In January 2025, the DNR announced plans to lease 420 acres of state-managed forestland in Otsego County to RWE Clean Energy for a solar development project. This area was adjacent to an existing 1,000-acre solar project on private land. The DNR's Director, Scott Bowen, stated that the location was chosen due to its proximity to a high-voltage transmission line and existing solar developments, aiming to contribute to Michigan's clean energy goals. 

The proposal sparked immediate backlash from various stakeholders:

• Legislative Opposition: Over 50 Republican state representatives and one Democrat, Rep. Karen Whitsett, demanded accountability from the DNR, criticizing the plan as a misuse of public land and calling for firings within the department. 
• Environmental Concerns: Critics argued that the forested land was vital wildlife habitat and recreational space. The Michigan United Conservation Clubs (MUCC) called for a public comment period and the establishment of clear criteria for such projects. 
• Public Perception: Misinformation campaigns amplified the controversy, with false claims about the destruction of pristine forests circulating widely. However, fact-checking revealed that the land in question had been previously clear-cut and was not old-growth forest. 

Amidst the growing controversy, RWE Clean Energy withdrew its interest in leasing the state land, stating that the decision was made prior to the public outcry.  Consequently, the DNR announced in May 2025 that it would not proceed with the lease.

While the Michigan DNR considered leasing 420 acres of state-managed forestland near Gaylord for a large-scale solar project, our modest proposal to install a memorial bench on North Fox Island was denied. Memorial benches are small, low-impact additions that honor community members and enhance visitor experiences. This contrast raises questions about consistency and priorities in how public lands are managed. We are asking the DNR to apply the same consideration and fairness to community-driven projects as they do to large commercial developments.