Dear Supporters,

We’re thrilled to let you know that our petition has almost reached 1,000 signatures, thanks to your incredible support! Every name added strengthens our message to city leaders that preserving open access to Phoenix’s trails is a priority for our community. Please continue sharing this petition with friends, family, and anyone else who might be impacted by these changes. Together, we can raise awareness and work to shape policies that honor both safety and access.

In conversations over the past few days, both with supporters and some who may not initially understand our perspective, a few key points have emerged that resonate with people on both sides of the issue. Below are some of the insights and “food for thought” ideas that you may find helpful as you discuss this issue with others.

 Talking Points and Food for Thought

1. Let’s Flip the Script: Imagine a seasoned desert dweller from Phoenix traveling to Minnesota to try ice fishing, only to be unprepared for the freezing temperatures and end up in a dangerous situation. Would Minnesotans, who are experienced and prepared for the cold, impose a resident ban on ice fishing due to the mistakes of visitors? It’s unlikely. In Phoenix, our trails are a natural and integral part of life, and blanket restrictions punish locals for risks taken by the inexperienced. We must advocate for policies that protect freedoms rather than restrict everyone’s access based on the actions of a few.

2. Holding Individuals Accountable: Just as we don’t ask all residents to stop driving when it rains—despite flash flood warnings from the NWS—we shouldn’t restrict all trail users based on potential risks. Instead, Arizona has specific laws, like the Stupid Motorist Law, that hold individuals accountable for risky decisions. We should seek similar accountability on trails, allowing experienced outdoor enthusiasts access while encouraging personal responsibility.

3. Support Driven by Lack of Understanding: Support for restrictions often comes from those who may not regularly use trails or fully appreciate their importance. Those unaffected by the closures may not recognize the vital role trails play in community well-being, fitness, and mental health. This skewed perspective can lead to policies that don’t accurately represent the interests of those most affected.

4. Personal Bias Against Outdoor Enthusiasts: People who don’t regularly use the trails may view outdoor activities only through a lens of risk, which can lead to a bias against the needs of those who rely on these spaces for health and recreation. This bias has a real impact, unfairly influencing decisions that limit the freedoms of active residents.

5. Disproportionate Impact on Outdoor Enthusiasts: These policies restrict outdoor enthusiasts—many of whom are well-prepared, responsible, and highly knowledgeable about managing the desert terrain—while favoring those less familiar with trail use. For these residents, trails are essential to maintaining physical and mental health, so policies that close trails disproportionately affect this population.

6. Mountain Rescues as Essential Public Service: Even before unions became involved, our Fire Chief in 2019 highlighted that mountain rescues are a vital public service, much like responding to highway accidents or medical emergencies. Mountain rescues uphold the city’s commitment to safety and quality of life, especially for residents who consider trails part of their daily lives. This is part of the city’s dedication to customer service for all citizens, and it reinforces our right to enjoy these unique outdoor spaces.

We will continue to gather support and make our voices heard in this uphill battle. Together, we’re aiming to bring valuable feedback to the city, Parks and Recreation, and other relevant boards and advisory groups. Please also consider reaching out to your City Council representatives by email or phone to help reinforce the importance of this issue.

Thank you for your passion, engagement, and commitment to keeping our trails accessible for all Phoenicians.

Warm and HOT regards,
AJ
Free Trails for All Phoenicians