

Open Letter: A Case for Simplification, Fairness, and Fiscal Responsibility
The Issue
Dear Fellow Citizens,
When I first wrote in support of a simpler tax system, the national debt stood near $34 trillion and the annual deficit was already a severe warning sign. Today, that warning has turned into an emergency. The federal government now spends roughly $7.4 trillion a year (about 23% of everything our economy produces) while collecting only about $5.4 trillion in revenue. The annual deficit for fiscal year 2026 just closed at $2 trillion, and total gross national debt has officially crossed $40.5 trillion. Debt held by the public matches the size of the entire United States economy.
Here is the number that should end any debate about whether this is urgent: net interest on the debt topped $1.05 trillion this past year. That works out to nearly $2.9 billion every single day. Interest is now the third-largest item in the entire federal budget, costing us more than our entire national defense. The Congressional Budget Office projects that around 2031, the interest rate on our debt will begin to outpace the growth rate of our economy. When that happens on a sustained basis, debt compounds faster than we can possibly grow out of it. Economists call this a debt spiral, and we are roughly five years away from it.
We did not arrive here because of any single party or president. We arrived here because our political system rewards politicians for spending today and passing the invoice to generations who cannot yet vote. That is the core problem, and tax reform alone will not fix it. This letter puts forward three connected proposals: simplify the tax code, balance the budget by design rather than by willpower, and lengthen the time horizon over which our leaders are forced to govern.
I. A Simpler, Fairer Tax Code
The current tax code spans tens of thousands of pages of carve-outs, credits, and special exemptions. It rewards anyone who can afford teams of accountants and lobbyists, and it punishes those who cannot. It is expensive to comply with, impossible for ordinary citizens to decipher, and designed to conceal who actually pays what.
We propose replacing it with a single, transparent federal tax built on three straightforward principles:
- One rate, one page. A single federal rate applied to income above a generous standard exemption, with the overwhelming majority of existing deductions and loopholes wiped out. Most Americans should be able to file their return in minutes.
- A real floor for working families. Income up to a defined threshold, indexed each year to the cost of living, would be fully exempt from federal income tax. The lowest earners owe nothing. (States and localities set their own tax policies; we urge them to adopt parallel safeguards, but federal reform only governs federal taxes.) This exemption directly answers the concern that a flat rate hurts those with the least: by shielding the base of every paycheck, the effective tax rate rises as income grows, even with a single statutory rate.
- A rate set to the truth, not a campaign slogan. An honest flat-tax proposal cannot promise a microscopic rate on a narrow base and still fund our core commitments. It pays for itself by broadening the base, closing carve-outs, and shifting toward consumption rather than punishing work and savings. The exact rate must be calculated and published by an independent fiscal authority against the actual cost of government, then debated in the daylight. We should demand only that the rate be set honestly, that it fund our obligations, and that it include a binding, published schedule to pay down the debt over time.
II. Balancing the Budget by Design
Decades of political promises to balance the budget have amounted to nothing. What works is structure: rules that make responsible choices mandatory and automatic. We propose:
- A structural balance rule over the business cycle. Demanding an exact balance every single year backfires during recessions by forcing deep spending cuts during downturns. A structural rule allows temporary deficits during true emergencies and requires surpluses during periods of growth, averaging out to balance across the economic cycle.
- A debt brake. Modeled on the Swiss system that has successfully kept debt in check, this would set a statutory or constitutional cap on structural deficits, tied to a firm schedule that lowers the debt-to-GDP ratio over time.
- Automatic triggers. If debt-to-GDP breaches agreed limits, automatic spending and revenue adjustments kick in without waiting for Congress to find sudden political courage. We insulated monetary policy decades ago by giving operational independence to the Federal Reserve; basic fiscal discipline needs that same protection.
- An independent, nonpartisan Fiscal Council. A permanent agency, similar to the United Kingdom's Office for Budget Responsibility, to score every major bill, calculate long-term costs, determine the necessary tax rate, and publish its findings in clear English. Hidden costs are how bad bills get passed.
- Real skin in the game. Institute a strict "No Budget, No Pay, No Recess" standard. If Congress fails to pass full appropriations on time, members forfeit their pay and remain in Washington without recess until the job is completed.
- An Emergency Fund as a dedicated pressure valve. True national crises (wars, major disasters, pandemics) must be financed through a segregated Emergency Fund. This fund would be refilled through an automatic, temporary surcharge that expires once the emergency concludes. Having a clear channel for genuine emergencies keeps politicians from labeling ordinary budget items as emergencies to bypass spending caps.
