

Remove Salesforce and Bring Back Amilia at the Miles Nadal JCC
The Issue
A petition to the CEO and Board of Directors of the Miles Nadal Jewish Community Centre, Toronto
We, the undersigned members and supporters of the Miles Nadal Jewish Community Centre (MNjcc), call on its leadership to reconsider the decision to replace the Canadian Amilia membership and registration platform with Salesforce and restore the previous system.
The Miles Nadal JCC is an important community institution. Its technology should be reliable, accessible, affordable, respectful of members' privacy and responsive to the needs of the community.
The transition to Salesforce has raised serious questions about costs, usability, transparency, data sovereignty and whether members were adequately consulted.
1. Higher Membership Fees and Questions About Software Spending
Members have experienced membership fee increases alongside the transition to Salesforce.
We believe members deserve to know whether the decision to adopt an American enterprise software platform has contributed to these increases.
In July 2026, the JCC announced a generous $1.3 million donation from the Azrieli Foundation to support organizational transformation, including improvements to its systems, leadership and infrastructure.
While this donation supports a broad initiative and was not necessarily intended exclusively for technology, it raises important questions about the JCC's financial priorities.
We ask:
- What was the total cost of implementing Salesforce?
- What are the ongoing licensing, development, maintenance and support costs?
- How much of the $1.3 million donation has been allocated to technology?
- Have Salesforce-related expenses contributed to increased membership fees?
- Was improving the existing Canadian platform evaluated as a potentially less expensive alternative?
- Members deserve transparency about how their fees and charitable contributions are being used.
2. Existing Member Data Was Migrated, Yet Members Had to Create New Accounts
During the transition, existing membership information was migrated to the new platform, but members were still required to create new accounts.
This raises questions about the planning and implementation of the transition.
Why were members required to register again when their information had already been transferred?
Screenshots of the new registration interface also show overlapping headings and layout problems, raising concerns about testing and quality assurance before launch.
Members should not experience unnecessary complications simply to access programs, manage their memberships or register for activities.
3. Privacy Concerns and the JCC's Published Privacy Policy
The JCC's publicly available Privacy Policy raises questions about how members' personal information is collected, used and shared.
The policy states that certain information may be shared with other organizations to help them contact individuals for marketing purposes.
However, it does not clearly identify those organizations, explain the categories of information shared, or describe the safeguards governing the Salesforce migration.
Members deserve answers about:
- What personal information was transferred from Amilia to Salesforce.
- Whether members were adequately notified about the migration.
- Which third-party organizations can access membership records.
- Whether personal information is shared for marketing purposes and how consent is obtained.
- How long information remains in the previous system.
- Whether a privacy impact assessment was conducted before the migration.
- Members should know who has access to their personal information and how it is being protected.
4. The USA PATRIOT Act, CLOUD Act and Canadian Data Sovereignty
The decision to move membership information to Salesforce, an American technology company, introduces additional questions about foreign jurisdiction and government access to personal information.
The USA PATRIOT Act and US CLOUD Act are relevant considerations when Canadian organizations rely on American technology providers.
The CLOUD Act can require certain US service providers to disclose information within their possession, custody or control, even when that information is stored outside the United States.
Canada's Office of the Privacy Commissioner has also discussed the privacy implications of outsourcing personal information to foreign service providers.
These considerations are particularly relevant for a community organization entrusted with information about members and their families.
We are not alleging that member information has been accessed by US authorities or improperly disclosed. We are asking whether the JCC evaluated these risks before migrating personal information.
We request clear answers to the following questions:
- Is member information stored and processed exclusively in Canada?
- Can Salesforce or its subcontractors access that information from the United States?
- Could member information be subject to disclosure under applicable US laws?
- What contractual and technical safeguards protect member information?
- Was a Canadian-controlled alternative evaluated?
- Data sovereignty should be a meaningful consideration when selecting technology for a Canadian community organization.
Further reading:
- Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada — USA PATRIOT Act
- Office of the Privacy Commissioner — CLOUD Act discussion
5. Why Abandon a Canadian Technology Solution?
Amilia is a Canadian technology company providing software for recreation, community organizations and membership management.
Replacing a Canadian platform with Salesforce raises questions about procurement priorities, particularly when domestic technology providers can offer comparable capabilities.
In September 2026, Toronto technology entrepreneur and JCC community member Perry Toone published an investigation titled:
Buy Ontario — So Why Isn't Ontario Buying Canadian Technology?
The investigation examined the broader issue of the Ontario Government purchasing American technology while domestic alternatives exist.
