Include Nurses in India's National Task Force for Better Working Conditions

13,483

The Issue

To,

 

Shri. Jagat Prakash Nadda.

Honarable Minister

Ministry of Health and Family Welfare .

Governemnt of India,

New Delhi 

AND 

Dr. (Mrs.) Deepika Cecil Khakha,

Nursing Advisor to Govt of India, Ministry of Health &Family Welfare,

Gol, Room No. 156-A, 

Nirman Bhawan, 

New Delhi - 110011.

 

Subject :  Urgent need of Visibility and Inclusion in National Task Force to formulate effective recommendations to remedy the issues of concern pertaining to “the safety,working conditions and wellbeing of healthcare workers”

 

Honarable Sir and Madam,

 

India has approx 35 lakh registered nurses , 13 lakh allopathy doctors and around 5 lakh ayush doctors with addition of 13 lakh allied healthcare professionals. Nurses have  majority among healthcare professional of India but are made invisible by the system. Currently around 70 percent of healthcare work force is made up of women workforce and represent around 90% frontline workers globally, but unfortunately hold a quarter of leadership positions.

 

The National Task force set up by Supreme Court for  hospital safety doesn’t have a single nurse representative. Sir, we are  majority in number among the healthcare professionals 35 lakhs and work 24 x 7 in hospitals and public health services in community. Nursing profession though dominated by women has men also who equally need safe and secured work environments. How can nurses strength in numbers and quality work be so invisible by Government and Supreme Court that they are not on decision making committees.? Nursing being a female oriented profession has been facing Gender bias , Patriarchy, social stigma , hierarchies issues , dominance by administrative and medical professionals, hegemonies as few  challenges  since long and during pandemic every newspaper has captured these challenges. 

 

We  all know healthcare is delivered by women and lead by men as per the WGH and WHO report . We need employee centric and patient centric policies for sure . 

 

Since Pandemic we have seen that demand for Healthcare  services is shooting high, many promoter driven healthcare services are now big profiteering corporates hospital facilities as rotors are high almost 17- 20 percent and no recession. So lots of funder for private sector and public health services are getting privatised . Contractual labour is the norm with  no or poor working facilities or benefits. 

 

Rate of Migration of skilled healthcare workers is soaring high as demand is rising for sure but in parallel we have shortage of skilled healthcare workers in India . We can’t ignore the fact that 70 % of our workforce is women so the gaps and challenges in their supply cannot be closed without addressing gender dynamics of healthcare work force. The barriers what women HCW face will not be faced by male HCW, period . This is a global issue and all international organisations are working on it be it WHO, ILO , WGH …. etc . We need to work on policy level with gender transformative approach. It is well known fact that nurses, doctors, other women workers are under paid , workplace has immense gender bias , discrimination and inequities, sexual assault and harassment are rising but are not reported or recorded anywhere , unfortunately gender disparities are widening. 

 

In hospital administration and policy offices males are dominating senior, higher status , higher paid jobs and hardly women have space to grow up the ladder on top positions.  Women who rise up have lots pressures  and have to be yes boss types  to maintain their jobs. Workplace violence and sexual harassment is faced by women from male workers and often they are not recorded due to fear and stigma  as said earlier .  I am sure many of us  now want to change the narrative, we nurses are the majority in HCW  33 lakh in India who are legally registered and many more who are not registered but do nursing work in small hospitals and clinics .  But are completely invisible and excluded from decision making process. National task forces never have nurses which a pity as nurses are 24x7 managing both sides patients and administration  and third side is their domestic responsibilities. 

 

Women  definitely are the drivers of global health. But, we systematically get or are made invisible and ignored by the power holders. So, we need policies which will stop the attempts to fix the women healthcare workers into inequitable systems. High time we fix the systems first . Safety outcomes are as important as top lines of healthcare business. We need budgets for assuring our safety and security . 