III. Longer Horizons Than the Next Election
Our fundamental challenge is short-term incentives. Two-year House terms and four-year presidential terms push politicians toward quick fixes that pay off before the next ballot and discourage investments that take a decade to bear fruit. The national debt is simply the most visible symptom of this short horizon. We propose two reforms that work together:
- Congressional term limits. Sensible limits on congressional service help restore the citizen-legislator and break the constant cycle of permanent campaigning, fundraising, and self-preservation. Term limits alone can sometimes empower unelected staff and lobbyists, which is why they must be paired with durable institutional changes.
- Institutions that outlast a single Congress. Real stability comes from durable rules whose authority carries through successive elections. We should move the federal government to multi-year budgeting rather than holding an annual scramble, and authorize the independent Fiscal Council to publish 10- and 20-year projections. The structural balance rule and the debt paydown schedule must be legally binding across future sessions so that one election cannot overturn years of financial discipline.
A Phased Transition
A transition of this scale must be planned carefully over roughly four years:
- Year One: Draft and pass enabling legislation, launch the independent Fiscal Council, modernize filing infrastructure, and conduct widespread public education.
- Years Two and Three: Run the legacy and new tax systems in parallel, allowing taxpayers and employers to adapt while funding retraining for administrative workers whose roles change.
- Year Four: Fully enact the simplified tax code and binding budget rules, with continued transitional support where needed.
In Closing
This is not a matter of left versus right. Tax simplicity, transparency about public spending, and a refusal to bankrupt our kids are not partisan ideas; they are basic responsibilities of self-government. We need a tax code that ordinary people can read, a budget that balances because the law requires it, and public officials whose success is measured by the long-term solvency of the country.
We are roughly five years away from the moment our national debt starts compounding faster than our economy can grow. The numbers do not negotiate, and they will not wait for convenient politics.
Please add your voice to demand a federal government that is transparent, accountable, and fiscally solvent, for our own families and for the generations who will inherit the bill.
Sincerely,
Alan Rihm
Note: Figures cited reflect official reports from the U.S. Department of the Treasury and the Congressional Budget Office for Fiscal Year 2026.

63
The Issue
Dear Fellow Citizens,
When I first wrote in support of a simpler tax system, the national debt stood near $34 trillion and the annual deficit was already a severe warning sign. Today, that warning has turned into an emergency. The federal government now spends roughly $7.4 trillion a year (about 23% of everything our economy produces) while collecting only about $5.4 trillion in revenue. The annual deficit for fiscal year 2026 just closed at $2 trillion, and total gross national debt has officially crossed $40.5 trillion. Debt held by the public matches the size of the entire United States economy.
Here is the number that should end any debate about whether this is urgent: net interest on the debt topped $1.05 trillion this past year. That works out to nearly $2.9 billion every single day. Interest is now the third-largest item in the entire federal budget, costing us more than our entire national defense. The Congressional Budget Office projects that around 2031, the interest rate on our debt will begin to outpace the growth rate of our economy. When that happens on a sustained basis, debt compounds faster than we can possibly grow out of it. Economists call this a debt spiral, and we are roughly five years away from it.
We did not arrive here because of any single party or president. We arrived here because our political system rewards politicians for spending today and passing the invoice to generations who cannot yet vote. That is the core problem, and tax reform alone will not fix it. This letter puts forward three connected proposals: simplify the tax code, balance the budget by design rather than by willpower, and lengthen the time horizon over which our leaders are forced to govern.
I. A Simpler, Fairer Tax Code
The current tax code spans tens of thousands of pages of carve-outs, credits, and special exemptions. It rewards anyone who can afford teams of accountants and lobbyists, and it punishes those who cannot. It is expensive to comply with, impossible for ordinary citizens to decipher, and designed to conceal who actually pays what.
We propose replacing it with a single, transparent federal tax built on three straightforward principles:
- One rate, one page. A single federal rate applied to income above a generous standard exemption, with the overwhelming majority of existing deductions and loopholes wiped out. Most Americans should be able to file their return in minutes.
- A real floor for working families. Income up to a defined threshold, indexed each year to the cost of living, would be fully exempt from federal income tax. The lowest earners owe nothing. (States and localities set their own tax policies; we urge them to adopt parallel safeguards, but federal reform only governs federal taxes.) This exemption directly answers the concern that a flat rate hurts those with the least: by shielding the base of every paycheck, the effective tax rate rises as income grows, even with a single statutory rate.