Perry also contacted the JCC and offered to volunteer his technical expertise to improve the existing Amilia platform through API integrations. His offer received no response.
We believe the JCC should explain why improving the existing Canadian system was not pursued and whether members were consulted before the decision was made.
Supporting Canadian technology is not simply a matter of national preference. It also raises practical questions about local economic benefits, procurement costs, accountability and data governance.
6. Salesforce's Licensing Costs and Available Alternatives
Salesforce's broader enterprise software strategy has also attracted scrutiny over pricing and the growing availability of competing AI tools.
An FSO News investigation examines how businesses can increasingly use ChatGPT, Claude, Microsoft Copilot and Grok to access Salesforce functionality without purchasing certain additional Agentforce licenses.
Salesforce's $125 AI Problem: Why ChatGPT, Claude, Copilot and Grok Could Undermine Agentforce
This analysis does not establish that the JCC purchased Agentforce or incurred these particular AI licensing costs. However, it illustrates the importance of evaluating enterprise software expenditures and available alternatives.
We believe the JCC should disclose its actual Salesforce costs and explain how the investment benefits members.
7. What We Are Asking the Miles Nadal JCC to Do
We call on CEO Ryla Braemer, Board President Ben Katz and the Board of Directors to:
- Reconsider Salesforce and restore Amilia as the membership and registration platform, subject to a transparent feasibility review.
- Publish the total Salesforce implementation costs, including ongoing licensing, development, support and maintenance.
- Explain the membership fee increases and whether technology expenditures contributed to them.
- Disclose how the $1.3 million organizational transformation donation is being allocated, including any technology-related spending.
- Provide a clear explanation of member data storage, processing and international access, including applicable US legal exposure.
- Review and improve the JCC's privacy policy, particularly its provisions concerning third-party marketing and data sharing.
- Consult members before further major technology decisions and publish a plan to address the problems identified.
- Put Members First
Members should be able to expect reliable registration systems, responsible financial management, meaningful consultation and transparent protection of their personal information. We had an opportunity to improve an existing Canadian technology solution, including offers of volunteer technical assistance.
Instead, members have been required to adapt to a new system while facing higher fees and unanswered questions about the costs and benefits of the transition.
We ask the Miles Nadal JCC to listen to its members, reconsider Salesforce, restore Amilia and put the community first.
Bring back Amilia. Support Canadian technology. Put members first.
17
The Issue
A petition to the CEO and Board of Directors of the Miles Nadal Jewish Community Centre, Toronto
We, the undersigned members and supporters of the Miles Nadal Jewish Community Centre (MNjcc), call on its leadership to reconsider the decision to replace the Canadian Amilia membership and registration platform with Salesforce and restore the previous system.
The Miles Nadal JCC is an important community institution. Its technology should be reliable, accessible, affordable, respectful of members' privacy and responsive to the needs of the community.
The transition to Salesforce has raised serious questions about costs, usability, transparency, data sovereignty and whether members were adequately consulted.
1. Higher Membership Fees and Questions About Software Spending
Members have experienced membership fee increases alongside the transition to Salesforce.
We believe members deserve to know whether the decision to adopt an American enterprise software platform has contributed to these increases.
In July 2026, the JCC announced a generous $1.3 million donation from the Azrieli Foundation to support organizational transformation, including improvements to its systems, leadership and infrastructure.
While this donation supports a broad initiative and was not necessarily intended exclusively for technology, it raises important questions about the JCC's financial priorities.
We ask:
- What was the total cost of implementing Salesforce?
- What are the ongoing licensing, development, maintenance and support costs?
- How much of the $1.3 million donation has been allocated to technology?
- Have Salesforce-related expenses contributed to increased membership fees?
- Was improving the existing Canadian platform evaluated as a potentially less expensive alternative?
- Members deserve transparency about how their fees and charitable contributions are being used.
2. Existing Member Data Was Migrated, Yet Members Had to Create New Accounts
During the transition, existing membership information was migrated to the new platform, but members were still required to create new accounts.
This raises questions about the planning and implementation of the transition.
Why were members required to register again when their information had already been transferred?
Screenshots of the new registration interface also show overlapping headings and layout problems, raising concerns about testing and quality assurance before launch.
Members should not experience unnecessary complications simply to access programs, manage their memberships or register for activities.
3. Privacy Concerns and the JCC's Published Privacy Policy
The JCC's publicly available Privacy Policy raises questions about how members' personal information is collected, used and shared.
The policy states that certain information may be shared with other organizations to help them contact individuals for marketing purposes.
However, it does not clearly identify those organizations, explain the categories of information shared, or describe the safeguards governing the Salesforce migration.
