Reduction in school fees
Reduction in school fees
The Issue
April 15, 2020
To the Chairman and Members of the Board of Directors of Hillel Academy, Jamaica
Dear Sir(s):
We are a group of parents of the Preparatory School of Hillel Academy.
We trust that this letter finds you and your family safe and healthy in these unprecedented times.This evening we received a letter from the Director of Hillel Academy, which states in pertinent part:
“In this period of uncertainty, we would like to offer parents options for Term 3 fee invoice payments. These apply to all those whose payments are up to date.
a. Parents who pay the entire fee by April 30th, 2020 will receive a 5% discount.
b. Others may pay in three equal monthly payments in April, May, and a last payment by June 15th, 2020. There will be no surcharge for this service.
c. Anyone who has difficulties with either of the two options should contact the Financial Controller for a confidential discussion on a payment plan.”
Since we have not yet received invoices, we must rely on this guidance from the Director.
We are writing to request a meeting at the earliest possible date with the Members of the Board to discuss the fees that are being charged to the parents for Term 3. This is the immediate and time sensitive issue since school begins in 5 days.
Let us begin by acknowledging that we are living in unusual and unprecedented times. We all understand that nothing is more important than respecting public health mandates to keep our children and the broader community healthy.
Hillel Academy closed on March 13th, one day before the Ministry of Education mandated closing the schools on the instruction of the Prime Minister.
Based on a survey of a sample of parents in all of the Grades of the Prep school, 30 minute introductory sessions with the students were conducted via Zoom and Google classroom between 7 and 10 days after this closing date. For many of the early teaching days classes were combined meaning that we sometimes had in excess of 40 to 50 children on one Zoom link.
We note that for reasons that are unclear to us, the prep school was unable to get unto the online platforms more expeditiously. We have had no communication from the school as to their long-term plan to make up these lost teaching days, as is surely the best-practice in any educational institution, particularly one that provides primary education to young children.
Over the course of the next few days, the school gradually ramped up teaching. At the date of closure for the Passover/Easter break, live teaching instruction on Zoom or Google Classroom was being conducted for between 2 and 2.5 hours. That is, the children were receiving between 33 percent and 40 percent of the live instruction time that they would normally receive at school. Even leaving aside those subjects that are not easily taught remotely (for example, P.E.), it is clear that this is a significant reduction in instruction time.
For obvious reasons, several parents have had to make alternative arrangements to supplement their children’s instruction time to ensure that the children do not suffer what the academic educational scholarship refers to as an “achievement gap” during their extended period away from in-school teaching. Suffice it to say that a significant degree of the responsibility of teaching that would normally be borne by Hillel has been shifted to the parents.
We should also note that for public health reasons, the facilities have had to close so we do not have access to swimming, football and other services that are normally provided by Hillel.
We refer here only to facts on which there is widespread agreement. We leave aside other issues as to whether or not the functions that one would expect of an educational institution (such as timely consistent review and feedback of the work product of the children, with uploading to Google classroom) are being consistently conducted.
For obvious reasons, the public health crisis has led to an economic crisis. In times of economic crisis, a consistent management principle is one of burden sharing. All over Jamaica (and indeed globally), management are engaging staff and customers in difficult but necessary conversations as to how to share the burdens that necessarily accompany economic crisis. Many of the Hillel parents (as is the case right across Jamaica and globally) have been engaged with such difficult conversations with the members of the staffs of their own businesses. The overriding principle is one of shared sacrifice.
The difficulty with the letter that the Director has sent to the parents is that it does not reflect that principle. The school is essentially asking parents to incur precisely the same cost for significantly reduced services. There is no reference to burden sharing on the part of any other stakeholders. Forgive our candor but we find this extraordinary, particularly given that Hillel is a non-profit institution.
As we await further guidance from the Jamaican Cabinet and the Ministry of Education, we need to face the very real possibility that this crisis will be prolonged. Thus, we do not believe that it is advisable for Hillel to postpone this conversation on appropriate burden sharing.
We have obtained the financial reports that Hillel circulated (the latest to which we have access is 2017). We would ask that Hillel share relevant financial information to facilitate a conversation as to where there might be savings.
We are inviting you to a virtual meeting with the parents on Monday April 20th at 6 pm. We are suggesting this date and time, given the time sensitivity and to facilitate the largest possible parental participation. We will circulate Zoom details.
We look forward to your expeditious response. We wish you and your families good health in this difficult period.
Thank you.
