
Proposal to Leicester Medical School to remove SAQ in final year
The Issue
We are writing to respectfully raise a concern regarding the standalone Short Answer Question (SAQ) examination in fifth year. While we fully appreciate the educational value of SAQs and the rationale behind their inclusion, we would like to request that the requirement to sit this assessment in the final year be reconsidered.
Throughout the programme, SAQs have played an important role in shaping our ability to think critically, analyse clinical scenarios, and apply our knowledge beyond rote memorisation. These are essential attributes for any doctor, and we recognise that the Leicester curriculum has successfully nurtured these qualities in us.
However, we believe that by the time students reach fifth year, these skills have been thoroughly developed. With four years of consistent exposure to SAQs and other critical thinking assessments, we feel that the intended learning outcomes of the format have already been met.
Furthermore, recent results highlight the effectiveness of Leicester’s teaching: 93% of our cohort passed the UKMLA Applied Knowledge Test (AKT). This is a clear testament to the quality of education we have received and strongly suggests that Leicester graduates are well-prepared for clinical practice according to GMC standards. As such, it feels disproportionate to require students to re-sit the Leicester SAQ exam if they have already demonstrated competence through the UKMLA, which is now the nationally mandated benchmark.
We also acknowledge that only a small number of UK medical schools continue to include standalone SAQs in final year. Given this, and the unique pressures of fifth year—including financial stress, the UK Foundation Programme application process, and the transition to working life—we believe it would be reasonable and compassionate to remove this exam in final year only.
To be clear, we are not asking for SAQs to be eliminated from the curriculum entirely. Rather, we are suggesting a focused revision that retains the benefits of the format in earlier years, while reducing the burden on students at a pivotal stage of their training. We believe this is a fair and balanced compromise that supports both educational integrity and student wellbeing.
Thank you for considering our perspective. We would be grateful for the opportunity to discuss this further and explore possible solutions.
33
The Issue
We are writing to respectfully raise a concern regarding the standalone Short Answer Question (SAQ) examination in fifth year. While we fully appreciate the educational value of SAQs and the rationale behind their inclusion, we would like to request that the requirement to sit this assessment in the final year be reconsidered.
Throughout the programme, SAQs have played an important role in shaping our ability to think critically, analyse clinical scenarios, and apply our knowledge beyond rote memorisation. These are essential attributes for any doctor, and we recognise that the Leicester curriculum has successfully nurtured these qualities in us.
However, we believe that by the time students reach fifth year, these skills have been thoroughly developed. With four years of consistent exposure to SAQs and other critical thinking assessments, we feel that the intended learning outcomes of the format have already been met.
Furthermore, recent results highlight the effectiveness of Leicester’s teaching: 93% of our cohort passed the UKMLA Applied Knowledge Test (AKT). This is a clear testament to the quality of education we have received and strongly suggests that Leicester graduates are well-prepared for clinical practice according to GMC standards. As such, it feels disproportionate to require students to re-sit the Leicester SAQ exam if they have already demonstrated competence through the UKMLA, which is now the nationally mandated benchmark.
We also acknowledge that only a small number of UK medical schools continue to include standalone SAQs in final year. Given this, and the unique pressures of fifth year—including financial stress, the UK Foundation Programme application process, and the transition to working life—we believe it would be reasonable and compassionate to remove this exam in final year only.
To be clear, we are not asking for SAQs to be eliminated from the curriculum entirely. Rather, we are suggesting a focused revision that retains the benefits of the format in earlier years, while reducing the burden on students at a pivotal stage of their training. We believe this is a fair and balanced compromise that supports both educational integrity and student wellbeing.
Thank you for considering our perspective. We would be grateful for the opportunity to discuss this further and explore possible solutions.
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on 23 May 2025