I be given that option if for instance, we were caught under the influence while at work driving around and doing abnormal things? He thinks we don’t know what happened, but, we do. This family member told us how badly Sawyer was treated at grandfather’s house. How grandfather almost burned the house down, almost crashed his car numerous times because he was abusing some kind of substance.(i also have proof of these messages) Which we knew because at exchanges, he’d slur his speech and sway as he walked. And we had to watch him drive away, hoping our baby would come home. Just as he did in court. We’ve had to call the police on him on two different occasions for trying to fight us. Psychically, in front of our child.  Another super disturbing thing that I was there when it happened, When sawyer was born Austin and I were going to eat. We got pulled over. He had a loaded 22 pistols and weed in the car. He had no license to carry. He should of been thrown in jail right then. But guess what? He told him his dad was a cop and this cop called Austin’s dad and then let us go. No charges and he got the gun back! This cop spontaneously moved to Florida then. I paid for that gun, and now this man has it. And he’s unstable and expects me to let my son go in his home. In August of 2020, we had our son Nash who is now dead. My water broke a month early. So, we’re on our way to get my moms car and drop the kids off with her so we can go to the hospital. We get not even a mile away from our home and get pulled over. Not for speeding or doing anything wrong, they claimed it was just a random plate run. Well, what we didn’t know is that our registration was suspended because when we switched insurance companies it wasn’t reported to penndot. We didn’t know we had to do that. So because Nash came a month early, we were obviously unprepared for everything. I had all of our bills set up on auto pay for Mondays. My husband got paid on Thursdays so it just worked out that way. The month before this, I couldn’t pay the entire car insurance payment so they let us pay half and we would just have to pay the other half added on to next months bill. Well, when I paid it, I forgot about the extra $50. So it lapsed. So now we were dealing with having lapsed insurance. Officer klender had a field day with us. We pulled over into a empty parking lot (satterlees) when we were pulled over. The other officer that was with this one was actually a good friend of Andy’s at one point in time. We don’t consider him a good friend anymore. He’s just as bad as the other one. But he actually was telling klender to give us a break. So Officer Klender was shining his flashlight in our kids eyes this entire time and they were terrified. They were screaming and crying and my water was broke and I was losing a lot of fluid. Fluid that my baby needed to survive. So we asked the officer if we can just drive to get a different car and get to the hospital and he told us no. He said he was going to tow our car away bc we were in a tow away zone. We were less than a mile from our home. So in front of officer Klender, I went online and paid the remaining balance on our insurance in front of him. And he said OK I will let you guys drive home but I’m taking your license plate. The other officer told him you don’t need to take their license plate it will end up costing them more money and it’ll take a while for them to get it back. And officer Klender said he didn’t care and that he was still taking it. I was supposed to have Nash naturally but because we got pulled over which took a total of three hours my water had been broken for two hours too long which made it too dangerous to let me be in labor any longer. On top of Nash already being a month early. This was an emergency situation. We weren’t just out driving around. We were trying to get to the hospital to have our baby. So we get to the hospital and I ended up having a very Trumatic C-section. Anything that could’ve went wrong did go wrong. Two days later we had to pay over $1000 to the state to get everything on our car fixed so we were able to drive it. Does anyone truly believe we’d let things go to the point of paying over $1k just bc of our car insurance? Our car is the only car that fits our entire family so we need it. For a little while we didn’t hear anything until we got papers in the mail and they said and he was being charged with driving without insurance and without registration which with the type of drivers license he has that would mean he would lose his job if he was charged and convicted with these things. And this guy knew this. My husband called down to the station and asked klender if he could charge him with something that would not make him lose his job. He is our only income. Our provider. And klender tells him “why do you think just bc what you went through you deserve a break.” He was absolutely awful. I ended up leaving a review on the police website about this night. And two months later the chief of police sent me a message on Facebook asking me to call him. So I called him and he tried to convince me that I had already spoken with him on the phone about the situation and that he already looked into it and he knows just as much as I know that’s a lie. I never spoke to chief Nicklas until yesterday when I called. He said he didn’t see anything wrong with the traffic stop because everything we were pulled over for was technically things that someone could be pulled over for. And it further proved to me that it had been talked about by them before. Why would they talk about it if they thought they did nothing wrong? But that’s not the point of this, the point is I was in labor and my baby was coming a month early and this cop treated us so poorly and made us wait an additional three hours to go to the hospital in turn, causing me to have an emergency C-section. I know people that have been caught with drugs and have been let go with a warning that have driven a car completely illegally and to this day still drive it and never get in trouble. We are a normal family just trying to raise our kids. So now, we have another court hearing in April for this. On the day of our