Petition Closed
The Issue
April 15, 2020
To the Chairman and Members of the Board of Directors of Hillel Academy, Jamaica
Dear Sir(s):
We are a group of parents of the Preparatory School of Hillel Academy.
We trust that this letter finds you and your family safe and healthy in these unprecedented times.This evening we received a letter from the Director of Hillel Academy, which states in pertinent part:
“In this period of uncertainty, we would like to offer parents options for Term 3 fee invoice payments. These apply to all those whose payments are up to date.
a. Parents who pay the entire fee by April 30th, 2020 will receive a 5% discount.
b. Others may pay in three equal monthly payments in April, May, and a last payment by June 15th, 2020. There will be no surcharge for this service.
c. Anyone who has difficulties with either of the two options should contact the Financial Controller for a confidential discussion on a payment plan.”
Since we have not yet received invoices, we must rely on this guidance from the Director.
We are writing to request a meeting at the earliest possible date with the Members of the Board to discuss the fees that are being charged to the parents for Term 3. This is the immediate and time sensitive issue since school begins in 5 days.
Let us begin by acknowledging that we are living in unusual and unprecedented times. We all understand that nothing is more important than respecting public health mandates to keep our children and the broader community healthy.
Hillel Academy closed on March 13th, one day before the Ministry of Education mandated closing the schools on the instruction of the Prime Minister.
Based on a survey of a sample of parents in all of the Grades of the Prep school, 30 minute introductory sessions with the students were conducted via Zoom and Google classroom between 7 and 10 days after this closing date. For many of the early teaching days classes were combined meaning that we sometimes had in excess of 40 to 50 children on one Zoom link.
We note that for reasons that are unclear to us, the prep school was unable to get unto the online platforms more expeditiously. We have had no communication from the school as to their long-term plan to make up these lost teaching days, as is surely the best-practice in any educational institution, particularly one that provides primary education to young children.
Over the course of the next few days, the school gradually ramped up teaching. At the date of closure for the Passover/Easter break, live teaching instruction on Zoom or Google Classroom was being conducted for between 2 and 2.5 hours. That is, the children were receiving between 33 percent and 40 percent of the live instruction time that they would normally receive at school. Even leaving aside those subjects that are not easily taught remotely (for example, P.E.), it is clear that this is a significant reduction in instruction time.
For obvious reasons, several parents have had to make alternative arrangements to supplement their children’s instruction time to ensure that the children do not suffer what the academic educational scholarship refers to as an “achievement gap” during their extended period away from in-school teaching. Suffice it to say that a significant degree of the responsibility of teaching that would normally be borne by Hillel has been shifted to the parents.
We should also note that for public health reasons, the facilities have had to close so we do not have access to swimming, football and other services that are normally provided by Hillel.
We refer here only to facts on which there is widespread agreement. We leave aside other issues as to whether or not the functions that one would expect of an educational institution (such as timely consistent review and feedback of the work product of the children, with uploading to Google classroom) are being consistently conducted.
For obvious reasons, the public health crisis has led to an economic crisis. In times of economic crisis, a consistent management principle is one of burden sharing. All over Jamaica (and indeed globally), management are engaging staff and customers in difficult but necessary conversations as to how to share the burdens that necessarily accompany economic crisis. Many of the Hillel parents (as is the case right across Jamaica and globally) have been engaged with such difficult conversations with the members of the staffs of their own businesses. The overriding principle is one of shared sacrifice.
The difficulty with the letter that the Director has sent to the parents is that it does not reflect that principle. The school is essentially asking parents to incur precisely the same cost for significantly reduced services. There is no reference to burden sharing on the part of any other stakeholders. Forgive our candor but we find this extraordinary, particularly given that Hillel is a non-profit institution.
As we await further guidance from the Jamaican Cabinet and the Ministry of Education, we need to face the very real possibility that this crisis will be prolonged. Thus, we do not believe that it is advisable for Hillel to postpone this conversation on appropriate burden sharing.
We have obtained the financial reports that Hillel circulated (the latest to which we have access is 2017). We would ask that Hillel share relevant financial information to facilitate a conversation as to where there might be savings.
We are inviting you to a virtual meeting with the parents on Monday April 20th at 6 pm. We are suggesting this date and time, given the time sensitivity and to facilitate the largest possible parental participation. We will circulate Zoom details.
We look forward to your expeditious response. We wish you and your families good health in this difficult period.
Thank you.
The Decision Makers
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on 16 April 2020