Muhlenberg College - reduce tuition for remote learning

Petition Closed

This petition had 676 supporters

The Issue

A CNBC article published July 21, 2020 cites that “roughly 93% of undergraduates said tuition should be lowered if classes continue remotely in the fall, according to a recent survey of more than 13,000 students by online note-sharing platform OneClass.” The source for that survey is here: https://oneclass.com/blog/featured/180637-students-think-online-classes-should-mean-lower-tuition.en.html


A survey conducted on the same platform reports that “three-quarters of all college students were unhappy with the quality of the education they received after moving online in the spring.” Source: https://oneclass.com/blog/featured/177356-7525-of-college-students-unhappy-with-quality-of-elearning-during-covid-19.en.html


“Even a high-quality online environment can’t replace the tangible experiences students have on campus,” says Daniel Collier, Research associate at the W.E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research. Most students (75% of them, as we know) agree. Source: https://www.cnbc.com/2020/07/21/these-colleges-offer-tuition-discounts-for-distance-learning-this-fall.html

Among the colleges that have reduced tuition for online learning in the fall are:

Hampton University in Virginia by 15%. Source: http://news.hamptonu.edu/release/President%27s-Letter-to-the-HU-Community-07%7C01%7C2020

Spelman College in Atlanta by 10% (tuition) and 40% (fees). Source: https://www.spelman.edu/academics/path-forward-2020-21

Paul Quinn College in Dallas by almost 30%. Source: https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5bf84b434611a034b52113b9/t/5f07145012b21d03521ab258/1594299472512/Formal+PQC+2020+Notification+Letter.pdf

And many others in the U.S., Canada, and abroad.

The CNBC article also references the important fact that “the coronavirus crisis has disproportionately affected people of color in the U.S., who have experienced both higher illness and death rates from the disease and more severe economic ramifications.” Muhlenberg College has been adamant in their support for the Black Lives Matter movement, but their plan to charge full tuition for remote learning during a pandemic certainly lacks consideration of the disproportionate economic and health effects of the COVID-19 crisis on black students around the country.

Lehigh University, just 25 minutes down the road from Muhlenberg, has decreased tuition by 10% for students whose classes are fully remote.

“For FALL 2020: There will be a 10-percent reduction in undergraduate tuition for the Fall semester for those students who choose to take classes fully remotely. These students, whether they live in South Bethlehem or elsewhere, will not have in-person access to campus facilities, with the exception of the Health and Wellness Center.” Source: https://www2.lehigh.edu/financial-aid/undergraduate


Our other neighbor Lafayette College was, like Muhlenberg, planning a tuition increase next semester. Instead, they are now also offering a 10% tuition reduction to all students studying remotely. Lafayette’s president Alison Byerly stated: “While our online courses will be of the highest quality, we recognize that students studying from home will not have access to campus facilities, or opportunities for the in-person interaction with fellow students that adds so much to a Lafayette education. We are therefore instituting a 10 percent reduction in the tuition rate for those who study from home.” Source: https://fall2020.lafayette.edu/2020/07/22/important-update-path-to-fall-2020/


I will now borrow some words from one of many other petitions to colleges and universities by their student bodies to lower tuition for remote learning:

“While the University is very optimistic insisting remote learning offers the same excellent and quality education as in person learning for all students— We disagree.  We believe remote learning and in person learning are fundamentally different and cannot provide the same quality education for everyone… Universities need to lower tuition for online learning since it is subpar and not the in person education for which many domestic and international students chose to enroll at the University in the first place.” Source: https://www.change.org/p/meric-gertler-uoft-reducing-tuition-for-remote-learning


An ABC article about student petitions and lawsuits includes this insight:

“Roy Willey, an attorney who started a website called CollegeRefund2020 in April, told ABC News he has filed over 30 lawsuits against colleges and universities. He expects that number to grow as the fall semester approaches. ‘It’s like if you and I go to a steakhouse and we order prime rib and pay in advance. And then we get to our table and they come and say, ‘we only have hamburgers,’ said Willey. ‘Hamburgers are still food, and we may accept that because we’re hungry, but they don't get to keep all of the money that we paid for the prime rib. Some colleges and universities are taking the position that they never promised an in person on-campus education and others are saying that they have added expenses,’ Willey added. “But there’s no excuse for taking that much money from students and families for online instruction.’” Source: https://abcnews.go.com/US/petitions-lawsuits-students-demand-lower-tuition-online-instruction/story?id=72105974


When we pay our tuition each semester, we are paying for the incredibly social experience of being at college. Students in the sciences pay for lab experience; art students pay for hands-on instruction; theatre, dance, and music students pay to perform. It’s hard to accept any argument stating that remote learning will provide the same experience for any college student, especially one involved in these fields— not to mention the large portion of the Muhlenberg student body that was drawn here by the performing arts programs.


Some students in these fields and others have chosen to take a semester or year off from the school rather than engage in remote learning; however, for others this disruption in their education and delay of graduation simply isn’t viable. All students should be compensated for the deficit in their social experiences and education during a fully remote fall semester.


The price of our tuition also accounts for our access to and use of on-campus facilities like the library, gym, practice rooms, laboratories, printers, and other common spaces for studying and socializing. Charging students the full price of tuition for remote classes, knowing we will not have access to any of these resources, hardly seems moral.


The demand of this petition is simple: a 10% reduction in tuition for all students attending fully remote classes either by choice or as dictated by the college’s plan.


We urge Muhlenberg College’s leadership to follow the example set by Lehigh University and Lafayette College, and reduce tuition for remote learning this fall. Thank you.

- Muhlenberg Students, the undersigned.

Students of Muhlenberg CollegePetition Starter

The Decision Makers

Dean Allison Gulati
President Kathleen Harring

Petition Updates