Fox and The Simpsons Need to Address Their Harmful Autism Spoof (episode "Testing 1-2-3")

22

Let’s get to 25 signatures!
Petitions with 1,000+ supporters are 5x more likely to win!

The Issue

I propose that we call on Fox and The Simpsons writers to pull the episode "Testing 1-2-3" or edit it heavily, issue a public apology, and start HELPING autistic people by educating the public instead of perpetuating harmful ideas about us. They claim to be promoters of social justice, so they shouldn't have a problem with this.

If you have time to read this, or if you don't already know a lot about autism, here is exactly WHY this is so important...

First, autism itself is not a defect. It is another "neurotype". Most people have the "neurotypical" neurotype, which means their brains run on automatic, primitive instincts that filter out unwanted sensory input and give them instant "gut feelings" about what is the appropriate action in every social situation. Neurotypicals call this "common sense". In the autistic neurotype, our brains don't use those automatic filters or run on social autopilot—instead, we rely on conscious logic. Because our brains don't turn down unwanted input, we get every sight, sound, and feeling at 100% strength, which is why we get so overwhelmed in noisy environments or at a party where dozens of people are talking at once. We can't ignore anyone or anything. On top of this, because we don't get those automatic social "gut feelings," we don't instinctively know what neurotypicals will consider the "right" thing to do. If an autistic person gives a reply that shows lack of "common sense", the neurotypical will get ANGRY and may even directly say "come on, use your common sense!" which is basically like a sighted person yelling at a blind person "come on, watch where you're going!" Of course, sometimes people DO yell that at blind people, until they find out they're blind, and then they apologize for being insensitive. But when they yell at an autistic person, and they're told the person is autistic, instead of saying "oh I'm sorry. That was insensitive and offensive. I'll keep that in mind", they instead just shake their heads and think "what an idiot! weirdo! They better stay out of my workplace"...or, they think "oh that poor person with a BROKEN BRAIN. I better tiptoe for them." But we don't want either of those reactions. What we want is for others to just ACCEPT that our way is NOT BROKEN, just different than theirs. Our way is more logical, immune to ridiculous tribalistic groupthink, and more caring and fair. We do not IGNORE, or not CARE, about our people's feelings... we care MORE than they do about ours. We just don't UNDERSTAND your reactions because we don't have those animal instincts and tribalistic groupthink. If you EXPLAIN why you're upset, we'll understand and remember not to do that particular thing again when we're in the same situation. WE LEARN. We enter a particular situation, notice that neurotypicals are angry at us for a certain thing, perhaps ASK why they're upset, then learn how to avoid causing that same reaction the next time we're in that same situation. We do it by thinking logically and memorizing neurotypical social rules. The problem is, neurotypicals have a habit of making up a rule, NOT SAYING IT to anyone, expecting everyone else to KNOW the rule...and when an autistic person breaks that rule, they get angry. But if a neurotypical person breaks that same rule, they're fine with it! It's because they have a "only for thee, not for me" attitude that only applies to them and their close friends. Anyone they think of as an outsider must obey the rules very strictly, and they can SENSE that we are outsiders. It's all about primitive tribalistic animal instincts.

So that all explains how and why we are different. But there is more. Because we are very fair and caring and reasonable, and don't use animal instincts to decide what's "appropriate", when we are surrounded by people who say that OUR behaviour is "wrong" and that their way is the only correct way, we assume they are RIGHT. In our minds, if 100 people say one thing, even about US personally, while we are thinking differently, we tell ourselves "it would be so arrogant if I were to assume I'M right and everyone else is wrong, so they must be right". This begins at a VERY young age, with us internalizing every negative thing that is said about us and to us. When our neurotypical classmates say "that person is WEIRD", we think "I am? What am I doing wrong?" and when we're told by teachers "you need to behave more like other people. Try your best to MASK your behaviour. Copy what you see others doing. Don't follow your own ideas about what is the right way to behave", we internalize the idea that we are BROKEN. So we fight our own minds constantly every day, starting from early childhood. Every time someone gives us a dirty look for doing the "wrong" thing, we hate ourselves for being "stupid". And it happens all day, every day, for years and years and years. It might take until adulthood to finally learn what I'm telling you all here today, that autism is NOT a defective neurotype, it's just different. It's actually superior in some ways. But imagine growing up NOT KNOWING THAT, and truly believing everyone who tells you that you are BROKEN. This is the EXACT REASON why so many autistic people become suicidal. It's not because we are broken, and it's not because we are too WEAK to handle stress. It's that we literally HATE OURSELVES. We literally wish we were NOT BORN. Some of us spend every day thinking "this is pointless...nobody will ever love me until I fix my brain, which I can't do, and no doctor can fix it either! so why keep going??" Just watch the Joker movie, especially the part where he's trudging up the stairs in the rain, and imagine feeling THAT depressed, every day of your life. That's what it's like being autistic in a world where everyone else thinks you're broken. But since we're very caring people, we don't react the way Joker did. We don't hurt others. We hurt ourselves instead. And it's all because people keep telling us we're broken and need to get fixed.

