Letter to President Garber
Letter to President Garber
The Issue
April 7, 2025
President Alan M. Garber
Office of the President
Massachusetts Hall
Harvard University
Cambridge, Massachusetts. 02138
Dear President Garber,
We are writing to plead that you not capitulate to the tyrannical demands of the current United States President. The $10 billion in unrestricted endowment exists to stand as a bulwark against existential threats. Our nation and the University face such a threat now, and the University should rely on its endowment now to stand firm for academic freedom and democracy and against fascism.
It is clear that kowtowing to this U.S. President only emboldens him to go further. The only way to deal with him is to say “no!”
We are a group of alumni and alumnae writing to urge you to join in collective action with the other Presidents of Ivy League and peer institutions to make a statement of solidarity in opposition to the U.S. President’s immoral, anti-American and illegal attacks on academic freedom and higher education. We understand these are fraught times and the delicacy of the circumstances. Elite institutions across the board - universities, law firms, corporations - are worried about preserving themselves. But this is a time for collective action and for courage. It is not a time for fear and the temptation to turn inward. We do not want future generations to look back at us and say, “why did no one stand up?” We do not want to be like Germans in the 1930’s. We do not want to be Ionesco’s rhinoceroses.
What does it mean to be the most elite university in the country, if not the world, if that position is not used to stand up when there is a crisis that jeopardizes our democracy and the very nature of the American project?
This is the time to use the unrestricted portion of the endowment - approximately $10 billion as of last year - if necessary. We know there are attacks coming at you from all directions, including legislative proposals to increase the excise tax on endowment income. And we applaud the University’s decision to offer free tuition to all students whose parents earn less than $200,000 a year.
But Harvard, and the rest of the Ivy League, should not cower in fear regarding federal funding. Harvard received approximately $700 million in government grants in 2024 - the unrestricted portion of the endowment could cover the hole left by the elimination of federal funding for the next four years. And the University can and should sue if the government cancels existing contracts.
Harvard should operate from a position of strength and courage. The more people bow down to the U.S. President, the more license he has to engage in dictatorial conduct.
There is strength in numbers. Laborers have known this for generations. Elite institutions must band together and say “No” in unison. They should help one another, if necessary, to preserve their independence even in the face of losing federal funding until the day when we can elect a new President who respects our nation’s ideals. Harvard is in a position to lead, and if it does, others will follow. There is strength in unity.
Sincerely yours,
Elizabeth Buckley Lewis, A.B ‘87, J.D ‘91
Lisa Dvorine Abrams, M.D., A.B. ‘87
Margaret Ackerly, A.B. ‘87
Jessica Ancker, A.B. ‘87
Charles Barzun, A.B. ‘97
Mary A. Berle, A.B. ‘87, M.Ed. ‘90
Maile Black, A.B. ‘87/’88
Lesley Blumenthal, A.B. ‘87
James R. Brown, J.D. ‘91
Louisa Burnham, A.B. ‘87
Margaret Cabot, A.B. ‘87
Yule Caise, A.B. ‘86/’87
Rebecca Carman, A.B. ‘87
Rebecca Carpenter, A.B. ‘87
James Carr, A.B. ‘87
Helen Chang, A.B. ‘87
Pang-Mei N. Chang, A.B. ‘87
Peggy Chou, A.B. ‘87
Charlene Chu, A.B. ‘87
Mary Clark, J.D. ‘91
Michael Cooperson, A.B. ‘87
Tom Doyle, A.B. ‘87
Jackie Ewenstein, A.B. ‘87
David Fisher, A.B. ‘87
Linda Flaherty Haltmaier, A.B. ‘87/’88
Jane F. Fogg, A.B. ‘87
Inigo Garcia-Bryce, A.B. ‘87
Jan Geniesse, A.B. ‘87
Ariela Gross, A.B. ‘87
Matthew S. Forsyth, A.B. ‘87/’88
Marissa Cheseborough Guijarro, A.B. ‘87
