Petition for Further Review and Adjustment of Exam Grades - International Economics 24/25
Petition for Further Review and Adjustment of Exam Grades - International Economics 24/25
The Issue
To the International Economics professors, Julian Emami Namini and Maarten Bosker
We, the undersigned students of International Economics from the IBEB 2nd year Cohort, respectfully request a review and adjustment of our final grades. We believe that an increase of at least one grade is warranted, based on several key factors that affected the overall fairness and accuracy of the grading process.
Our cohort has worked diligently throughout this course, and we believe that these factors contributed to an unfairly low outcome for many of us. We hope that this petition will help ensure that our efforts are accurately reflected in our final grades.
We appreciate the 1 grade increase already applied to the grades. However, without this adjustment, only about 20% of the 500+ students in our cohort would have passed. its important to also note that only 9% of the dutch cohort passed. These statistics are concerning and indicate that the exam’s design or implementation may not have been as fair as intended. We argue that this adjustment, while appreciated, still does not fully address the issues outlined below, which contributed to an overall negative impact on the grades of many students.
1. The Guessing Factor and Its Impact on Exam Scores
One significant issue that affected many students was the impact of the guessing factor on our overall scores. With a total of 30 points for the exam, the guessing factor reduced many students’ scores by approximately 7 points. This is not the norm for exams of this nature and unfairly penalizes students who have studied and worked hard throughout the course. The exam should reflect the students’ understanding of the material, not be unduly influenced by chance, which distorts the evaluation of our knowledge and effort. We urge you to consider this issue when assessing our final grades.
2. Confusion During the Exam Due to Unclear Announcements
During the exam, it was announced over the microphone that two or more questions had been adjusted. Unfortunately, the manner in which these changes were communicated was unclear, as the announcements were excessively loud and not made in clear English. This left the majority of students confused and uncertain about how to proceed with the altered questions. As a result, many students may have been unable to answer these questions properly or at all, which unfairly impacted their overall performance. We kindly request that these two questions be either awarded to all students or completely removed from the final score calculation.
3. Cohort’s Historical Performance and the Unusually Low Average
It is worth noting that this cohort has historically been one of the highest achieving groups, statistically outperforming previous cohorts. The average score on this exam, however, is amongst the lowest this group has ever received, if not the lowest. This is a clear indication that something was anomalous in the exam’s design, implementation, or grading. Given our history of strong academic performance, the unusually low average suggests that factors beyond our control—such as the issues mentioned above—have unduly affected our results.
Our request:
We ask for your understanding and consideration in light of these challenges. We do not believe that the current grading system fairly reflects the hard work and effort put in by the students of this cohort. Given the factors outlined, we respectfully request a revision of our final grades, with at least a 1 grade increase applied to each student’s score. This adjustment would better reflect the circumstances of the exam and the hard work of this cohort.
We trust that you will consider our request seriously and look forward to your positive response.
Sincerely,
Students of International Economics 2024/25
14/01/25
177
The Issue
To the International Economics professors, Julian Emami Namini and Maarten Bosker
We, the undersigned students of International Economics from the IBEB 2nd year Cohort, respectfully request a review and adjustment of our final grades. We believe that an increase of at least one grade is warranted, based on several key factors that affected the overall fairness and accuracy of the grading process.
Our cohort has worked diligently throughout this course, and we believe that these factors contributed to an unfairly low outcome for many of us. We hope that this petition will help ensure that our efforts are accurately reflected in our final grades.
We appreciate the 1 grade increase already applied to the grades. However, without this adjustment, only about 20% of the 500+ students in our cohort would have passed. its important to also note that only 9% of the dutch cohort passed. These statistics are concerning and indicate that the exam’s design or implementation may not have been as fair as intended. We argue that this adjustment, while appreciated, still does not fully address the issues outlined below, which contributed to an overall negative impact on the grades of many students.
1. The Guessing Factor and Its Impact on Exam Scores
One significant issue that affected many students was the impact of the guessing factor on our overall scores. With a total of 30 points for the exam, the guessing factor reduced many students’ scores by approximately 7 points. This is not the norm for exams of this nature and unfairly penalizes students who have studied and worked hard throughout the course. The exam should reflect the students’ understanding of the material, not be unduly influenced by chance, which distorts the evaluation of our knowledge and effort. We urge you to consider this issue when assessing our final grades.
2. Confusion During the Exam Due to Unclear Announcements
During the exam, it was announced over the microphone that two or more questions had been adjusted. Unfortunately, the manner in which these changes were communicated was unclear, as the announcements were excessively loud and not made in clear English. This left the majority of students confused and uncertain about how to proceed with the altered questions. As a result, many students may have been unable to answer these questions properly or at all, which unfairly impacted their overall performance. We kindly request that these two questions be either awarded to all students or completely removed from the final score calculation.
3. Cohort’s Historical Performance and the Unusually Low Average
It is worth noting that this cohort has historically been one of the highest achieving groups, statistically outperforming previous cohorts. The average score on this exam, however, is amongst the lowest this group has ever received, if not the lowest. This is a clear indication that something was anomalous in the exam’s design, implementation, or grading. Given our history of strong academic performance, the unusually low average suggests that factors beyond our control—such as the issues mentioned above—have unduly affected our results.
Our request:
We ask for your understanding and consideration in light of these challenges. We do not believe that the current grading system fairly reflects the hard work and effort put in by the students of this cohort. Given the factors outlined, we respectfully request a revision of our final grades, with at least a 1 grade increase applied to each student’s score. This adjustment would better reflect the circumstances of the exam and the hard work of this cohort.
We trust that you will consider our request seriously and look forward to your positive response.
Sincerely,
Students of International Economics 2024/25
14/01/25
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on January 14, 2025