Autistic people are just as much an oppressed group as LGBTQ people are, except that LGBTQ people have communities that constantly tell them that they are NOT broken, and now even media says it to them literally every single day in almost every story you ever watch. They have SO much support! But autistic people, we get portrayed as rude jerks like Sheldon on the Big Bang Theory, or unable to speak properly like Rainman. When we are able to speak clearly, as you can see I am able to do, this causes people to not even REALIZE we're autistic, which makes them even more demanding that we do think their way about everything. Once they know we're autistic, they sometimes try to be more understanding, but then they pity us, which makes us become even more uncomfortable around them. It actually makes us feel even MORE BROKEN because someone is looking at us with PITY.

NOW FOR THE PURPOSE OF THIS PETITION.

Now that you understand all of that, you may understand why the Simpsons episode "Testing 1-2-3" (season 38, episode 5) is not only extremely offensive, but LITERALLY harmful.

The episode starts with Lisa getting overwhelmed by all the noise in her classroom, then noticing another student is taking a test in a quiet room alone. Even though the episode implies Lisa is not autistic, she literally complains "hey, I want that for me too!", as if an oppressed group doesn't need accommodations to help them reach the same level as those who are not oppressed.

Lisa goes to an assessment center where the teacher keeps implying that nobody really NEEDS accommodations, that they're all just lazy. She even implies they're crazy.

Next, there is a segment where it's implied that Principal Skinner is autistic, which is fine in itself. But then he's shown literally not noticing a HUGE fire 20 feet away or Lisa yelling in his ear. This is going to cause neurotypicals to think "wow, autistic people are super oblivious and don't care about people around them!" And then Skinner says "I was working on the school budget, and now it's now", like as if he BLACKED OUT. Really?? That's what the writers think we do?? Next, Skinner has to speak to the school board, and he's very nervous. If this was some random character, I'd say yeah that's accurate, that we're nervous about speaking with neurotypicals, especially a group of them. We have to constantly calculate what they will probably WANT TO HEAR. But the fact that it's SKINNER, a character who for years has been portrayed as weak and stupid, it makes autistic people look weak and stupid. Our fear of speaking to neurotypicals is the result of repeated PTSD from oppression since childhood, not weakness. Then he speaks to Shauna, who is very very obviously being sarcastic. She's NOT subtle about it at all. Even an autistic person could easily recognize her sarcasm. But Skinner 100% misses that it's sarcasm, causing a neurotypical audience to think "wow, those autistic people are really stupid!"

By this point, it's clear that Lisa's voiceovers are NOT meant to teach people about the problems autistic people face, but clearly to MOCK us. So when she next says "Do you find it difficult to alter your routine?", instead of an autistic viewer thinking "yes, I do, wow they really get me", we're thinking "um yes...and are you going to mock THAT too??" and then THEY DO.

The Breakfast Club scene was kinda funny, especially when Skinner freeze frames with his fist up high, like in the Breakfast Club. Nothing too directly offensive there.

Since the episode is subtitled "Into the Neurodiverse", an uneducated audience might only know enough to realize the Skinner segment was about autism, and then lump the next 2 segments in with autism, even though they are meant to be about ADHD and OCD respectively. I can't speak directly about how these 2 segments will offend people with ADHD or OCD because I don't think I have ADHD, and my OCD is controllable. But I can imagine that they would be offended by some of the things in these 2 segments, especially the part where Homer's eyes roll back in his head at the fair. I tried to remind myself that segment wasn't meant to be about autism, but I couldn't help FEELING that the entire episode was targetting me anyway...maybe because they didn't directly SAY that only the first segment was about autism.

