

Petition to Save Historic Garbutt NY and it's Mining History
The Issue
PETITION TO PRESERVE HISTORIC GARBUTT, NEW YORK
Protect Our History. Preserve Our Heritage.
To: New York State Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation, Town of Wheatland Officials, and Monroe County Representatives
We, the undersigned, respectfully request the evaluation, recognition, and preservation of the historic community of Garbutt (formerly Garbuttsville), New York, including the surviving remnants of its historic gypsum mining industry within Oatka Creek Park and surrounding areas. Also to include the men who lost their lives, in which they still remain in the mines. Their souls should be allowed to rest without being disturbed.
Beginning in the early 1800s, Garbuttsville became an important center of gypsum mining and production in western New York. Generations of families worked in its mines, mills, and associated industries, helping shape the community and the surrounding region.
Today, significant physical evidence of this history remains, including:
Historic gypsum mine entrances, shafts, and surface excavations.
Foundations and remnants of former gypsum mills and industrial buildings.
Historic railroad beds, bridge foundations, and transportation corridors.
Mining-related structures and archaeological features.
Historic homes, businesses, and community landmarks associated with Garbuttsville.
These surviving features represent an important chapter of New York's industrial and community history.
Unfortunately, time, erosion, development, and ground disturbances threaten what remains. Once these historic resources are destroyed, they cannot be replaced.
We respectfully request:
A formal historical and archaeological evaluation of the Garbutt area for potential historic district designation.
Consideration for listing eligible historic resources on the New York State and National Registers of Historic Places.
Documentation and appropriate protection of surviving mining structures, railroad beds, foundations, and archaeological remains.
Consultation with local historians, preservation specialists, property owners, and community representatives before activities that could damage historically significant resources.
Recognition of Garbutt's contributions to the industrial development of Monroe County and New York State.
Our goal is not to prevent responsible use of public or private property, but to ensure that historically significant resources are properly evaluated and considered before they are permanently lost.
Garbutt's history belongs to future generations as much as it belongs to us today.
By signing this petition, we express our support for efforts to document, recognize, and preserve this remarkable piece of New York history.
Please help us protect what remains before it disappears forever.
Organized by:
Noel
Garbuttsville – Garbutt NY Gypsum Mining History
Every signature represents another voice for preserving our history.

169
The Issue
PETITION TO PRESERVE HISTORIC GARBUTT, NEW YORK
Protect Our History. Preserve Our Heritage.
To: New York State Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation, Town of Wheatland Officials, and Monroe County Representatives
We, the undersigned, respectfully request the evaluation, recognition, and preservation of the historic community of Garbutt (formerly Garbuttsville), New York, including the surviving remnants of its historic gypsum mining industry within Oatka Creek Park and surrounding areas. Also to include the men who lost their lives, in which they still remain in the mines. Their souls should be allowed to rest without being disturbed.
Beginning in the early 1800s, Garbuttsville became an important center of gypsum mining and production in western New York. Generations of families worked in its mines, mills, and associated industries, helping shape the community and the surrounding region.
Today, significant physical evidence of this history remains, including:
Historic gypsum mine entrances, shafts, and surface excavations.
Foundations and remnants of former gypsum mills and industrial buildings.
Historic railroad beds, bridge foundations, and transportation corridors.
Mining-related structures and archaeological features.
Historic homes, businesses, and community landmarks associated with Garbuttsville.
These surviving features represent an important chapter of New York's industrial and community history.
Unfortunately, time, erosion, development, and ground disturbances threaten what remains. Once these historic resources are destroyed, they cannot be replaced.
We respectfully request:
A formal historical and archaeological evaluation of the Garbutt area for potential historic district designation.
Consideration for listing eligible historic resources on the New York State and National Registers of Historic Places.
Documentation and appropriate protection of surviving mining structures, railroad beds, foundations, and archaeological remains.
Consultation with local historians, preservation specialists, property owners, and community representatives before activities that could damage historically significant resources.
Recognition of Garbutt's contributions to the industrial development of Monroe County and New York State.
Our goal is not to prevent responsible use of public or private property, but to ensure that historically significant resources are properly evaluated and considered before they are permanently lost.
Garbutt's history belongs to future generations as much as it belongs to us today.
By signing this petition, we express our support for efforts to document, recognize, and preserve this remarkable piece of New York history.
Please help us protect what remains before it disappears forever.
Organized by:
Noel
Garbuttsville – Garbutt NY Gypsum Mining History
Every signature represents another voice for preserving our history.

The Decision Makers





Supporter Voices
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on October 28, 2026