Petition for Change: Immediate Removal of Mickey Loomis as General Manager of the Saints
The Issue
To: Ownership & Executive Management of the New Orleans Saints
From: WhoDat Nation
Subject: Formal Petition to Relieve Mickey Loomis of General Management Duties
Executive Summary
We, the dedicated fan base of the New Orleans Saints—WhoDat Nation—hereby submit this petition demanding an immediate overhaul of our football operations, starting with the removal or reassignment of General Manager Mickey Loomis.
For over two decades, Saints fans have demonstrated unmatched loyalty, filling the Superdome through high points and severe dry spells. However, under Mickey Loomis’s recent stewardship, the organization has descended into middle-of-the-pack stagnation, questionable cap management, and a fundamental lack of accountability. It is clear that without Sean Payton, the current front office structure is holding the franchise back from contending.
Key Grounds for Removal
1. Constant National and Global Embarrassment
Losses on the World Stage: The Saints’ brand has suffered repeatedly on international and standalone broadcasts—most recently capped off by frustrating, lackluster performances overseas in Paris.
Disappearing Primetime Presence: Due to years of uninspiring, non-competitive football, the league has continually flexed the Saints out of primetime slots. On the rare occasions the team does earn a national stage (such as recent blowout losses on Monday Night Football), the product on the field looks completely unprepared and embarrassing.
Losing Record of Blowouts: Instead of being a feared contender, the Saints have routinely suffered non-competitive blowout losses against division rivals and national opponents, further eroding the standard set during the championship years.
2. Poor Draft History & First-Round Missteps
Draft Track Record: Out of nearly two decades leading the front office, the Saints have managed only a handful of truly elite draft classes (most notably 2017). The majority of draft cycles have yielded sub-par returns relative to premium draft capital.
Pattern of High-Risk Picks: Loomis has repeatedly gambled first-round assets on players with extensive injury histories or raw projections (e.g., Marcus Davenport, Payton Turner, Trevor Penning). These decisions continuously cost the team vital depth and cheap, young talent.
3. Loss of Key Locker Room Leaders & Roster Mismanagement Depleting Core Leadership: Rather than building a cohesive bridge to the next era, decision-making has allowed core veteran leaders—players who hold the locker room together like Demario Davis—to face uncertain futures or watch key glue guys walk in free agency.
Lack of Real Talent Acquisition: A reliance on kick-the-can salary cap strategies has limited the front office's flexibility to sign top-tier, prime-age talent in free agency, leading to patch-job rosters rather than genuine rebuilds.
4. Coaching Selection & Failure of Accountability Questionable Coaching Hires: When forced to make head coaching and offensive coordinator decisions, Loomis consistently favored internal comfort over proven innovative minds. The decision to hire and stick by coaches like Dennis Allen and Kellen Moore over dynamic, modern leaders like Dan Campbell and other elite head-coaching candidates set the franchise back years.
Zero Accountability: Loomis has consistently shown an inability to hold his hired coaching staff accountable for underperformance, public game-management errors, and lack of team discipline.
5. The "Sean Payton Effect" & Post-Payton Decline
Unsuccessful Without Payton: The data is stark: Mickey Loomis has never reached the postseason without Sean Payton as head coach.
Tale of Two Trajectories: After letting Sean Payton walk, Payton returned to head coaching and quickly built a competitive program elsewhere, while the Saints remain trapped in post-Brees/post-Payton purgatory.
6. Complacency & Loss of Home-Field Advantage
Failure of Succession Comfort: Because Loomis is deeply entrenched in ownership transition and estate succession planning, he operates without the pressure or accountability faced by traditional NFL general managers. This job security has bred complacency at the top.
Surrendering the Superdome: The legendary home-field advantage of the Caesars Superdome has eroded. Opposing fanbases routinely buy out sections and dominate the atmosphere—a direct consequence of delivering a mediocre, uninspiring product on the field.
Conclusion & Call to Action
Mickey Loomis played an undeniable role in the most successful era of Saints history. However, past achievements cannot excuse present stagnation. The New Orleans Saints are currently being held back by a refusal to modernize, rebuild, and demand accountability at every level.
We call on ownership to initiate a complete front-office reset, relieve Mickey Loomis of GM duties, and bring in progressive football leadership capable of rebuilding a championship-caliber team.
