Justice for Deborah Murphy (Our Nanny): Demand Reconsideration

1,053

The Issue

On May 17, 2026, our beloved Nanny, Deborah Ann Murphy, was killed while walking through a marked crosswalk outside a Publix in Panama City, Florida.

She was healthy, full of life, and deeply loved by everyone who knew her. To all of us, she was simply Nanny. She was our safe place, our guiding hand, and the heart of our family. She had so much life left to live, so much love left to give, and so many memories left to make.

She was doing something every one of us does without a second thought: walking out of the grocery store on an ordinary Sunday afternoon.

She never made it home.

As Deborah crossed a marked pedestrian crosswalk in broad daylight, the driver of an SUV began reversing toward the crosswalk. He struck her, knocked her to the ground, and kept reversing. The rear wheels and then the front wheels of his vehicle ran over her.

She died from her injuries.

Nearly six months later, on November 13, 2026, the Office of the State Attorney for Florida's Fourteenth Judicial Circuit announced that it would not pursue criminal charges against the driver, Carlos Suarez Contreras.

The State Attorney's Office expressly acknowledged that Mr. Suarez Contreras operated his vehicle negligently, that his driving caused Deborah's death, and that his conduct was "certainly careless and dangerous." Even so, prosecutors concluded that his actions did not meet the legal standard for vehicular homicide. 

We fundamentally disagree with that decision. We believe the circumstances surrounding it raise serious questions that deserve answers.

Our family has spoken publicly about the heartbreak of losing Deborah and the unanswered questions surrounding the decision not to prosecute. We encourage you to watch our interview to hear firsthand why we are continuing to fight for answers and accountability.

Why This Decision Deserves Reconsideration

1. The circumstances of her death warrant closer scrutiny.

Deborah was walking in a marked pedestrian crosswalk. According to the crash report, Mr. Suarez Contreras's vision was unobstructed, and Deborah did nothing improper.

The surveillance footage our family has seen shows Deborah in the crosswalk, in plain view, while the SUV reversed toward her. It then shows the vehicle striking her and continuing to reverse until both sets of wheels had passed over her.

Florida law prohibits backing a vehicle unless the maneuver can be completed safely.

Yet prosecutors concluded that the driver's conduct was not reckless enough to support a vehicular homicide charge. We believe that conclusion should be reconsidered in light of all the circumstances. 

2. Significant questions remain about the investigation.

Based on the investigative records and information provided to our family:

  • Mr. Suarez Contreras  was not tested for alcohol or drugs.
  • His cellphone records were not obtained, even though the crash report coded him as "inattentive.".
  • Only one independent witness was interviewed.
  • An off-duty first responder who gave Deborah emergency aid was never interviewed or contacted, even after our family identified him to prosecutors.
  • A Publix employee who photographed the scene and the driver's vehicle was not interviewed, and her photographs were not obtained, as far as our family has been told.
  • The surveillance footage provided to our family ends while emergency aid is still being given to Deborah. That raises questions about whether additional footage was recorded, preserved, or obtained. No body-camera footage has been provided, and it remains unclear whether any exists.

How can prosecutors confidently conclude that the evidence is insufficient when potentially relevant evidence was never collected?

3. The official records contain significant discrepancies and unanswered questions.

The prosecution's memorandum relies on a reconstruction estimating the vehicle's speed at four to five miles per hour. Yet the original crash report lists an estimated speed of 15 miles per hour. Our family believes this discrepancy warrants a clear explanation.

The arrest affidavit's description of the sequence of events also differs from what our family saw in the surveillance footage.

Questions also remain concerning the driver's license records and about the driver's actions immediately after the collision.

These discrepancies should be investigated and reconciled before the case is treated as closed.

4. Time may be running out.

After the decision not to prosecute, the driver was released from state custody and transferred to federal immigration custody.

If he is removed from the United States before charges are filed, it may become impossible to hold him accountable in Florida.

That is why prompt reconsideration is so important.

What We Are Asking

We call upon State Attorney Larry Basford and the Office of the State Attorney for Florida's Fourteenth Judicial Circuit to:

  1. Immediately reconsider the November 13, 2026, decision not to prosecute, and determine whether criminal charges are warranted based on a complete and accurate record.
  2. Reopen and complete the investigation. That means pursuing the outstanding evidence, interviewing the witnesses who were never contacted, resolving the discrepancies in the existing record, and confirming that all surveillance and body-camera footage has been preserved.
  3. Conduct a thorough reassessment of potential criminal charges, including vehicular homicide and the applicable driver's-license offense.
  4. Take every legally appropriate step to preserve the possibility of prosecution, including filing charges and lodging a Florida detainer with federal immigration authorities, so the driver is not removed before this case is resolved.
  5. Give our family a substantive explanation of the charging decision and an opportunity to meet with prosecutors to discuss the unresolved questions.

She Deserved Better

Deborah's life was so much bigger than the tragedy that took her from us. Long before her name appeared in headlines and legal documents, she was the heart of our family. Our Nanny.

She was an extraordinary woman who loved deeply and was loved just as fiercely in return. She was supposed to have so many more years with us: more birthdays, more holidays, more ordinary Sunday afternoons, and more moments with the family she meant everything to.

Instead, we are left grieving a loss that never should have happened.

We understand that criminal charges must be supported by sufficient evidence and that prosecutors have an obligation to exercise independent judgment.

But prosecutorial discretion is not beyond scrutiny. A decision of this magnitude deserves to rest on a thorough investigation, a reliable factual record, and a careful application of the law.

We are asking for accountability, transparency, and a meaningful reconsideration of a decision that has left our family with profound unanswered questions.

We cannot bring Deborah back. But we can continue fighting for answers, for accountability, and for the justice we believe she deserves.

Read More: News Coverage and Official Documents

We encourage everyone to learn more about her story, the circumstances of her death, and the decision not to pursue criminal charges.

News headlines and articles reflect the reporting and word choices of each outlet, not our family's own statements.

We believe the public deserves to understand not only what happened to her, but also why our family continues to question the decision not to prosecute.

With your support, we can demand that her death receive the thorough investigation, careful consideration, and meaningful accountability it deserves.

Please sign this petition and share her story. Every signature adds another voice calling on State Attorney Larry Basford to reconsider this decision, address the unanswered questions, and ensure that justice is not abandoned.

Justice for Nanny.

The Decision Makers

Larry Basford
Florida State Attorney - Circuit 14

Supporter Voices

Petition Updates