

Muhlenberg College: Extend Optional Pass/Fail for the Fall 2020 Semester
The Issue
Dear Muhlenberg College,
In the spring semester, the college graciously offered students the option to pass/fail courses given that the semester had been disrupted abruptly. Yet I would argue that the Fall 2020 semester is equally as challenging if not more disruptive than the previous term. The majority of us are not on campus. We are relearning how to study in this environment. This is not a skill that could be acquired quickly over the span of the second half of the spring semester. It’s an exhausting process and the longer it extends the harder it becomes. For 12-16 years we learned how to learn and study a certain way, and now that system is being completely reimagined. Exams are no longer in quiet uninterrupted classrooms. We don’t have the freedom to move about campus and study in various locations, motivated by the studying of our peers. We don’t have access to the gym to help destress at the end of the day. The moments that we are living in, the constant outpouring of news that we are receiving does not allow students to make their studies their only priority.
Everything about this semester has changed. The pandemic has only gotten worse since we left campus. Educational institutions at all levels have to treat both their faculty and students with compassion. We are not in a normal academic year, therefore the traditional standards cannot possibly apply. One of the rationales behind returning to a traditional grading system is that professors received extensive training to teach in an online environment, and both faculty and students were aware of the method of instruction. We’re all aware that the professors are excellent at Muhlenberg, and their ability to pivot to an online environment demonstrates their excellence. Yet, there is little professors and students could control about the current circumstances that will make it a challenging semester for many students.
I think this issue comes down to equity and acknowledgement of the extenuating circumstances we’re all living through. If as an institution we are going to recognize that students at Muhlenberg come from different backgrounds, then the college should be aware that not everyone is going to have a fair shot to succeed in an online environment. Some at home are going to take care of issues they don’t typically have to worry about while at college. Now, it’s not the duty of professors to construct the lines of an equitable environment, that’s up to the college. When students are residing on campus, as most students that attend Muhlenberg do, we all are living in similar spaces, eating the same food, having access to the same facilities, and resources. That system no longer holds, therefore, having a safety net for students that may have less resources and more responsibilities at home is necessary.
MIT was one of the first institutions last semester that prioritized equity and the mental health of their students and many colleges followed. This semester they have again recognized that these are challenging times and approached it as such, with letter grades returning but a failing grade not being recorded on students transcripts. MIT is one among many institutions that have implemented some type of safety net for students this semester. The list includes: Bowdoin College, UNC, University of Michigan, DePaul, East Carolina University, Ohio State, etc. Muhlenberg graduates will be competing for jobs and spots at graduate institutions, our transcripts may be at a disadvantage compared to others because our college didn’t validate the necessity to restructure the way we test knowledge this semester.
I hope you consider extending optional pass/fail into the Fall 2020 semester, it is the equitable approach for a pandemic that is inequitable.
Petition Closed
The Issue
Dear Muhlenberg College,
In the spring semester, the college graciously offered students the option to pass/fail courses given that the semester had been disrupted abruptly. Yet I would argue that the Fall 2020 semester is equally as challenging if not more disruptive than the previous term. The majority of us are not on campus. We are relearning how to study in this environment. This is not a skill that could be acquired quickly over the span of the second half of the spring semester. It’s an exhausting process and the longer it extends the harder it becomes. For 12-16 years we learned how to learn and study a certain way, and now that system is being completely reimagined. Exams are no longer in quiet uninterrupted classrooms. We don’t have the freedom to move about campus and study in various locations, motivated by the studying of our peers. We don’t have access to the gym to help destress at the end of the day. The moments that we are living in, the constant outpouring of news that we are receiving does not allow students to make their studies their only priority.
Everything about this semester has changed. The pandemic has only gotten worse since we left campus. Educational institutions at all levels have to treat both their faculty and students with compassion. We are not in a normal academic year, therefore the traditional standards cannot possibly apply. One of the rationales behind returning to a traditional grading system is that professors received extensive training to teach in an online environment, and both faculty and students were aware of the method of instruction. We’re all aware that the professors are excellent at Muhlenberg, and their ability to pivot to an online environment demonstrates their excellence. Yet, there is little professors and students could control about the current circumstances that will make it a challenging semester for many students.
I think this issue comes down to equity and acknowledgement of the extenuating circumstances we’re all living through. If as an institution we are going to recognize that students at Muhlenberg come from different backgrounds, then the college should be aware that not everyone is going to have a fair shot to succeed in an online environment. Some at home are going to take care of issues they don’t typically have to worry about while at college. Now, it’s not the duty of professors to construct the lines of an equitable environment, that’s up to the college. When students are residing on campus, as most students that attend Muhlenberg do, we all are living in similar spaces, eating the same food, having access to the same facilities, and resources. That system no longer holds, therefore, having a safety net for students that may have less resources and more responsibilities at home is necessary.
MIT was one of the first institutions last semester that prioritized equity and the mental health of their students and many colleges followed. This semester they have again recognized that these are challenging times and approached it as such, with letter grades returning but a failing grade not being recorded on students transcripts. MIT is one among many institutions that have implemented some type of safety net for students this semester. The list includes: Bowdoin College, UNC, University of Michigan, DePaul, East Carolina University, Ohio State, etc. Muhlenberg graduates will be competing for jobs and spots at graduate institutions, our transcripts may be at a disadvantage compared to others because our college didn’t validate the necessity to restructure the way we test knowledge this semester.
I hope you consider extending optional pass/fail into the Fall 2020 semester, it is the equitable approach for a pandemic that is inequitable.
The Decision Makers
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on October 23, 2020