RESTORING ACCOUNTABILITY AND INTEGRITY: REFORMING DURHAM CONSTABULARY UK

Petition Closed

This petition had 33 supporters

The Issue

A considerable number of citizens have faced challenges with Durham Constabulary. Unfortunately, a portion of these individuals feel hesitant to voice their experiences due to fears of potential consequences. By affixing your signature here, we are presenting a united front, emphasizing our commitment to addressing these issues together as a collective.

Who is affected?

Numerous upstanding residents of County Durham are directly affected by the dubious practices and disproportionate responses of Durham Constabulary, whether it's within various departments or in public interactions. Those who approach the Professional Complaints Department of Durham Constabulary for resolution are often disheartened by the unethical behaviour they encounter. Notably, Joy Allen's role as Crime Commissioner lacks the independence of an unbiased panel, as highlighted by Councillor Robert Potts, a representative who advocates for an ethical approach benefiting all County Durham residents.

What is at stake?

The consequences of either change or stagnation in this scenario are profound. If these problematic practices persist, the public's trust in Durham Constabulary's commitment to crime prevention, ethics, and justice will erode significantly. The reputation of the organisation, and by extension, the community's overall safety and well-being, is at risk.

Communication Transparency: Durham Constabulary has been criticised for lack of transparency in their communication, especially when responding to queries, requests for information, and complaints from the public. This lack of openness erodes trust and hampers community-police relations.

Response to Complaints: Residents have reported dissatisfaction with how Durham Constabulary handles complaints. Concerns have been raised about the internal investigation process, where officers within the same force investigate their colleagues, leading to perceived bias and lack of impartiality.

Accountability: There is a perception that Durham Constabulary has not taken full responsibility for their actions and decisions. This includes failing to own up to mistakes, mishandling cases, and not holding officers accountable when they are found to be at fault.

Lack of Support for Vulnerable Groups: Some members of the community, particularly vulnerable groups, feel that Durham Constabulary has not adequately supported and protected them. Instances of mishandling cases involving vulnerable individuals, such as elderly or mentally ill residents, have been reported.

Inadequate Training: Concerns have been raised about the training provided to officers, especially in areas related to handling diverse communities, mental health crises, and de-escalation techniques, as well as what legislation actually means. This has resulted in instances where officers' actions escalated situations rather than defusing them.

Community Engagement: Many residents believe that Durham Constabulary has not done enough to engage with the community, listen to their concerns, and actively involve them in decision-making processes related to policing strategies.  Newton Aycliffe "Worry over potential loss of Newton Aycliffe police response" is a clear example of the distrust the public has in Durham Constabulary.

Response Time and Accessibility: There have been complaints about delayed response times to emergency calls and difficulties in reaching out to Durham Constabulary through official channels, which can hinder effective law enforcement and in turn erodes trust.

Ineffective Feedback Mechanisms: The absence of an effective feedback mechanism that accurately reflects public sentiment has led to concerns that the police force is not truly interested in understanding the community's experiences and concerns. Instead there is many cherry picking exercises put into action, and deflates the public's interest and trust.

Culture of Intimidation: Some individuals have reported instances of feeling intimidated or manipulated as well as fearful after filing complaints against Durham Constabulary officers. This perceived culture of intimidation discourages open dialogue and transparency, this can also lead to internal records being manipulated, with a distortion of the truth.

Why is now the time to act?

Immediate action is imperative to rectify this concerning situation. The lack of independence in the complaints process, coupled with the internal resistance to transparency and reform, demands urgent attention.

Numerous dissatisfied members of the public have been affected by flawed investigations, biases, and selective approaches. In some cases, when individuals raise concerns or complaints about the actions of a police force, they can inadvertently be labelled as "persistent complainers" by the police. This term can carry a negative connotation and may lead to their concerns being dismissed or not taken seriously. Additionally, police procedures and actions might be driven by a desire to manage statistics rather than genuinely address the concerns of the public. This can create a cycle of frustration for individuals seeking accountability and resolution.

As evidenced by the remarks of Councillor Robert Potts and the need for an impartial complaints unit, the time has come to address these issues. He highlights a troubling aspect of this process within Durham Constabulary; when a person raises a complaint against a Durham Constabulary officer, the investigation is conducted by another Durham Constabulary officer or staff member. This lack of an independent review raises questions about impartiality.

Councillor Potts points out that even if the complainant appeals the initial decision, the review is carried out by a senior officer within Durham Constabulary. This structure, where officers within the same organisation review each other's actions, appears to lack the impartiality necessary for fair assessments.

Moreover, Councillor Potts underscores the issue of hierarchy. He reveals that if the complainant remains dissatisfied, they can bring their concerns to Joy Allen, who then delegates these complaints to a staff member within her office. Notably, this staff member is a retired senior Durham Constabulary officer. This individual subsequently reviews the findings of the senior Durham Constabulary officer who reviewed the original investigation, creating a chain that lacks true independence and impartiality.

Councillor Potts contrasts this with practices in other police forces. He notes that some forces have established a process where complaints are directed to an independent unit outside the police force. In contrast, Joy Allen, Crime Commissioner of Durham Constabulary, hides the fact the implementation of such an independent unit, which raises further questions about the transparency and fairness of the complaints process within Durham Constabulary. The community's faith in the police force needs to be restored promptly to ensure that the principles of justice and accountability are upheld for the benefit of all residents, who then form our communities.

Ensuring the integrity of Durham Constabulary's complaints process and the impartiality of the staff handling these complaints is of paramount importance. There's a critical need to prevent biases and manipulations from seeping into the process. It's unacceptable to label actions as "reasonable and proportionate" while evidence points to the lack of genuine investigation and independence within various internal departments. This glaring contradiction goes against the very code of conduct that should guide the police's actions and is a breach of their ethical principles.

As concerned citizens, we have a duty to hold Durham Constabulary accountable and demand change. We must work towards restoring the fundamental values of faith, trust, honesty, integrity, and fairness, which are the cornerstones of effective law enforcement. This process of change commences with this petition – a platform that gives voice to the public's concerns and underscores the urgency of adhering to a proper code of conduct. Our collective action has the power to instigate meaningful transformations within Durham Constabulary and reinstate the high standards of diligence and ethics that should define our police force.

Please sign and share to show your support for change.

avatar of the starter
Julie-Anne NormanPetition StarterPatriot

Petition Updates