Remove the $5.99 surprise regulatory fee from Instacart orders


Remove the $5.99 surprise regulatory fee from Instacart orders
The Issue
Instacart has recently imposed a $5.99 'Surprise Regulatory Fee' on its consumers, and this additional cost is proving to be unjust and burdensome. A simple grocery delivery, which is meant to be convenient, now comes with a hefty price increase — an extra $10 to $15 when including other fees, excluding the tip. This sudden inflation makes the service less accessible, especially for those on tight budgets.
It raises a critical question: why should consumers be held responsible for boosting employee salaries which are reportedly around $22/hour? Especially when the fee is imposed without prior consultation or transparency. This unilateral decision by Instacart shifts financial obligations onto its users, disproportionately impacting those who depend on the service due to circumstances beyond their control.
To add insult to injury, criticism of this fee is often met with insensitivity. A blanket statement categorizing users as "privileged" disregards the individual struggles they may face, such as living on a limited income or managing households where partners are unable to work due to disabilities.
Instead of levying unexpected fees on consumers, Instacart should explore more equitable solutions, such as reducing corporate overheads or implementing a more transparent pricing model that doesn’t penalize users.
The introduction of this fee reflects a lack of understanding and empathy towards users who rely on Instacart for its convenience. It is imperative that Instacart re-evaluate this decision and work towards an approach that balances fair employee compensation without placing the burden on customers.
I urge City Council and the Mayor to rethink their support of this decision.
Sign this petition to urge Instacart to remove the $5.99 Surprise Regulatory Fee and reconsider their policy in favor of more fair and transparent practices.

75
The Issue
Instacart has recently imposed a $5.99 'Surprise Regulatory Fee' on its consumers, and this additional cost is proving to be unjust and burdensome. A simple grocery delivery, which is meant to be convenient, now comes with a hefty price increase — an extra $10 to $15 when including other fees, excluding the tip. This sudden inflation makes the service less accessible, especially for those on tight budgets.
It raises a critical question: why should consumers be held responsible for boosting employee salaries which are reportedly around $22/hour? Especially when the fee is imposed without prior consultation or transparency. This unilateral decision by Instacart shifts financial obligations onto its users, disproportionately impacting those who depend on the service due to circumstances beyond their control.
To add insult to injury, criticism of this fee is often met with insensitivity. A blanket statement categorizing users as "privileged" disregards the individual struggles they may face, such as living on a limited income or managing households where partners are unable to work due to disabilities.
Instead of levying unexpected fees on consumers, Instacart should explore more equitable solutions, such as reducing corporate overheads or implementing a more transparent pricing model that doesn’t penalize users.
The introduction of this fee reflects a lack of understanding and empathy towards users who rely on Instacart for its convenience. It is imperative that Instacart re-evaluate this decision and work towards an approach that balances fair employee compensation without placing the burden on customers.
I urge City Council and the Mayor to rethink their support of this decision.
Sign this petition to urge Instacart to remove the $5.99 Surprise Regulatory Fee and reconsider their policy in favor of more fair and transparent practices.

75
Petition created on January 30, 2026