Members deserve answers about:
- What personal information was transferred from Amilia to Salesforce.
- Whether members were adequately notified about the migration.
- Which third-party organizations can access membership records.
- Whether personal information is shared for marketing purposes and how consent is obtained.
- How long information remains in the previous system.
- Whether a privacy impact assessment was conducted before the migration.
- Members should know who has access to their personal information and how it is being protected.
4. The USA PATRIOT Act, CLOUD Act and Canadian Data Sovereignty
The decision to move membership information to Salesforce, an American technology company, introduces additional questions about foreign jurisdiction and government access to personal information.
The USA PATRIOT Act and US CLOUD Act are relevant considerations when Canadian organizations rely on American technology providers.
The CLOUD Act can require certain US service providers to disclose information within their possession, custody or control, even when that information is stored outside the United States.
Canada's Office of the Privacy Commissioner has also discussed the privacy implications of outsourcing personal information to foreign service providers.
These considerations are particularly relevant for a community organization entrusted with information about members and their families.
We are not alleging that member information has been accessed by US authorities or improperly disclosed. We are asking whether the JCC evaluated these risks before migrating personal information.
We request clear answers to the following questions:
- Is member information stored and processed exclusively in Canada?
- Can Salesforce or its subcontractors access that information from the United States?
- Could member information be subject to disclosure under applicable US laws?
- What contractual and technical safeguards protect member information?
- Was a Canadian-controlled alternative evaluated?
- Data sovereignty should be a meaningful consideration when selecting technology for a Canadian community organization.
Further reading:
- Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada — USA PATRIOT Act
- Office of the Privacy Commissioner — CLOUD Act discussion
5. Why Abandon a Canadian Technology Solution?
Amilia is a Canadian technology company providing software for recreation, community organizations and membership management.
Replacing a Canadian platform with Salesforce raises questions about procurement priorities, particularly when domestic technology providers can offer comparable capabilities.
In September 2026, Toronto technology entrepreneur and JCC community member Perry Toone published an investigation titled:
Buy Ontario — So Why Isn't Ontario Buying Canadian Technology?
The investigation examined the broader issue of the Ontario Government purchasing American technology while domestic alternatives exist.
Perry also contacted the JCC and offered to volunteer his technical expertise to improve the existing Amilia platform through API integrations. His offer received no response.
We believe the JCC should explain why improving the existing Canadian system was not pursued and whether members were consulted before the decision was made.
Supporting Canadian technology is not simply a matter of national preference. It also raises practical questions about local economic benefits, procurement costs, accountability and data governance.
6. Salesforce's Licensing Costs and Available Alternatives
Salesforce's broader enterprise software strategy has also attracted scrutiny over pricing and the growing availability of competing AI tools.
An FSO News investigation examines how businesses can increasingly use ChatGPT, Claude, Microsoft Copilot and Grok to access Salesforce functionality without purchasing certain additional Agentforce licenses.
Salesforce's $125 AI Problem: Why ChatGPT, Claude, Copilot and Grok Could Undermine Agentforce
This analysis does not establish that the JCC purchased Agentforce or incurred these particular AI licensing costs. However, it illustrates the importance of evaluating enterprise software expenditures and available alternatives.
We believe the JCC should disclose its actual Salesforce costs and explain how the investment benefits members.
7. What We Are Asking the Miles Nadal JCC to Do
We call on CEO Ryla Braemer, Board President Ben Katz and the Board of Directors to:
- Reconsider Salesforce and restore Amilia as the membership and registration platform, subject to a transparent feasibility review.
- Publish the total Salesforce implementation costs, including ongoing licensing, development, support and maintenance.
- Explain the membership fee increases and whether technology expenditures contributed to them.
- Disclose how the $1.3 million organizational transformation donation is being allocated, including any technology-related spending.
- Provide a clear explanation of member data storage, processing and international access, including applicable US legal exposure.
- Review and improve the JCC's privacy policy, particularly its provisions concerning third-party marketing and data sharing.
- Consult members before further major technology decisions and publish a plan to address the problems identified.
- Put Members First
Members should be able to expect reliable registration systems, responsible financial management, meaningful consultation and transparent protection of their personal information. We had an opportunity to improve an existing Canadian technology solution, including offers of volunteer technical assistance.
Instead, members have been required to adapt to a new system while facing higher fees and unanswered questions about the costs and benefits of the transition.
We ask the Miles Nadal JCC to listen to its members, reconsider Salesforce, restore Amilia and put the community first.
Bring back Amilia. Support Canadian technology. Put members first.
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on November 18, 2026