Pamela. J. Hagerty, A.B. ‘87
James Jonas Hamilton, A.B. ‘87
Deborah Hellman, J.D. ‘91
Jeffrey Hellman, J.D. ‘86
Ann Colin Herbst, A.B. ‘87
Alissa Hirshfeld, A.B. ‘87
Yi-Fun Hsueh, A.B. ‘87, J.D. ‘91
Kay Hwangbo, A.B. ‘87
Ellen Jovin, A.B. ‘87
Alice Kaswan, J.D. ‘91
Michael Katz, A.B. ‘87
Marianne Kimura, A.B. ‘87
Diane Klein, A.B. ‘87
Rebecca Kramnick, A.B. ‘87
Cori Krane, A.B. ‘87
Jennifer Landau-Carter, A.B. ‘87/’88
Paula Lawson Barksdale, A.B. ‘87
John B. Lawton III, A.B. ‘87
David LeLacheur, A.B. ‘87
Suzanne Litke, A.B. ‘87
Kim Little, A.B. ‘87
Elizabeth Losh, A.B. ‘87
Catherine Lunt, A.B. ‘87
Elizabeth Mason, A.B. ‘87
Richard McGill Murphy, A.B. ‘88
Hugh F. Murray III, A.B. ‘87
Tucker McGrady, A.B. ‘87
Holly Million, A.B. ‘87
Ben Mutschler, A.B. ‘87
Danny L. North, A.B. ‘87
Emily Nozick, A.B. ‘87
Angela L. Padilla, A.B. ‘87
Mari Park, A.B. ‘87, J.D. ‘91
Regan Ralph, A.B. ‘87
Mary Rasenberger, J.D. ‘89
Andrew Rigsby, A.B. ‘87
Cathy Ellen Rosenholtz, A.B. ‘87, MDiv ‘91
Lisa Rosowsky, A.B. ‘87
Paul Ryan, A.B. ‘87
Valerie Scoon, A.B. ‘87
Jessica Sewell, A.B. ‘87
Lauren Smith, A.B. ‘87
Colette St. Mary, A.B. ‘87
Mildred Steward, A.B. ‘87
Ashley Thompson, A.B. ‘87/’88
Anne Ueland Bailey, A.B. ‘87
Elizabeth Umlas, A.B. ‘87
Steven E. Young, A.B. ‘87
Juliette Zener, A.B. ‘87/’88, MTS, ‘94

35
The Issue
April 7, 2025
President Alan M. Garber
Office of the President
Massachusetts Hall
Harvard University
Cambridge, Massachusetts. 02138
Dear President Garber,
We are writing to plead that you not capitulate to the tyrannical demands of the current United States President. The $10 billion in unrestricted endowment exists to stand as a bulwark against existential threats. Our nation and the University face such a threat now, and the University should rely on its endowment now to stand firm for academic freedom and democracy and against fascism.
It is clear that kowtowing to this U.S. President only emboldens him to go further. The only way to deal with him is to say “no!”
We are a group of alumni and alumnae writing to urge you to join in collective action with the other Presidents of Ivy League and peer institutions to make a statement of solidarity in opposition to the U.S. President’s immoral, anti-American and illegal attacks on academic freedom and higher education. We understand these are fraught times and the delicacy of the circumstances. Elite institutions across the board - universities, law firms, corporations - are worried about preserving themselves. But this is a time for collective action and for courage. It is not a time for fear and the temptation to turn inward. We do not want future generations to look back at us and say, “why did no one stand up?” We do not want to be like Germans in the 1930’s. We do not want to be Ionesco’s rhinoceroses.
What does it mean to be the most elite university in the country, if not the world, if that position is not used to stand up when there is a crisis that jeopardizes our democracy and the very nature of the American project?
This is the time to use the unrestricted portion of the endowment - approximately $10 billion as of last year - if necessary. We know there are attacks coming at you from all directions, including legislative proposals to increase the excise tax on endowment income. And we applaud the University’s decision to offer free tuition to all students whose parents earn less than $200,000 a year.
But Harvard, and the rest of the Ivy League, should not cower in fear regarding federal funding. Harvard received approximately $700 million in government grants in 2024 - the unrestricted portion of the endowment could cover the hole left by the elimination of federal funding for the next four years. And the University can and should sue if the government cancels existing contracts.
Harvard should operate from a position of strength and courage. The more people bow down to the U.S. President, the more license he has to engage in dictatorial conduct.
