ENOUGH IS ENOUGH

Episode after episode of Season 5 of Project Runway All Stars we have witnessed Sam Donovan overtly flirting with Isaac Mizrahi openly on camera. Isaac Mizrahi has flirted shamelessly back.

Sam Donovan evaded elimination out of favoritism among the judges, specifically from Isaac Mizrahi. It is so obvious that the contestants have seen it, the viewers have seen it and the judges have commented on it earlier in the season. It is all anyone can talk about online. It has infuriated us time and time again.

After watching Episode 11 "State of the Art", we have had enough.

Emily Payne is an excellent designer with great technique and originality, that was sent home for a likable dress whose main critique was that it was too wearable and not avant garde enough. Sam was kept for a dress that was also "not avant garde enough", but also described as "panicked", "tortured", "mediocre" "pinned and tacked on" "a kite stuck in a tree". It was an objectively worse dress that was liked by only one judge.

At this point, either Isaac Mizrahi is suffering from blatant favoritism or poor taste and neither are acceptable for a judge on the show. The entire show has lost its credibility. We refuse to watch Project Runway with him as a judge.

As they say in fashion, 'one day you are in and the next day you are out'.

It is time for Mizrahi to be eliminated from the show.

Signed,
Fans and Viewers of Project Runway