Make Child Custody Court Orders Enforceable: Require Police to Investigate and Act

257

Let’s get to 500 signatures!
Petitions with 1,000+ supporters are 5x more likely to win!

The Issue

Make Child Custody Court Orders Enforceable: Require Police to Investigate and Act

Petition to the Indiana General Assembly, Governor of Indiana, and law enforcement leadership

Petition summary

A court order should mean something. Parents should not be left without a meaningful remedy when another parent knowingly violates a custody or parenting-time order. We call on Indiana lawmakers to require law enforcement to investigate qualifying complaints, document the outcome, and take legally required enforcement action when statutory conditions are met. We want clear rules, consistent responses, child-safety protections, and accountability. We will start in Indiana and work toward similar reforms nationwide.

The petition

Imagine having a valid court order establishing who has custody of your child, when your child must be returned, or when you are entitled to parenting time—only to be told by law enforcement that it is a civil matter.

For a parent whose child is being unlawfully withheld or who is repeatedly denied court-ordered parenting time, that response can leave them feeling powerless. They may have a valid order, documentation of the violation, and no clear understanding of how to obtain timely assistance.

Parents are expected to obey court orders. Children deserve stability, predictable routines, and relationships consistent with lawful custody arrangements. Yet families can find themselves caught between a court order that has been violated and an enforcement system that leaves them unsure where to turn.

A court order should not become meaningless simply because enforcing it is difficult.

This petition is not a demand to arrest every parent accused of violating an order. It is a demand for a consistent, legally defined response that does not automatically dismiss qualifying complaints simply because they involve custody or parenting time.

What needs to change?

We are calling on Indiana to establish a statewide custody-order enforcement framework that requires law enforcement to investigate qualifying complaints and take appropriate action when legal conditions are met.

Our legislative demands

1. Require investigation of qualifying complaints.

When someone presents a facially valid custody or parenting-time order and credible information indicating a violation, officers should be required to review the order, assess the reported circumstances, document the complaint, and determine the appropriate legal response. A complaint should not be dismissed solely because it involves a family-law matter.

2. Require enforcement when statutory conditions are met.

When an order is verified and the legal requirements for enforcement are satisfied, officers should be required to take the action prescribed by law. Depending on the circumstances, this may include facilitating compliance, referring suspected criminal conduct for prosecution, or executing a valid judicial warrant.

3. Address the unlawful withholding of children.

Establish clear procedures for situations in which a parent refuses to return a child or knowingly withholds a child in violation of a custody order. The law should define when direct law enforcement intervention is authorized and when expedited judicial assistance is necessary.

4. Address interference with court-ordered parenting time.

Create a defined process for investigating and documenting qualifying reports that a parent is knowingly and unjustifiably interfering with another parent's court-ordered parenting time. Repeated violations should have a meaningful path toward enforcement and appropriate remedies.

5. Establish consistent statewide procedures and training.

Require law enforcement agencies to adopt written procedures for verifying orders, documenting complaints, recognizing possible criminal conduct, handling conflicting orders, and determining when judicial authorization is required.

6. Provide timely access to judicial assistance.

When officers cannot lawfully resolve a violation without additional judicial authority, establish a clear and timely process for seeking that authority. Urgent cases involving credible risks of serious harm or unlawful removal should receive appropriate priority.

7. Protect children and prevent misuse.

Include safeguards for domestic violence, protective orders, credible safety concerns, unclear or conflicting orders, and bad-faith complaints. No parent should be able to use police intervention to bypass a judge's decision or obtain a custody arrangement that the court has not granted.

8. Require accountability and transparency.

Require agencies to document custody-order complaints and their dispositions. Appropriate public reporting should help lawmakers identify inconsistent practices, recurring barriers, and opportunities to improve enforcement.

A specific action we want lawmakers to take

We ask Indiana lawmakers to introduce legislation requiring law enforcement agencies to document and investigate qualifying custody-order complaints, provide a reasoned disposition, and take legally required enforcement action when statutory conditions are satisfied.

The legislation should define qualifying complaints, the information officers must review, the circumstances requiring enforcement, the situations requiring judicial authorization, and the safeguards necessary to protect children and families.

We ask the Indiana General Assembly to review existing law, consult with judges, law enforcement officers, prosecutors, family-law professionals, child advocates, and affected families, and develop a bill that closes enforcement gaps without compromising due process or child safety.

We ask the Governor to support these reforms and encourage coordination among the relevant state agencies and law enforcement organizations.

Why this matters

When a custody order is violated, the consequences can extend beyond a missed exchange. Children may experience uncertainty, disrupted routines, and conflict between the adults responsible for their care. Parents may lose time, income, and resources pursuing repeated court proceedings.

A meaningful enforcement system would give families a defined process, help officers understand their responsibilities, and preserve the authority of the courts that issue these orders.

Civil remedies and contempt proceedings remain important. But families should not have to guess whether an existing order can be enforced, which agency can help, or what steps must be taken next.

This is about children, not choosing sides.

This campaign is not about favoring mothers over fathers, custodial parents over noncustodial parents, or one side of a family dispute over another.

The same rules should apply fairly to everyone. Officers must respect valid protective orders, consider credible safety concerns, and follow the law rather than independently deciding disputed custody issues.

The goal is simple: clear standards, consistent responses, and meaningful enforcement when the law requires it.

Start in Indiana. Expand nationwide.

Indiana can be the starting point for a broader effort to establish clear, consistent standards for custody-order enforcement. Once a workable framework has been developed, we will encourage other states to review their laws and adopt appropriate enforcement procedures and safeguards.

We call on Indiana lawmakers to act, the Governor to support meaningful reform, and law enforcement leadership to help develop a practical system that works for children and families.

If a court order is valid, its terms should be respected. If it is violated, there should be a clear process for responding. And when the law requires enforcement, that duty should not be optional.

Sign this petition and help us call for meaningful change.

Court orders should have meaning. Children deserve stability. Families deserve a fair and effective enforcement process.

The Decision Makers

Mike Braun
Indiana Governor
Former Indiana House of Representatives
2 Members
Chris Jeter
Former Indiana House of Representatives - District 88
Gregory Steuerwald
Former Indiana House of Representatives - District 40
Indiana State Senate
5 Members
Aaron Freeman
Indiana State Senate - District 32
Eric Koch
Indiana State Senate - District 44
Indiana State Senate
Wendy McNamara
Indiana House of Representatives - District 76

Supporter Voices

Petition Updates