Remove Carrie Ann Inaba from DWTS judging panel for rudeness
The Issue
As a devoted fan of “Dancing with the Stars” (DWTS) and someone who cherishes the art of dance, I feel compelled to raise a pressing issue that has been frustrating viewers, dancers, and fans alike: the harsh and often rude judging style of Carrie Ann Inaba. While we understand the need for constructive criticism to help dancers improve, Carrie Ann's approach frequently crosses the line. Her comments often come off as unnecessarily harsh, lacking the supportive tone that fans expect from someone in her esteemed position.
Numerous fans and even some dancers have expressed their dissatisfaction with her judging style. Public forums and fan sites are rife with complaints highlighting how her comments sometimes overshadow the performances themselves, affecting the morale of both novice and experienced dancers. This pattern not only undermines the spirit of the competition but also detracts from the enjoyment of viewers who tune in to celebrate the performances rather than critique them.
Statistics reveal that shows with more constructive and positive critique see higher viewer retention rates. DWTS, a show built on the passion of its participants and the joy of dance, should exemplify these values by promoting a more encouraging and supportive judging panel. Each participant, regardless of skill level, deserves to walk away from the competition enriched by their experience, not diminished by unnecessarily negative feedback.
We propose that ABC and the producers of DWTS consider a replacement for Carrie Ann Inaba, or alternatively, encourage a shift in her approach to judging. By making this important change, DWTS can maintain its reputation as a nurturing platform for both celebrities and professional dancers, providing them with the opportunity to learn and grow in a positive environment.
Join us in signing this petition to call on the producers of "Dancing with the Stars" to ensure that judging remains constructive and respectful, thereby enhancing the viewing experience for all and safeguarding the integrity and joy of the competition.
200
The Issue
As a devoted fan of “Dancing with the Stars” (DWTS) and someone who cherishes the art of dance, I feel compelled to raise a pressing issue that has been frustrating viewers, dancers, and fans alike: the harsh and often rude judging style of Carrie Ann Inaba. While we understand the need for constructive criticism to help dancers improve, Carrie Ann's approach frequently crosses the line. Her comments often come off as unnecessarily harsh, lacking the supportive tone that fans expect from someone in her esteemed position.
Numerous fans and even some dancers have expressed their dissatisfaction with her judging style. Public forums and fan sites are rife with complaints highlighting how her comments sometimes overshadow the performances themselves, affecting the morale of both novice and experienced dancers. This pattern not only undermines the spirit of the competition but also detracts from the enjoyment of viewers who tune in to celebrate the performances rather than critique them.
Statistics reveal that shows with more constructive and positive critique see higher viewer retention rates. DWTS, a show built on the passion of its participants and the joy of dance, should exemplify these values by promoting a more encouraging and supportive judging panel. Each participant, regardless of skill level, deserves to walk away from the competition enriched by their experience, not diminished by unnecessarily negative feedback.
We propose that ABC and the producers of DWTS consider a replacement for Carrie Ann Inaba, or alternatively, encourage a shift in her approach to judging. By making this important change, DWTS can maintain its reputation as a nurturing platform for both celebrities and professional dancers, providing them with the opportunity to learn and grow in a positive environment.
Join us in signing this petition to call on the producers of "Dancing with the Stars" to ensure that judging remains constructive and respectful, thereby enhancing the viewing experience for all and safeguarding the integrity and joy of the competition.
Supporter Voices
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on October 14, 2026