There is strength in numbers. Laborers have known this for generations. Elite institutions must band together and say “No” in unison. They should help one another, if necessary, to preserve their independence even in the face of losing federal funding until the day when we can elect a new President who respects our nation’s ideals. Harvard is in a position to lead, and if it does, others will follow. There is strength in unity.
Sincerely yours,
Elizabeth Buckley Lewis, A.B ‘87, J.D ‘91
Lisa Dvorine Abrams, M.D., A.B. ‘87
Margaret Ackerly, A.B. ‘87
Jessica Ancker, A.B. ‘87
Charles Barzun, A.B. ‘97
Mary A. Berle, A.B. ‘87, M.Ed. ‘90
Maile Black, A.B. ‘87/’88
Lesley Blumenthal, A.B. ‘87
James R. Brown, J.D. ‘91
Louisa Burnham, A.B. ‘87
Margaret Cabot, A.B. ‘87
Yule Caise, A.B. ‘86/’87
Rebecca Carman, A.B. ‘87
Rebecca Carpenter, A.B. ‘87
James Carr, A.B. ‘87
Helen Chang, A.B. ‘87
Pang-Mei N. Chang, A.B. ‘87
Peggy Chou, A.B. ‘87
Charlene Chu, A.B. ‘87
Mary Clark, J.D. ‘91
Michael Cooperson, A.B. ‘87
Tom Doyle, A.B. ‘87
Jackie Ewenstein, A.B. ‘87
David Fisher, A.B. ‘87
Linda Flaherty Haltmaier, A.B. ‘87/’88
Jane F. Fogg, A.B. ‘87
Inigo Garcia-Bryce, A.B. ‘87
Jan Geniesse, A.B. ‘87
Ariela Gross, A.B. ‘87
Matthew S. Forsyth, A.B. ‘87/’88
Marissa Cheseborough Guijarro, A.B. ‘87
Pamela. J. Hagerty, A.B. ‘87
James Jonas Hamilton, A.B. ‘87
Deborah Hellman, J.D. ‘91
Jeffrey Hellman, J.D. ‘86
Ann Colin Herbst, A.B. ‘87
Alissa Hirshfeld, A.B. ‘87
Yi-Fun Hsueh, A.B. ‘87, J.D. ‘91
Kay Hwangbo, A.B. ‘87
Ellen Jovin, A.B. ‘87
Alice Kaswan, J.D. ‘91
Michael Katz, A.B. ‘87
Marianne Kimura, A.B. ‘87
Diane Klein, A.B. ‘87
Rebecca Kramnick, A.B. ‘87
Cori Krane, A.B. ‘87
Jennifer Landau-Carter, A.B. ‘87/’88
Paula Lawson Barksdale, A.B. ‘87
John B. Lawton III, A.B. ‘87
David LeLacheur, A.B. ‘87
Suzanne Litke, A.B. ‘87
Kim Little, A.B. ‘87
Elizabeth Losh, A.B. ‘87
Catherine Lunt, A.B. ‘87
Elizabeth Mason, A.B. ‘87
Richard McGill Murphy, A.B. ‘88
Hugh F. Murray III, A.B. ‘87
Tucker McGrady, A.B. ‘87
Holly Million, A.B. ‘87
Ben Mutschler, A.B. ‘87
Danny L. North, A.B. ‘87
Emily Nozick, A.B. ‘87
Angela L. Padilla, A.B. ‘87
Mari Park, A.B. ‘87, J.D. ‘91
Regan Ralph, A.B. ‘87
Mary Rasenberger, J.D. ‘89
Andrew Rigsby, A.B. ‘87
Cathy Ellen Rosenholtz, A.B. ‘87, MDiv ‘91
Lisa Rosowsky, A.B. ‘87
Paul Ryan, A.B. ‘87
Valerie Scoon, A.B. ‘87
Jessica Sewell, A.B. ‘87
Lauren Smith, A.B. ‘87
Colette St. Mary, A.B. ‘87
Mildred Steward, A.B. ‘87
Ashley Thompson, A.B. ‘87/’88
Anne Ueland Bailey, A.B. ‘87
Elizabeth Umlas, A.B. ‘87
Steven E. Young, A.B. ‘87
Juliette Zener, A.B. ‘87/’88, MTS, ‘94

The Decision Makers
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on April 7, 2025