

Protect women in blue-collar jobs
The Issue
Petition to the Parliament of Canada
Reforming the Standard of Proof in Sexual Violence Cases
To the Honourable Members of Parliament, the Minister of Justice, and the Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights:
Women in Canada continue to face sexual harassment and assault, particularly in male-dominated workplaces, but also across many professional and public environments. While the law guarantees every person the right to a fair trial, the current application of the criminal standard of proof “beyond a reasonable doubt” in sexual assault cases places an unrealistic and unequal burden on survivors and contributes to systemic injustice.
Challenges Faced by Survivors
Sexual assault is a psychological and traumatic experience, not a logical or procedural event. Survivors must recount deeply personal experiences while under intense scrutiny, often after having been re-traumatized. Meanwhile, the accused is afforded multiple legal protections:
• The accused may remain silent during arrest, questioning, preliminary hearings, and trials
• They are often coached and supported by legal professionals
• They face no comparable psychological burden during the process
By contrast, survivors must:
• Write detailed reports under stress and trauma, often without professional support
• Relive and recount the assault repeatedly to investigators and in court
• Endure cross-examination tactics that exploit trauma to discredit them
This creates a fundamental inequality: only the survivor is scrutinized, while the accused is largely shielded and professionally supported. The current system disproportionately favors perpetrators and fails to provide a fair and equal trial, as guaranteed under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
Under-Reporting of Sexual Assault
Sexual assault is widely underreported in Canada. Over 80% of sexual assaults are never reported to law enforcement, largely because survivors do not believe they will receive a fair trial or the justice they deserve. Survivors anticipate disbelief, scrutiny, and retraumatization in a system that does not adequately recognize the psychological and emotional realities of sexual violence.
This widespread under-reporting underscores the urgent need for reform to ensure survivors feel supported, believed, and fairly treated under the law.
The Burden of Proof in Sexual Assault Cases
In sexual assault cases, the burden of proof is often applied in situations that are highly complex:
• Colleagues or staff may witness harassment or assault but remain silent due to loyalty, fear, or to protect others
• Many incidents occur in isolation or involve abusers in positions of power over the survivor, such as supervisors or managers
• These dynamics frequently create “he-said/she-said” situations, where the survivor carries the full burden of proof while under trauma
Sexual assault is not a logical or simple dispute; it is an emotional and psychological violation. Defence strategies often exploit this reality to manipulate, discredit, or confuse survivors, further undermining the fairness of the trial.
This raises a critical question: how can a trial be considered fair or equal when the survivor must speak, relive trauma, and justify their responses while the accused is protected by silence and legal guidance? The current standard of proof fails to account for the unique nature of sexual violence and places an impossible burden on survivors, leaving many without justice.
Reforming how the standard of “beyond a reasonable doubt” is applied in sexual violence cases is essential to creating a justice system that is fair, balanced, and supportive of survivors. Survivors deserve a system that recognizes:
• The psychological and emotional realities of sexual assault
• The unequal burden placed on them under the current system
• The systemic advantages afforded to perpetrators
• The widespread under-reporting caused by fear of disbelief and injustice
Changing the legal framework to better reflect these realities will ensure that survivors can access justice, perpetrators are held accountable, and the rights of all parties are respected in a truly equitable trial.
3
The Issue
Petition to the Parliament of Canada
Reforming the Standard of Proof in Sexual Violence Cases
To the Honourable Members of Parliament, the Minister of Justice, and the Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights:
Women in Canada continue to face sexual harassment and assault, particularly in male-dominated workplaces, but also across many professional and public environments. While the law guarantees every person the right to a fair trial, the current application of the criminal standard of proof “beyond a reasonable doubt” in sexual assault cases places an unrealistic and unequal burden on survivors and contributes to systemic injustice.
Challenges Faced by Survivors
Sexual assault is a psychological and traumatic experience, not a logical or procedural event. Survivors must recount deeply personal experiences while under intense scrutiny, often after having been re-traumatized. Meanwhile, the accused is afforded multiple legal protections:
• The accused may remain silent during arrest, questioning, preliminary hearings, and trials
• They are often coached and supported by legal professionals
• They face no comparable psychological burden during the process
By contrast, survivors must:
• Write detailed reports under stress and trauma, often without professional support
• Relive and recount the assault repeatedly to investigators and in court
• Endure cross-examination tactics that exploit trauma to discredit them
This creates a fundamental inequality: only the survivor is scrutinized, while the accused is largely shielded and professionally supported. The current system disproportionately favors perpetrators and fails to provide a fair and equal trial, as guaranteed under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
Under-Reporting of Sexual Assault
Sexual assault is widely underreported in Canada. Over 80% of sexual assaults are never reported to law enforcement, largely because survivors do not believe they will receive a fair trial or the justice they deserve. Survivors anticipate disbelief, scrutiny, and retraumatization in a system that does not adequately recognize the psychological and emotional realities of sexual violence.
This widespread under-reporting underscores the urgent need for reform to ensure survivors feel supported, believed, and fairly treated under the law.
The Burden of Proof in Sexual Assault Cases
In sexual assault cases, the burden of proof is often applied in situations that are highly complex:
• Colleagues or staff may witness harassment or assault but remain silent due to loyalty, fear, or to protect others
• Many incidents occur in isolation or involve abusers in positions of power over the survivor, such as supervisors or managers
• These dynamics frequently create “he-said/she-said” situations, where the survivor carries the full burden of proof while under trauma
Sexual assault is not a logical or simple dispute; it is an emotional and psychological violation. Defence strategies often exploit this reality to manipulate, discredit, or confuse survivors, further undermining the fairness of the trial.
This raises a critical question: how can a trial be considered fair or equal when the survivor must speak, relive trauma, and justify their responses while the accused is protected by silence and legal guidance? The current standard of proof fails to account for the unique nature of sexual violence and places an impossible burden on survivors, leaving many without justice.
Reforming how the standard of “beyond a reasonable doubt” is applied in sexual violence cases is essential to creating a justice system that is fair, balanced, and supportive of survivors. Survivors deserve a system that recognizes:
• The psychological and emotional realities of sexual assault
• The unequal burden placed on them under the current system
• The systemic advantages afforded to perpetrators
• The widespread under-reporting caused by fear of disbelief and injustice
Changing the legal framework to better reflect these realities will ensure that survivors can access justice, perpetrators are held accountable, and the rights of all parties are respected in a truly equitable trial.
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on November 18, 2025