HE SAID NO TO A LIE. NOW HE'S SERVING LIFE FOR A MURDER A FREE MAN COMMITTED.

12,995

The Issue

Donte' Swanier is 31 years old. He has spent over a decade in prison for a murder he did not plan, did not encourage, did not carry out, and did not even witness. He was 18 when it happened. A life sentence in Tennessee is a determinate sentence, with a start date and an end date, not a parole board decision. It's 60 years at 100%, with at most 9 years taken off for good behavior. That's 51 calendar years served before the sentence flattens.

In October 2017, a Davidson County jury convicted him of Attempted Aggravated Robbery, Attempted Especially Aggravated Robbery, and First Degree Felony Murder. Judge Steve Dozier sentenced him to life. Sentence expiration date: 2075.


No one, not the state and not a single witness, has ever said Donte' pulled the trigger. He was convicted anyway, under a legal theory that he was criminally responsible for someone else's act. But look at what the state's own witness actually said on the stand. Rayvon Walker never testified that the robbery was Donte's plan. He never said Donte' encouraged anyone to commit it. He never testified that Donte' needed money that night or wanted anything from that robbery at all. There is no evidence supporting the theory the jury was asked to convict him under. Donte' isn't just innocent of pulling the trigger. He was never criminally responsible for it in the first place.


The Man Who Actually Confessed Is Free, and Silent


Before he was ever arrested, Rayvon Walker told his own family he was the one who pulled the trigger. He killed the victim in the front yard of an Antioch home. Walker, 16 at the time, was prosecuted only for Facilitation of First Degree Felony Murder and received juvenile probation until age 19.
Walker is now protected by double jeopardy. He legally cannot be recharged for this murder, no matter what he says. And still he won't come forward with the truth, because he believes he can be recharged anyway, regardless of what anyone tells him or what the law actually says.
Diana Reyes was in the vehicle that night. She was 15. She was never charged, never arrested, never even brought in. But in a proffer with law enforcement, she said it plainly: Walker was the shooter, not Quintavious Patton, the co-defendant now serving life for a killing he didn't commit. Reyes has never changed her story. The District Attorney's office chose not to call her as a witness at trial. Ask yourself why a prosecutor would keep the one witness who could clear an innocent man off the witness list. To hide the truth. 

Why? Because Donte' Wouldn't Lie.


The answer traces back to former juvenile prosecutor Paul Dewitt, who let Walker walk with probation. Once that decision was made, protecting it became the priority. Donte' was pushed to testify falsely against Patton to help keep it buried. He refused. That refusal is what turned Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Charles's prosecution against him, a case built not on evidence but on making sure the truth about Walker and Dewitt never saw daylight.


And the "Evidence"? It Was Illegal, and the Court Knew It


The GPS tracker used to identify every suspect in this case was installed under a court order, not a valid search warrant, in violation of the Fourth Amendment standard set in United States v. Jones. Without that illegal tracking, no suspects would ever have been identified or arrested.
The Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals has already recognized exactly this kind of violation. In September 2014, in State v. Jerry Brandon Phifer, that same court ruled that police use of a GPS tracker without a warrant was an illegal search, threw out the evidence it produced, including the arrest and statements that followed, and ordered a new trial. The Tennessean covered that ruling: "Suspect gets new trial over illegal GPS use by police" tennessean.com/story/news/crime/2014/09/23/suspect-gets-new-trial-illegal-gps-use-police/16121255/ Phifer got a new trial. In Donte's case, the same court looked at the same kind of illegal tracking and upheld his conviction anyway.


When the GPS wasn't enough, prosecutors reached for a rap song. Donte' wrote lyrics denying any involvement. The state twisted his own words in front of the jury, calling him and Patton "prodigies of robbery and death," and turned a declaration of innocence into a manufactured confession.


Where the Fight Stands Now


The same claims raised on Donte's post-conviction appeal, including the GPS tracking, the mishandled plea offer, the cell-site location data, and the Rule 404(b) prior-bad-acts and rap lyrics evidence, are now the heart of his federal habeas corpus petition, Swanier v. Perry, pending in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee with court appointed federal public defenders.


Donte' is also appealing a Tennessee declaratory judgment action that challenges how the state applied the criminal responsibility law to him. Tennessee law draws a clear line: a person is criminally responsible for another's crime only if he acted with intent to promote or assist it, meaning he planned it, directed it, or wanted it to happen. Someone who simply gives a ride or other help, without that intent, can at most be guilty of facilitation, a far lesser offense. Donte's challenge argues that the state erased that line, stretching criminal responsibility to cover conduct that, even on the state's own version of events, fits facilitation at most. That is the same offense Rayvon Walker, the actual shooter, was allowed to plead to. 

He also continues pushing for legislative reform of Tennessee's criminal responsibility statute so no one else's life gets taken this way.


A confessed killer walks free and stays silent out of a fear the law says he shouldn't have. A witness who could confirm the truth was never allowed to speak. And an innocent man sits in prison for refusing to lie about it.


Sign this petition. Demand Donte' Swanier finally gets the scrutiny, and the justice, this case was denied.

The Decision Makers

Bill Lee
Tennessee Governor

Petition Updates