- A rate set to the truth, not a campaign slogan. An honest flat-tax proposal cannot promise a microscopic rate on a narrow base and still fund our core commitments. It pays for itself by broadening the base, closing carve-outs, and shifting toward consumption rather than punishing work and savings. The exact rate must be calculated and published by an independent fiscal authority against the actual cost of government, then debated in the daylight. We should demand only that the rate be set honestly, that it fund our obligations, and that it include a binding, published schedule to pay down the debt over time.
II. Balancing the Budget by Design
Decades of political promises to balance the budget have amounted to nothing. What works is structure: rules that make responsible choices mandatory and automatic. We propose:
- A structural balance rule over the business cycle. Demanding an exact balance every single year backfires during recessions by forcing deep spending cuts during downturns. A structural rule allows temporary deficits during true emergencies and requires surpluses during periods of growth, averaging out to balance across the economic cycle.
- A debt brake. Modeled on the Swiss system that has successfully kept debt in check, this would set a statutory or constitutional cap on structural deficits, tied to a firm schedule that lowers the debt-to-GDP ratio over time.
- Automatic triggers. If debt-to-GDP breaches agreed limits, automatic spending and revenue adjustments kick in without waiting for Congress to find sudden political courage. We insulated monetary policy decades ago by giving operational independence to the Federal Reserve; basic fiscal discipline needs that same protection.
- An independent, nonpartisan Fiscal Council. A permanent agency, similar to the United Kingdom's Office for Budget Responsibility, to score every major bill, calculate long-term costs, determine the necessary tax rate, and publish its findings in clear English. Hidden costs are how bad bills get passed.
- Real skin in the game. Institute a strict "No Budget, No Pay, No Recess" standard. If Congress fails to pass full appropriations on time, members forfeit their pay and remain in Washington without recess until the job is completed.
- An Emergency Fund as a dedicated pressure valve. True national crises (wars, major disasters, pandemics) must be financed through a segregated Emergency Fund. This fund would be refilled through an automatic, temporary surcharge that expires once the emergency concludes. Having a clear channel for genuine emergencies keeps politicians from labeling ordinary budget items as emergencies to bypass spending caps.
III. Longer Horizons Than the Next Election
Our fundamental challenge is short-term incentives. Two-year House terms and four-year presidential terms push politicians toward quick fixes that pay off before the next ballot and discourage investments that take a decade to bear fruit. The national debt is simply the most visible symptom of this short horizon. We propose two reforms that work together:
- Congressional term limits. Sensible limits on congressional service help restore the citizen-legislator and break the constant cycle of permanent campaigning, fundraising, and self-preservation. Term limits alone can sometimes empower unelected staff and lobbyists, which is why they must be paired with durable institutional changes.
- Institutions that outlast a single Congress. Real stability comes from durable rules whose authority carries through successive elections. We should move the federal government to multi-year budgeting rather than holding an annual scramble, and authorize the independent Fiscal Council to publish 10- and 20-year projections. The structural balance rule and the debt paydown schedule must be legally binding across future sessions so that one election cannot overturn years of financial discipline.
A Phased Transition
A transition of this scale must be planned carefully over roughly four years:
- Year One: Draft and pass enabling legislation, launch the independent Fiscal Council, modernize filing infrastructure, and conduct widespread public education.
- Years Two and Three: Run the legacy and new tax systems in parallel, allowing taxpayers and employers to adapt while funding retraining for administrative workers whose roles change.
- Year Four: Fully enact the simplified tax code and binding budget rules, with continued transitional support where needed.
In Closing
This is not a matter of left versus right. Tax simplicity, transparency about public spending, and a refusal to bankrupt our kids are not partisan ideas; they are basic responsibilities of self-government. We need a tax code that ordinary people can read, a budget that balances because the law requires it, and public officials whose success is measured by the long-term solvency of the country.
We are roughly five years away from the moment our national debt starts compounding faster than our economy can grow. The numbers do not negotiate, and they will not wait for convenient politics.
Please add your voice to demand a federal government that is transparent, accountable, and fiscally solvent, for our own families and for the generations who will inherit the bill.
Sincerely,
Alan Rihm
Note: Figures cited reflect official reports from the U.S. Department of the Treasury and the Congressional Budget Office for Fiscal Year 2026.

The Decision Makers
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on April 23, 2024