 

Nurses are backbone of healthcare and also are  mirrors of hospitals.  The nurses were not included in any national or state task force during pandemic but were asked to provide healthcare services 24 x 7. Majority of our nurses work in private hospitals where safety concerns are major issues. Nursing work environment is found to be unhealthy in majority of organisations. If nurses are not safe and then how can the patients be safe ? Many nurses  lost their lives in private sector during pandemic  but none were paid any compensation. 

 

We need to make nurses visible in the system for safe patient care. Nursing is a social and clinical responsibility so their representatives must be there in all decisions making bodies related to healthcare.

 

We very humbly request the supreme court and respected Government authorities to always create space for nurses in decisions making bodies. Please include nurses in National Task Force to , create safety protocols, strengthen healthcare system and provide quality care to patients in safe working environments . 

 

Our humble demands for our safety and security is healthy nurse work environments.

 

1.    Zero tolerance of any misbehaviour with nurses by male colleagues or superiors

 

2.    POSH and ICC must be followed strictly followed 

 

3.    Gender audits and budget are mandatory; hence must be operationalises in the hospitals, nursing homes and health centres. 

 

4.    Physical infrastructure like changing rooms, rest rooms, hostels, work areas of nurses’ working environment as safe and secured .

 

5.    Transport facilities provided during evening and night shifts to nurses.

 

6.    Proper CCTV camera are installed and must be functioning.

 

7.    Grievance redressal cells at local organisational level and state level needed.

 

8.    Insurance coverage for physical and mental conditions .

 

9.    Stop Contractual recruitments of nurses.

 

10. Equal work equal pay needs to followed

 

11. Nurse representatives who are vocal must be part of every healthcare committee on state and national levels.

 

We believe that everyone among healthcare professional team has the right to attain equal levels of recognition, participation, decision making regardless professional hierarchies, or gender this will help to  get ideas, innovations, expertise and talent. We advocate for equal representation of nurses in decision making roles across healthcare sector on national levels, especially as they represent the vast majority in healthcare team. 

 

According to a study by the Trained Nurses' Association of India, over 60% of nurses report feelings of exhaustion, 50% face workplace violence, and 22% experienced discrimination (TNAI, 2018). These stats highlight the urgency and magnitude of the problems faced by these heroes in scrubs in our country.

 

It is time that India wakes up to the plight of our nurses. We vehemently urge the government to integrate nurses into the National Task Force to leverage their unique insights, experiences, and contributions in formulating effective policies to remedy work conditions. Let us give our nurses the voice they rightly deserve in shaping their own profession.

 

Please sign and share this petition if you agree that our nurses' voices matter as we strive to better the working conditions within the healthcare sector. Let's be the change we long to see.

 

 

 

(The draft is prepared by Dr Swati S Rane, Founder Vice President Clinical Nursing Research Society, India. Ceo – SevaShakti Healthcare Consultancy,Mumbai.)

 

C.C:

 

1.⁠ ⁠Smt. Anupriya Patel, Minister of State, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare,

 

Nirman

 

Bhavan, New

 

Delhi-110011.

 

2.⁠ ⁠Shri. Apurva Chandra, Secretary (H&FW), Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Room No. 156 A, Nirman Bhavan, New Delhi- 110011.

 

3.⁠ ⁠Ms. V. Hekali Zhimomi, Additional Secretary, 254-Wing A / 6th Floor Chandra Lok Building, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Nirman Bhawan.

 

4.⁠ ⁠Dr. (Mrs.) Deepika Cecil Khakha, Nursing Advisor to Govt of India, Ministry of Health &Family Welfare, Gol, Room No. 156-A, Nirman Bhawan, New Delhi - 110011.

 

5.⁠ ⁠Ms. Achala Kumar, ADG(Nursing), Ph.D Nursing, Nursing Division Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India, New Delhi 110011.

 

Endorsed By 

 

1. Dr. Swati Rane .

 

RN, TNAI member, VP Clinical Nursing ResearchSociety , Ceo Sevashakti, Alumni of Tarangan  (LT college of Nursing)                                                                            

 

2. ⁠Mr. Rajabhau P. Rathod. President TNAI Maharashtra State.

