

Greenhills Village Council Needs to Hit Brakes on Beechwoods Proposal
The Issue
To the Greenhills Village Council:
We the undersigned wish to express our considerable dissatisfaction with the steps taken to date, including the September meeting of the Planning Commission, in the development of the former Beechwoods Elementary property in pursuing Planned Unit Development (PUD) status. We are urgently requesting you to place a hold on moving forward with any further approval steps of this development process by the full council until a number of necessary, common-sense efforts can take place.
Steps we are requesting so a fully informed decision can be made include:
- A professional traffic impact study to determine how neighboring streets will be impacted by the proposed number and layout of new homes in our neighborhood.
- Specific analysis by Greenhills Police, Greenhills Fire and Greenhills Public Works on how such an addition of this many homes on the perimeter of the village will stress their abilities to continue their services at the level that village residents expect and have voted to support.
- A full analysis of the flow for both sewage and rainwater runoff not just looking at current standards, but in recognition of environmental conditions where extreme rainfall events are becoming increasingly common. During the three months of summer alone in 2026, Hamilton County was impacted by four disaster-level such events, including a 1,000-year storm overwhelming multiple communities in central and eastern Hamilton County. Even lesser rain storms caused street flooding and flooded basements in the village in late May. The adjoining “J” section streets already endured a history of decades of flooding issues that originated with real estate developers who blindly promised additional homes would cause no problems.
- The development proposal as is now would create 39 all-electric smart homes, introducing a massive structural shift for the local utility infrastructure. As a collective pocket, these 39 lots will add roughly 80,000 kWh of new electrical demand every single month to our local circuit. Of utmost concern is whether our existing local grid, which already seems stressed, could handle the electrical demand during extreme weather events. For instance, on a sub-zero winter night when 39 massive electric heat pumps turn on their backup heating elements at the same time, the peak demand on our local grid jumps from 136.5 kW to 526.5 kW (a half-megawatt spike). Neighbors are requesting council require a Duke Energy Capacity Study. That would include a formal, public simulation report proving the existing substation and overhead feeder lines can handle a half-megawatt spike without degrading service to surrounding streets.
- Soil-sampling and testing of the site for residual hazardous materials from the school’s demolition, such as asbestos, that are likely to become airborne once heavy equipment begins moving soil for any project work.
- A cost-benefit analysis of an increase in green space from the current proposed density of homes for the site, with larger lots and more greenery, and how that would likely stack up with higher overall property values for the benefit of the village and more revenue. The PUD ordinances contain a common open space provision, a factor completely ignored by Maronda Homes in their proposal as submitted to the village.
This development not only will reshape the east side of Greenhills, for better or worse, for at least the next several decades, it is an opportunity to change the trajectory of the village. Almost all residents would agree that tranquility, natural surroundings, safety and spaces where people enjoy being outside have all been traditional strengths of life in Greenhills, dating back to the village’s founding and the Greenbelt concept. We need to ensure this project protects and continues those traditions in the best way possible.
Public input opportunities on this project have been next to nil to this point, and it’s too important to the village to just barrel ahead without having as much information as possible to make the best decisions, including the safety and livability issues raised here. We implore council as our representatives to take the time to make sure we get this right for the greater benefit of all Greenhills residents, both today and for years to come.
123
The Issue
To the Greenhills Village Council:
We the undersigned wish to express our considerable dissatisfaction with the steps taken to date, including the September meeting of the Planning Commission, in the development of the former Beechwoods Elementary property in pursuing Planned Unit Development (PUD) status. We are urgently requesting you to place a hold on moving forward with any further approval steps of this development process by the full council until a number of necessary, common-sense efforts can take place.
Steps we are requesting so a fully informed decision can be made include:
- A professional traffic impact study to determine how neighboring streets will be impacted by the proposed number and layout of new homes in our neighborhood.
- Specific analysis by Greenhills Police, Greenhills Fire and Greenhills Public Works on how such an addition of this many homes on the perimeter of the village will stress their abilities to continue their services at the level that village residents expect and have voted to support.
- A full analysis of the flow for both sewage and rainwater runoff not just looking at current standards, but in recognition of environmental conditions where extreme rainfall events are becoming increasingly common. During the three months of summer alone in 2026, Hamilton County was impacted by four disaster-level such events, including a 1,000-year storm overwhelming multiple communities in central and eastern Hamilton County. Even lesser rain storms caused street flooding and flooded basements in the village in late May. The adjoining “J” section streets already endured a history of decades of flooding issues that originated with real estate developers who blindly promised additional homes would cause no problems.
- The development proposal as is now would create 39 all-electric smart homes, introducing a massive structural shift for the local utility infrastructure. As a collective pocket, these 39 lots will add roughly 80,000 kWh of new electrical demand every single month to our local circuit. Of utmost concern is whether our existing local grid, which already seems stressed, could handle the electrical demand during extreme weather events. For instance, on a sub-zero winter night when 39 massive electric heat pumps turn on their backup heating elements at the same time, the peak demand on our local grid jumps from 136.5 kW to 526.5 kW (a half-megawatt spike). Neighbors are requesting council require a Duke Energy Capacity Study. That would include a formal, public simulation report proving the existing substation and overhead feeder lines can handle a half-megawatt spike without degrading service to surrounding streets.
- Soil-sampling and testing of the site for residual hazardous materials from the school’s demolition, such as asbestos, that are likely to become airborne once heavy equipment begins moving soil for any project work.
- A cost-benefit analysis of an increase in green space from the current proposed density of homes for the site, with larger lots and more greenery, and how that would likely stack up with higher overall property values for the benefit of the village and more revenue. The PUD ordinances contain a common open space provision, a factor completely ignored by Maronda Homes in their proposal as submitted to the village.
This development not only will reshape the east side of Greenhills, for better or worse, for at least the next several decades, it is an opportunity to change the trajectory of the village. Almost all residents would agree that tranquility, natural surroundings, safety and spaces where people enjoy being outside have all been traditional strengths of life in Greenhills, dating back to the village’s founding and the Greenbelt concept. We need to ensure this project protects and continues those traditions in the best way possible.
Public input opportunities on this project have been next to nil to this point, and it’s too important to the village to just barrel ahead without having as much information as possible to make the best decisions, including the safety and livability issues raised here. We implore council as our representatives to take the time to make sure we get this right for the greater benefit of all Greenhills residents, both today and for years to come.
The Decision Makers
Supporter Voices
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on November 11, 2026