Petition updateRemoval of Sheldon Pollock as mentor and Chief Editor of Murty Classical LibraryTwenty statements from Sheldon Pollock on India, Hinduism and Sanskrit
Prof. Ganesh Ramakrishnan, Department of Computer Science and Engineering, IIT Bombay
Mar 4, 2016
Please read this article that highlights Sheldon Pollock's views clearly. http://indiafacts.org/twenty-statements-sheldon-pollock-india-hinduism-sanskrit/ Some key points: 1. Some might argue that as a learned language of intellectual discourse and belles lettres, Sanskrit had never been exactly alive in the first place. But the usual distinction in play here between living and dead languages is more than a little naive. It cannot accommodate the fact that all written languages are learned, and therefore in some sense frozen in time (“dead”); or, conversely, that such languages often are as supple and dynamically changing (“alive”) as so-called natural ones. Yet the assumption that Sanskrit was never alive has discouraged the attempt to grasp its later history; after all, what is born dead has no later history. As a result, there exist no good accounts or theorizations of the end of the cultural order that for two millennia exerted a trans-regional influence across Asia-South, Southeast, Inner, and even East Asia- that was unparalleled until the rise of Americanism and global English. We have no clear understanding of whether, and if so, when, Sanskrit culture ceased to make history; whether, and if so, why, it proved incapable of preserving into the present the creative vitality it displayed in earlier epochs, and what this loss of affectivity might reveal about those factors within the wider world of society and polity that had kept it vital. 2. At the end of the thirteenth and the beginning of the fourteenth centuries, several major cultic centers devoted to Rama are created or reinvigorated. 3. To infer from temples bearing Rama reliefs that a cult of Rama existed in the ninth and tenth centuries is not possible.
Copy link
WhatsApp
Facebook
Nextdoor
Email
X