 

3. ⁠Arun GS 

 

President Dr rml hospital nurses union.Core committee central government nurse's federation.General secretary Indian professional nurses association.

 

4.Mr Binu Joe . Founder President Nursing Scholar Society.

 

5.Mr Jibin T Chalil , National Working Secretary and Maharashtra State President of United Nurses 

 

6.Dr Annu Kaushik Nursing Director with Cloudnine Group of Hospitals.

 

7.Prof. (Dr) Anjana Williams 

 

Principal Himalayiya College of Nursing Sparsh Himalaya University Dehradun.

 

8.Dr Shobha Gaikwad , TNAI chairperson - Nursing Education, Associate Professor in LT college of Nursing and senior nursing leader

 

9.Dr. Shabana Azmi Malik 

 

Principal 

 

Kingston imperial institute of medical sciences Dunga Dehradun Uttarakhand

 

10.Prof.Jasvir Kaur Principal/Director College Of Nursing, A.I.M.S, SRI MUKTSAR SAHIB-PUNJAB

 

11.Prof.(Dr.) Virendra Singh Choudhary, Principal Smt. Vidyawati College of Nursing, Jhansi, Uttar Pradesh, Founder President UIJIR Academic Research Foundation.

 

12.Prof(Dr) Bimla Kapoor, Former Director and Professor School of Health Sciences, IGNOU, Chairperson of NNMC Bill,                                                                                                               13.Prof Archana Masih 

 

Principal, 

 

Doon institute of medical sciences Dehradun Uttarakhand.                                                 14.Snehlata Tripathi 

 

Principal, 

 

Vinayak institute of nursing and paramedical sciences,Bijnor, 

 

Lucknow, Uttarpradesh.                                                                                                            15.Dr.Sunita Choubey 

 

Nursing Officer

 

Hamidia Hospital Gandhi Medical College Bhopal,M.P.                                                            16.Renuka Silas

 

Principal of Aryans Institute of Nursing

 

Chandigarh.President NTAI

 

17.Madam Pity KoulNursing Teachers Association India Also 

 

President of  PNNFI  SOMI NRSI  Annie.                                                                                                18.Dr. Bharati E. Peters 

 

Retd. Nurse Supervisor,

 

Dubai Hospital.                                                                                                                                            Government of Dubai.                                                                                                                            19. Dr Rita Lakhani                                                                                            

 

Chairperson Byelaws                                                                                              

 

20.D.Maryline Flinsi 

 

Principal 

 

Apollo school of Nursing 

 

Apollo Hospital ,NewDelhi                                                                                      

 

21.Deepika K 

 

Research Nurse

 

JIPMER                                                                                                         

 

22.Vandana

 

Deputy Nursing Superintendent

 

AIIMS Rishikesh.                                                                                                      

 

23.Dr. Harmeet Kaur Kang

 

Director & Principal,

 

Chitkara School of Health Sciences,  Chitkara University, Punjab      

 

24.Dr Gitumoni Konwar,

 

Team Lead, Jhpiego, India. Former Director, Faculty of Nursing, Assam down town University

 

25.Dr NASEEMA SHAFQAT

 

ASST PROFESSOR Nursing College AIIMS Bhopal                                        

 

26.Bk Rupa Upadhye. Chief of Nursing  services, J.W.Global Hospital & Research Centre, Mount Abu, Rajasthan                                                                                       

 

27.Prof. Emeritus Dr. S. Narula-Khanna

 

28.⁠ ⁠Dr. Mariamma Sen

 

29.Ms. Molly Sam

 

30.Ms. Prachi Sahni 

 

31.⁠Miss Stuti Mcawen 

 

32.Mrs. Usha Rai

 

33. M.Maheshwary.

 

       Principal 

 

       Chitkara University 

 

            Baddi , HP.

 

34. Prof Jagadessh V

 

      Principal 

 

      Institute of Public Health and Hygiene College of Nursing .

 

      Jammu.

 

 

 



Dr Swati RanePetition Starter

Supporter Voices

Petition Updates