

Give colour-blind pilots a fair test: bring practical colour vision assessments to the UK
The Issue
For as long as I can remember, I wanted to fly airliners. That dream ended in a medical examiner’s office, not in a cockpit. I never failed a flight test. I failed a colour vision test, and the UK system gave me no way to show I could fly safely anyway.
Every aspiring UK airline pilot needs an unrestricted Class 1 Medical. It starts with the Ishihara plate test, a book of coloured dots designed in 1917. Fail it, and you have one route left: a computer-based screening test, the Colour Assessment and Diagnosis (CAD). Fail that, and the door closes for good. There is no flight test and no real-world assessment. Your actual ability in the cockpit is never tested.
Even the CAA’s own guidance admits that judging pilots’ “colour safety” with Ishihara plates has real problems. Yet the UK still offers nothing beyond a screen test.
Other leading regulators do it differently:
- United States: the FAA lets candidates who fail screening take an Operational Colour Vision Test, which means reading aeronautical charts and identifying control-tower light signals. They then fly a Medical Flight Test with an FAA inspector. Pass both, and they receive a medical with no colour restriction, valid up to airline level.
- Australia: CASA offers the Australian Operational Colour Vision Assessment as an alternative to CAD. Pass it, and you receive an unrestricted Class 1 medical.
These pilots fly safely every day in some of the most respected aviation systems in the world. A pilot judged safe to fly in Chicago or Sydney can be grounded in London.
Around 3 million people in the UK are colour blind, including 1 in 12 men. Meanwhile, the industry needs 660,000 new pilots worldwide over the next 20 years. Britain cannot afford to turn away capable candidates because of a test that never puts them in a cockpit.
We are not asking the CAA to lower safety standards. We are asking it to measure what really matters: whether someone can safely do the job.
We call on the CAA to:
- Introduce a practical, operational colour vision assessment for Class 1 applicants who fail CAD, based on the proven FAA and CASA pathways.
- Publish the evidence behind its current CAD pass thresholds and review them against current research.
- Give every applicant a fair chance to show their competence in a real flying environment.
Let’s keep our skies safe, and open to everyone who can fly them safely. Please sign and share.
87
The Issue
For as long as I can remember, I wanted to fly airliners. That dream ended in a medical examiner’s office, not in a cockpit. I never failed a flight test. I failed a colour vision test, and the UK system gave me no way to show I could fly safely anyway.
Every aspiring UK airline pilot needs an unrestricted Class 1 Medical. It starts with the Ishihara plate test, a book of coloured dots designed in 1917. Fail it, and you have one route left: a computer-based screening test, the Colour Assessment and Diagnosis (CAD). Fail that, and the door closes for good. There is no flight test and no real-world assessment. Your actual ability in the cockpit is never tested.
Even the CAA’s own guidance admits that judging pilots’ “colour safety” with Ishihara plates has real problems. Yet the UK still offers nothing beyond a screen test.
Other leading regulators do it differently:
- United States: the FAA lets candidates who fail screening take an Operational Colour Vision Test, which means reading aeronautical charts and identifying control-tower light signals. They then fly a Medical Flight Test with an FAA inspector. Pass both, and they receive a medical with no colour restriction, valid up to airline level.
- Australia: CASA offers the Australian Operational Colour Vision Assessment as an alternative to CAD. Pass it, and you receive an unrestricted Class 1 medical.
These pilots fly safely every day in some of the most respected aviation systems in the world. A pilot judged safe to fly in Chicago or Sydney can be grounded in London.
Around 3 million people in the UK are colour blind, including 1 in 12 men. Meanwhile, the industry needs 660,000 new pilots worldwide over the next 20 years. Britain cannot afford to turn away capable candidates because of a test that never puts them in a cockpit.
We are not asking the CAA to lower safety standards. We are asking it to measure what really matters: whether someone can safely do the job.
We call on the CAA to:
- Introduce a practical, operational colour vision assessment for Class 1 applicants who fail CAD, based on the proven FAA and CASA pathways.
- Publish the evidence behind its current CAD pass thresholds and review them against current research.
- Give every applicant a fair chance to show their competence in a real flying environment.
Let’s keep our skies safe, and open to everyone who can fly them safely. Please sign and share.
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on 14 March 2025
