

SELL THE TEAM: Pittsburgh Deserves Better Than Bob Nutting
The Issue
Enough is enough.
For decades, Pittsburgh Pirates fans have been loyal to a fault. We have supported this team through losing seasons, rebuilds that never end, and constant excuses. In return, we are given one of the cheapest, least competitive operations in Major League Baseball.
This is not rebuilding.
This is ownership failure.
The Numbers Don’t Lie
The Pittsburgh Pirates routinely rank in the bottom 5 in MLB payroll
In multiple seasons, the team payroll has sat tens of millions of dollars below the league average
At times, the Pirates have spent less than half of what top MLB teams spend on payroll
Despite this, the Pirates consistently receive revenue-sharing funds intended to promote competitive balance
Revenue sharing exists to help teams compete — not to bankroll permanent losing while fans are told to be patient.
When Individual Superstars Cost More Than an Entire Franchise
MLB has entered an era where individual superstars are signing contracts worth hundreds of millions of dollars.
Shohei Ohtani’s historic contract alone is larger than the Pittsburgh Pirates’ entire team payroll in some recent seasons. If projected or future mega-deals for elite players like Kyle Tucker reach their expected levels, they would similarly rival or exceed what the Pirates spend on an entire roster.
Let that sink in.
One player can cost more than an entire Major League team in Pittsburgh.
That is not competitive balance. That is proof the Pirates are operating far below Major League standards — not because they must, but because ownership chooses to.
Stop Blaming the Market
Pittsburgh is not the problem.
Small markets are not the problem.
Other small-market teams invest, retain talent, and compete. The Pirates do not because Bob Nutting refuses to run this franchise like a serious baseball operation.
Low payrolls are not an accident.
Roster sell-offs are not bad luck.
This is a business model — and the fans are paying for it.
If We Can’t Even Keep Andrew McCutchen, What Are We Doing?
The most damning symbol of this failure is Andrew McCutchen.
A former National League MVP.
The face of a generation of Pirates baseball.
A leader who embodied Pittsburgh and wanted to be here.
Yet even Andrew McCutchen was never treated like a true priority.
If this franchise cannot fully commit — financially or symbolically — to the most iconic player it has had in decades, it sends a clear message:
Winning doesn’t matter. Loyalty doesn’t matter. Legacy doesn’t matter.
Rob Manfred’s Failure to Act
This situation exists not just because of ownership, but because MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred has allowed it to continue.
Under Manfred’s leadership, teams like the Pittsburgh Pirates have been permitted to:
Collect revenue-sharing money year after year
Maintain bottom-tier payrolls with no accountability
Field non-competitive rosters without consequence
Revenue sharing was designed to promote parity — not to enable profit-first ownership and intentional losing. By failing to enforce standards or demand reinvestment, Rob Manfred has allowed competitive neglect to become an accepted business strategy.
This is not only an ownership failure.
This is a league leadership failure.
Fans Are Done Being Patient
Pirates fans are tired of:
Watching homegrown talent leave
Being told payroll “doesn’t matter” while losses pile up
Supporting a team that refuses to support itself
Pittsburgh is a proud baseball city. This franchise belongs to the fans — not to an owner content with the bare minimum.
Our Demand Is Simple
MLB must hold Pirates ownership accountable
Revenue-sharing funds must be tied to actual competitiveness
Bob Nutting must sell the Pittsburgh Pirates to an owner committed to winning
Baseball is better when the Pirates matter.
Pittsburgh deserves a team that actually tries.
SELL. THE. TEAM.
Sign this petition if you’re done with excuses, done with intentional losing, and done with Bob Nutting.
1
The Issue
Enough is enough.
For decades, Pittsburgh Pirates fans have been loyal to a fault. We have supported this team through losing seasons, rebuilds that never end, and constant excuses. In return, we are given one of the cheapest, least competitive operations in Major League Baseball.
This is not rebuilding.
This is ownership failure.
The Numbers Don’t Lie
The Pittsburgh Pirates routinely rank in the bottom 5 in MLB payroll
In multiple seasons, the team payroll has sat tens of millions of dollars below the league average
At times, the Pirates have spent less than half of what top MLB teams spend on payroll
Despite this, the Pirates consistently receive revenue-sharing funds intended to promote competitive balance
Revenue sharing exists to help teams compete — not to bankroll permanent losing while fans are told to be patient.
When Individual Superstars Cost More Than an Entire Franchise
MLB has entered an era where individual superstars are signing contracts worth hundreds of millions of dollars.
Shohei Ohtani’s historic contract alone is larger than the Pittsburgh Pirates’ entire team payroll in some recent seasons. If projected or future mega-deals for elite players like Kyle Tucker reach their expected levels, they would similarly rival or exceed what the Pirates spend on an entire roster.
Let that sink in.
One player can cost more than an entire Major League team in Pittsburgh.
That is not competitive balance. That is proof the Pirates are operating far below Major League standards — not because they must, but because ownership chooses to.
Stop Blaming the Market
Pittsburgh is not the problem.
Small markets are not the problem.
Other small-market teams invest, retain talent, and compete. The Pirates do not because Bob Nutting refuses to run this franchise like a serious baseball operation.
Low payrolls are not an accident.
Roster sell-offs are not bad luck.
This is a business model — and the fans are paying for it.
If We Can’t Even Keep Andrew McCutchen, What Are We Doing?
The most damning symbol of this failure is Andrew McCutchen.
A former National League MVP.
The face of a generation of Pirates baseball.
A leader who embodied Pittsburgh and wanted to be here.
Yet even Andrew McCutchen was never treated like a true priority.
If this franchise cannot fully commit — financially or symbolically — to the most iconic player it has had in decades, it sends a clear message:
Winning doesn’t matter. Loyalty doesn’t matter. Legacy doesn’t matter.
Rob Manfred’s Failure to Act
This situation exists not just because of ownership, but because MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred has allowed it to continue.
Under Manfred’s leadership, teams like the Pittsburgh Pirates have been permitted to:
Collect revenue-sharing money year after year
Maintain bottom-tier payrolls with no accountability
Field non-competitive rosters without consequence
Revenue sharing was designed to promote parity — not to enable profit-first ownership and intentional losing. By failing to enforce standards or demand reinvestment, Rob Manfred has allowed competitive neglect to become an accepted business strategy.
This is not only an ownership failure.
This is a league leadership failure.
Fans Are Done Being Patient
Pirates fans are tired of:
Watching homegrown talent leave
Being told payroll “doesn’t matter” while losses pile up
Supporting a team that refuses to support itself
Pittsburgh is a proud baseball city. This franchise belongs to the fans — not to an owner content with the bare minimum.
Our Demand Is Simple
MLB must hold Pirates ownership accountable
Revenue-sharing funds must be tied to actual competitiveness
Bob Nutting must sell the Pittsburgh Pirates to an owner committed to winning
Baseball is better when the Pirates matter.
Pittsburgh deserves a team that actually tries.
SELL. THE. TEAM.
Sign this petition if you’re done with excuses, done with intentional losing, and done with Bob Nutting.
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on January 29, 2026