sons funeral, we received a letter from grandfather’s attorney. Threatening us. We haven’t been sending Sawyer because grandfather suggested because of covid he shouldn’t go. But during this time is when his family member, who lived with him, came forward and told me the awful things Sawyer had to endure while at his house. I have some pretty disgusting photos and videos of just how tormented and tortured sawyer was by this man. To this day, if he sees him he screams, he cries. This man has also told me I have no business being a mother or part of society. In other words, telling me my life shouldn’t exist. Sawyer begs to not see him. And If Austin was alive, this would have NEVER happened. Austin’s dad had him trespassed from his home three days before he died. He HID sawyer from him so he couldn’t see him. What kind of father is that? All because his son smoked weed? I also want to add that grandfather has no relationship with his own mother. Or most of his family at that. He has been charged with simple assault, terroristic threats, endangering another person and still was able to be a cop. How crooked is that? Criminals hiding behind a badge. It’s scary. At one of our exchanges, the judge that granted him visitation was actually parked beside him! That was no coincidence! He told Andy, The man who is raising sawyer, that he isn’t his dad and his dad is dead. IN FRONT OF SAWYER! Sawyer used to wake up on the weekends crying because he knew what it meant. He knew he’d have to go. And being a parent, it breaks your heart when your child is telling you they’re being hurt but no one will do anything. It’s now been almost a year since Sawyer has seen him. Grandfather FaceTimed him once and sawyer walked away crying and told me “why would you do that to me?” Everyone that knows this man, knows how evil he is. (My opinion) Everyone I’ve talked to anyway. How corrupt our department is. And what’s ironic is there was a huge investigation into the smpd years ago for corruption and bad behavior by the police. We want justice for our son and for our family. We have been drug through the dirt all because of this man. This man has worked with all of the judges we have to go in front of. So they’re all in kahoots with each other. We know how things work. We want these people to be held responsible! Not for just us but for terrorizing our son! Those 3 hours klender wasted time on, took away my chance to have a natural birth. And now my baby is dead. PLEASE HELP US! Help us get justice for our family and to stop the corruption that is taking place in our county. We need you guys now more than ever. I refuse to lose another child. All because Austin’s dad is feeling the guilt of not trying to fix his relationship with his son before he died.(my opinion) He’s trying to make sawyer into Austin. He wants a second chance. It’s sick and twisted. And his own family members have said this! They have called sawyer Austin! We specifically asked them to not tell him about Austin yet. He’s too little. We want him to have a shot at a good life. Not a childhood of horror and heartbreak. Sawyer won’t even call this man grandpa! And yells at us if we do. Please share this. Help us get justice in this unjust system we are dealing with. Nothing will change if we don’t stand up! I will be creating a Facebook group showing these videos. Messages. Pictures. I have a tiktok account that is pretty big and tells our story. I encourage all of you to check it out. This is real. And they are ruining our family. Just because they wear a badge, doesn’t make them good people. Look what is going on now. It’s police like this that give the good ones a bad name. It’s a shame! I have contacted lawyers and they have told us we do we have a good case. And through hell or high water, we will prevail and show the TRUTH! Anyone who truly knew Austin, knows his father was not a big part of his life. When he was younger and FORCED to go with him, that is the only time they ever had a relationship. Ask his dad for pictures of them together in Austin’s late teen/adult life. There are none. Besides the day sawyer was born. Locally, you all know who this man is. And I know ALOT of you were also victimized by him. I’m asking for anyone that has had any issues with this department and court system to message me. You will remain ANONYMOUS. I will NOT put anyone’s name out there. I know in my heart what is worth fighting for. We took charges that we weren’t even guilty of. We also want the WITETAPPING case to investigated. I don’t care if it’s closed! These people LIED IN COURT! So this isn’t about stopping the fines and charges. It’s about MAKING A CHANGE!

I know we are NOT above the law. We don’t expect special treatment. But we also don’t deserve to keep being harassed for something that happened years ago! The chief was supposed to call me today 1-18-21. But I have yet to get a call. I know that call will never come. This is why everyone is against the police right now. Because they are taking things way too far. It’s time to end this. These expressions and views are my opinions based on how my family has been treated. It’s time to stand up. 

UPDATE: The chief never called me back. Further proving my point that this is exactly what is going on. 
UPDATE: 1-20-21. A man by the name of Shawn Miller has now started harassing us for posting this petition. He said I was a wannabe mother and wife. This is Sawyers grandfather’s brother. I knew this day would come, but it’s starting. These people are scary people and will stop at nothing to destroy anything in the way of what they want. I know this will only get worse and I want you all to know, if you don’t see any updates from me for more than a few days, something has happened. I live in fear every day that one of these people will come to my home or see me out somewhere and hurt me. All because I’m standing up for my son. Although I knew this was coming, it still scares me. But, I will never back down. Thank you all for your support. We are so grateful that people are finally taking a stand with us! 

Dawn DPetition Starter

The Decision Makers

Elk county court house
St Marys Area City Police

Petition Updates