

Include ALL Key Mixers For Sound Mixing Emmy Categories
The Issue
Every year, countless TV projects are submitted for Emmys recognition across multiple categories and generally recognize all of the key players within every given category.
Unfortunately, when it comes to Sound Mixing, many important mixers are completely left off the ballot because the Sound Mixing branch only allows a maximum of 4 mixers to be included on each project submission. Each of the typically 1-2 Re-Recording Mixers and the Production Sound Mixer are always included by default, often leaving only 1 slot available. As a result, it’s typically left to one of the Re-Recording Mixers to make the difficult and unnecessary decision of choosing if the ADR, Foley, or Scoring Mixer are worthy of inclusion, leaving the other mixers without any recognition for their contributions. Are we therefore to assume that only 1 of these 3 mixers are worthy of recognition and that the work of the other 2 just wasn’t important enough for inclusion?
Perhaps years ago there were fewer mixers working on a given project when TV shows featured less dramatic and large production styles so this rule made more sense. But in the golden age of Television that we now find ourselves in, many TV productions are much more akin to a film production, meaning the teams in many departments are often larger.
Scoring Mixers, for example, were often not needed for sitcoms and simpler productions as the music would be delivered to the dub stage straight from the composer’s writing studio given that there was no live orchestra recorded. However, many many more productions are now in need of skilled Scoring Mixers due to the production of these scores becoming much more cinematic, often featuring live orchestral recordings that need mixing before hitting the dub stage. With this strict 4 mixer limit, the Scoring Mixer is often left without recognition alongside 1 of the other 3 mixers who aren’t included due to this prohibitive rule.
Foley mixers were sometimes not needed or used on simpler or lower budget TV productions, with the Sound Editors just editing foley effects from a sound effects library. But for the more complicated and dense soundscapes we often hear today, should the Foley Mixer really be not recognized for their contributions?
If you look over at the sister Sound Editing branch, we find that editors from all 3 categories of sound are regularly included with far more than 4 editors on each submission. ADR, Foley, and Music Editors are often on the Sound Editing submission alongside the Supervising Sound Editor and the other key Sound Editors and Designers.
Stranger Things, the winner of the Emmy for Outstanding Sound Editing For A Comedy Or Drama Series (One Hour) celebrated 10 editors, of which 2 were Foley Editors and 2 were Music Editors. The show also won for Sound Mixing, but only the 3 Re-Recording Mixers and the Production Sound Mixer were recognized for their work. For a show with such a complicated and dense sound job as Stranger Things (requiring an unusual 3 Re-Recording Mixers), were the contributions of the Foley, ADR, and Scoring Mixer (assuming they were used) really not worthy of recognition just because of an arbitrary limit?
As it stands, to include a 4th mixer who isn’t a Re-Recording or Production Mixer on a submission always requires a petition from the submitting mixer to verify the merits of the mixer to be included. That system very likely should remain to ensure that only mixers who made significant contributions to the project are included.
But why only allow 1? There are a multitude of shows produced every year that require skilled ADR, Foley, and Scoring Mixers to get the final sound of the show to sound its best. Sure, there are often more Sound Editors than Mixers working on a given production so the Editing categories naturally will include more people but why intentionally snub up to 2 of the important mixers?
We humbly ask that the governors of the Sound Mixing branch reconsider their limiting 4 mixer rule for submissions given the ever changing and expanding level of sound production that we often see for Television shows and movies.
If more than 4 editors can be recognized, why not more than 4 mixers?

134
The Issue
Every year, countless TV projects are submitted for Emmys recognition across multiple categories and generally recognize all of the key players within every given category.
Unfortunately, when it comes to Sound Mixing, many important mixers are completely left off the ballot because the Sound Mixing branch only allows a maximum of 4 mixers to be included on each project submission. Each of the typically 1-2 Re-Recording Mixers and the Production Sound Mixer are always included by default, often leaving only 1 slot available. As a result, it’s typically left to one of the Re-Recording Mixers to make the difficult and unnecessary decision of choosing if the ADR, Foley, or Scoring Mixer are worthy of inclusion, leaving the other mixers without any recognition for their contributions. Are we therefore to assume that only 1 of these 3 mixers are worthy of recognition and that the work of the other 2 just wasn’t important enough for inclusion?
Perhaps years ago there were fewer mixers working on a given project when TV shows featured less dramatic and large production styles so this rule made more sense. But in the golden age of Television that we now find ourselves in, many TV productions are much more akin to a film production, meaning the teams in many departments are often larger.
Scoring Mixers, for example, were often not needed for sitcoms and simpler productions as the music would be delivered to the dub stage straight from the composer’s writing studio given that there was no live orchestra recorded. However, many many more productions are now in need of skilled Scoring Mixers due to the production of these scores becoming much more cinematic, often featuring live orchestral recordings that need mixing before hitting the dub stage. With this strict 4 mixer limit, the Scoring Mixer is often left without recognition alongside 1 of the other 3 mixers who aren’t included due to this prohibitive rule.
Foley mixers were sometimes not needed or used on simpler or lower budget TV productions, with the Sound Editors just editing foley effects from a sound effects library. But for the more complicated and dense soundscapes we often hear today, should the Foley Mixer really be not recognized for their contributions?
If you look over at the sister Sound Editing branch, we find that editors from all 3 categories of sound are regularly included with far more than 4 editors on each submission. ADR, Foley, and Music Editors are often on the Sound Editing submission alongside the Supervising Sound Editor and the other key Sound Editors and Designers.
Stranger Things, the winner of the Emmy for Outstanding Sound Editing For A Comedy Or Drama Series (One Hour) celebrated 10 editors, of which 2 were Foley Editors and 2 were Music Editors. The show also won for Sound Mixing, but only the 3 Re-Recording Mixers and the Production Sound Mixer were recognized for their work. For a show with such a complicated and dense sound job as Stranger Things (requiring an unusual 3 Re-Recording Mixers), were the contributions of the Foley, ADR, and Scoring Mixer (assuming they were used) really not worthy of recognition just because of an arbitrary limit?
As it stands, to include a 4th mixer who isn’t a Re-Recording or Production Mixer on a submission always requires a petition from the submitting mixer to verify the merits of the mixer to be included. That system very likely should remain to ensure that only mixers who made significant contributions to the project are included.
But why only allow 1? There are a multitude of shows produced every year that require skilled ADR, Foley, and Scoring Mixers to get the final sound of the show to sound its best. Sure, there are often more Sound Editors than Mixers working on a given production so the Editing categories naturally will include more people but why intentionally snub up to 2 of the important mixers?
We humbly ask that the governors of the Sound Mixing branch reconsider their limiting 4 mixer rule for submissions given the ever changing and expanding level of sound production that we often see for Television shows and movies.
If more than 4 editors can be recognized, why not more than 4 mixers?

The Decision Makers
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on June 27, 2023