

Petition for a Fair Review and Protection of Karmelo Anthony’s Appellate Rights
The Issue
We, the undersigned, respectfully ask that Karmelo Anthony be afforded every legal protection and opportunity available throughout the appellate process.
Karmelo Anthony has been sentenced to 35 years in prison. While the trial phase has concluded, we believe that justice also requires fairness, transparency, and confidence that every legal avenue is thoroughly explored.
This petition is not intended to diminish the profound loss experienced by Austin Metcalf’s family and loved ones. Multiple families have been forever impacted by this tragedy, and our hearts go out to everyone affected.
However, we also believe that every individual deserves equal treatment under the law, the right to appeal, and access to a judicial process that is free from bias and committed to due process.
We respectfully ask that:
• Karmelo Anthony’s appellate rights be fully protected.
• Any concerns regarding the fairness and integrity of the proceedings be carefully reviewed through the proper legal channels.
• All available legal remedies be pursued and considered in accordance with the law.
• Karmelo Anthony and his family be treated with dignity and compassion throughout the appellate process.
As citizens, we recognize that advocating for due process is not an attack on justice. Rather, it is an affirmation that our legal system is strongest when it remains fair, transparent, and accountable.
By signing this petition, we are standing for the principle that every person deserves the opportunity to have their case reviewed through the legal processes established by our justice system.
We ask that the appropriate authorities ensure that fairness, integrity, and equal protection under the law remain at the forefront of this case as it moves through the appellate process.
Respectfully,
Supporters of Due Process, Fairness, and Compassion

305
The Issue
We, the undersigned, respectfully ask that Karmelo Anthony be afforded every legal protection and opportunity available throughout the appellate process.
Karmelo Anthony has been sentenced to 35 years in prison. While the trial phase has concluded, we believe that justice also requires fairness, transparency, and confidence that every legal avenue is thoroughly explored.
This petition is not intended to diminish the profound loss experienced by Austin Metcalf’s family and loved ones. Multiple families have been forever impacted by this tragedy, and our hearts go out to everyone affected.
However, we also believe that every individual deserves equal treatment under the law, the right to appeal, and access to a judicial process that is free from bias and committed to due process.
We respectfully ask that:
• Karmelo Anthony’s appellate rights be fully protected.
• Any concerns regarding the fairness and integrity of the proceedings be carefully reviewed through the proper legal channels.
• All available legal remedies be pursued and considered in accordance with the law.
• Karmelo Anthony and his family be treated with dignity and compassion throughout the appellate process.
As citizens, we recognize that advocating for due process is not an attack on justice. Rather, it is an affirmation that our legal system is strongest when it remains fair, transparent, and accountable.
By signing this petition, we are standing for the principle that every person deserves the opportunity to have their case reviewed through the legal processes established by our justice system.
We ask that the appropriate authorities ensure that fairness, integrity, and equal protection under the law remain at the forefront of this case as it moves through the appellate process.
Respectfully,
Supporters of Due Process, Fairness, and Compassion

Supporter Voices
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on June 9, 2026