Signed,
WhoDat Nation
177
The Issue
To: Ownership & Executive Management of the New Orleans Saints
From: WhoDat Nation
Subject: Formal Petition to Relieve Mickey Loomis of General Management Duties
Executive Summary
We, the dedicated fan base of the New Orleans Saints—WhoDat Nation—hereby submit this petition demanding an immediate overhaul of our football operations, starting with the removal or reassignment of General Manager Mickey Loomis.
For over two decades, Saints fans have demonstrated unmatched loyalty, filling the Superdome through high points and severe dry spells. However, under Mickey Loomis’s recent stewardship, the organization has descended into middle-of-the-pack stagnation, questionable cap management, and a fundamental lack of accountability. It is clear that without Sean Payton, the current front office structure is holding the franchise back from contending.
Key Grounds for Removal
1. Constant National and Global Embarrassment
Losses on the World Stage: The Saints’ brand has suffered repeatedly on international and standalone broadcasts—most recently capped off by frustrating, lackluster performances overseas in Paris.
Disappearing Primetime Presence: Due to years of uninspiring, non-competitive football, the league has continually flexed the Saints out of primetime slots. On the rare occasions the team does earn a national stage (such as recent blowout losses on Monday Night Football), the product on the field looks completely unprepared and embarrassing.
Losing Record of Blowouts: Instead of being a feared contender, the Saints have routinely suffered non-competitive blowout losses against division rivals and national opponents, further eroding the standard set during the championship years.
2. Poor Draft History & First-Round Missteps
Draft Track Record: Out of nearly two decades leading the front office, the Saints have managed only a handful of truly elite draft classes (most notably 2017). The majority of draft cycles have yielded sub-par returns relative to premium draft capital.
Pattern of High-Risk Picks: Loomis has repeatedly gambled first-round assets on players with extensive injury histories or raw projections (e.g., Marcus Davenport, Payton Turner, Trevor Penning). These decisions continuously cost the team vital depth and cheap, young talent.
3. Loss of Key Locker Room Leaders & Roster Mismanagement Depleting Core Leadership: Rather than building a cohesive bridge to the next era, decision-making has allowed core veteran leaders—players who hold the locker room together like Demario Davis—to face uncertain futures or watch key glue guys walk in free agency.
Lack of Real Talent Acquisition: A reliance on kick-the-can salary cap strategies has limited the front office's flexibility to sign top-tier, prime-age talent in free agency, leading to patch-job rosters rather than genuine rebuilds.
4. Coaching Selection & Failure of Accountability Questionable Coaching Hires: When forced to make head coaching and offensive coordinator decisions, Loomis consistently favored internal comfort over proven innovative minds. The decision to hire and stick by coaches like Dennis Allen and Kellen Moore over dynamic, modern leaders like Dan Campbell and other elite head-coaching candidates set the franchise back years.
Zero Accountability: Loomis has consistently shown an inability to hold his hired coaching staff accountable for underperformance, public game-management errors, and lack of team discipline.
5. The "Sean Payton Effect" & Post-Payton Decline
Unsuccessful Without Payton: The data is stark: Mickey Loomis has never reached the postseason without Sean Payton as head coach.
Tale of Two Trajectories: After letting Sean Payton walk, Payton returned to head coaching and quickly built a competitive program elsewhere, while the Saints remain trapped in post-Brees/post-Payton purgatory.
6. Complacency & Loss of Home-Field Advantage
Failure of Succession Comfort: Because Loomis is deeply entrenched in ownership transition and estate succession planning, he operates without the pressure or accountability faced by traditional NFL general managers. This job security has bred complacency at the top.
Surrendering the Superdome: The legendary home-field advantage of the Caesars Superdome has eroded. Opposing fanbases routinely buy out sections and dominate the atmosphere—a direct consequence of delivering a mediocre, uninspiring product on the field.
Conclusion & Call to Action
Mickey Loomis played an undeniable role in the most successful era of Saints history. However, past achievements cannot excuse present stagnation. The New Orleans Saints are currently being held back by a refusal to modernize, rebuild, and demand accountability at every level.
We call on ownership to initiate a complete front-office reset, relieve Mickey Loomis of GM duties, and bring in progressive football leadership capable of rebuilding a championship-caliber team.
Signed,
WhoDat Nation
Supporter Voices
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on October 26, 2026