The way Marge is exhausted from chasing after Homer, it reminded me of a forum I once read where neurotypical women were saying how horrible it was being married to an autistic man. Nobody on that forum ever said anything positive about the husbands. Nobody said "you should have learned his way of thinking and find constructive ways to interact with each other", instead they just implied that he was exhausting and ridiculous and that he caused the divorce. But like I said, this segment of the episode wasn't really meant to be about autism, but I still couldn't help remembering that forum and getting more upset at the episode.

Then, in the OCD segment, the writers attempted to make a positive statement by showing how 2 people with OCD could accept each other's unreasonable demands if they just KNEW that each other had OCD. Ok, good for those who HAVE someone who understands. But if you're autistic, not just OCD, it takes more than just finding someone who understands. And even if that was enough to help you cope with the oppression from everyone else in the world, and make you realize that others are WRONG to call you "broken", first you have to FIND someone who understands and accepts you! Most autistic people NEVER find someone like that, so they die alone, hating themselves. It's not enough just to find someone. Society needs to realize they are the main cause of problems that RUIN autistic lives, and STOP with the oppression! And how does that happen? By educating them about what autism ACTUALLY IS. And how do we educate them? With the media. This is why LGBTQ people are now so widely accepted, because media kept pushing a positive message about them relentlessly for DECADES. We need the same thing for autistic people NOW...but here we are, in 2026, and STILL we have shows like the SIMPSONS, which usually is for social JUSTICE, actually tearing autistic people DOWN and perpetuating the oppression!

And then the episode got MUCH MUCH more offensive! The characters began singing a lighthearted song that the writers seemed to be trying to use for a positive goal of acceptance, which went:

"When you wear a mask to get mail at exactly 3:03, You'll touch every lamp to protect us, that's our OCD. I'll cause my team to lose if I watch them, Or clean my lucky tee. Even tossing salt over your shoulder, Is groupthink OCD. We all have quirks bottled up in our brain. Just 'cause you're crazy doesn't mean you're insane. So look to your left and look to your right, Then do it three more times so you don't die in the night. Wake-up pills calm me down when I'm fidgety, I also medicate to control my ADHD. This is excellent for stimming, Shirt tags bother me. Having every problem above is Comorbidity, Magical thinking, Excessive drinking, Intensive interests, Addicted to Pinterest, Echolalia, Echolalia, We are all a little bit crazy.
You might see yourself in examples we gave, That make you think about how you behave. If you're offended and ready to walk, Remember we're only drawings that talk. There's a whole spectrum of spectrums. You might need therapy, Meds for your heads, Blues before reds, Or just some TLC, And maybe THC. Everybody's got a little something...Neurodiversity."

If you only listen to the ending, it kinda sounds like they're saying "oh don't worry that you're different...everyone is different. It's just diversity, and diversity is a good thing". And yeah, if THAT was the whole song, it could be taken in a positive way. But if you listen to the whole song, it's VERY VERY offensive and HARMFUL. First, they take things like superstitions and lump them in with autism, trying to convince autistic people that we're not any different from neurotypical people. And if that message was actually USED by neurotypicals to ACCEPT autistic people, then great! But in the REAL WORLD, neurotypical people DO NOT accept autistic people AT ALL. They either get angry or pity us, both of which are harmful to our mental health. So when the song directly says TO AUTISTIC PEOPLE (not to neurotypicals) "think about how you behave", it's trying to tell us that WE ARE THE PROBLEM, not neurotypicals, and that we need to BEHAVE LIKE A NEUROTYPICAL better. Guess what writers? OUR behaviour isn't the problem! We behave in a logical, fair, caring way. Neurotypicals behave in a selfish destructive tribalistic way that makes NO SENSE, except TO THEM. And then you might say "well, if it makes sense to 99% of people, then the other 1% should try to fit in". But don't you remember that that's what people used to say about LGBTQ people? They'd say "try harder to fit in. GO TO CONVERSION THERAPY. Become straight. Accept your gender", etc. And now what does society say about that? They now say that forcing a MINORITY to change, so the majority is more comfortable, is OPPRESSION. But they're STILL DOING IT to autistic people! Government agencies and groups that supposedly help autistic people keep pushing for ABA therapy, which is basically neuroCONVERSION THERAPY. This "therapy" actually ADDS to the suicidal feelings of autistic people! But oh well, we're just a minority, so ignore it, those of you in the majority. But I say NO. This has been going on long enough! It's time to start PUSHING BACK, the same way LGBTQ people pushed back against the media and eventually turned them to their side. Now the same needs to be done for autistic people. No more messages about forcing us to BE LIKE YOU! WE ARE US, NOT YOU. WE ARE NOT BROKEN.

And then the song implies we can "fix" autism by "thinking about how we behave", getting therapy, or taking drugs to "fix" our brains. Like as if our lives full of daily misery and depression are all the result of us NOT TRYING HARD ENOUGH to fix ourselves! Say that to an LGBTQ person and see what happens! You'll get swift and strong retribution on social media and probably fired from your job. But say that about autistic people and...nothing happens...because nobody cares. WE NEED TO MAKE THEM CARE!

If you think it's an exaggeration to say this episode "harms" autistic people, consider the effect it can have on many people. For most neurotypicals, it will reinforce any negative or untrue beliefs they have about autistic people, which will cause them to either hate or pity us instead of seeking to truly understand us. And the more people hate or pity us, the more we HATE OURSELVES, and when we hate ourselves, we end ourselves. I'd call that harm! And for autistic viewers, the harm is more direct. If an autistic viewer has not yet learned that we are NOT THE PROBLEM, and they hear the song saying that they just need to "think about how they behave" or get therapy to "fix" their brains, it will REMIND them of their daily dark thoughts about how they CAN'T "fix" their brains, which will make them feel even MORE deep despair, pushing them to end themselves. And if an autistic viewer, like myself, has already learned that we are not actually the problem, the problem is neurotypicals not understanding us, it gives US despair too, because it shows us that even in 2026, there is no progress on this issue. Shows like the Simpsons are actively trying to KEEP things in a bad place, despite claiming to be for social justice! That will cause even more despair, which could, even for an autistic person who now knows that they are NOT THE PROBLEM, result in the same danger...ending themselves.

If you think this is all an exaggeration, think about how many LGBTQ people have ended themselves because of being told they were broken. And their brains have automatic instincts that help them brush off negative things outsiders say. Autistic brains don't do that! And LGBTQ people have communities and media and even LAWS that prevent people from saying negative things about them. Autistic people don't have that. We get very dark thoughts because of all this. Every single day of our lives. It's the reason why autistic people very often can't get any job, and without a job, it's extremely hard to have A LIFE. So we just give up and stop living.

One of the most infuriating things about the song in the episode is the line "If you're offended and ready to walk, Remember we're only drawings that talk." OMG. The writers RECOGNIZED how horrible this episode and this song are, how hateful and harmful it is, and shrug it off as "oh well, it's just a cartoon". Really? Then why did the 3 showrunners who made this and other episodes say the following...

 Rob LaZebnik said "Sometimes TV can have a real impact on people's thinking." He said this when discussing the episode where Smithers came out as gay, noting that he worked directly with his gay son to make sure the portrayal was accurate and respectful.

 Matt Selman said "Anger is a great motivating force for social change!" when explaining how the writers' room uses real-life stories to raise awareness and push social change.

 Al Jean said "The Simpsons started as counter-culture and became culture", directly admitting that the show actively shapes how millions of people think.

This proves that the showrunners not only KNOW that their show affects society, they WANT it to affect society, so for them to brush off the great harm this episode will do with the comment "it's just a cartoon" adds even MORE offensiveness! It means that other groups MATTER to these showrunners, and have their respect, but autistic people DO NOT.

The Simpsons has already retired characters that were later found to be offensive, and has even edited past episodes to fix offensive racial stereotypes and improve LGBTQ accuracy. But then they make a NEW episode that is extremely offensive and try to preemptively reject any complaints by saying it's just a cartoon RIGHT IN THE EPISODE! That was the last straw that pushed me to write this petition.

So, I propose that we call on Fox and The Simpsons writers to pull this episode or edit it heavily, issue a public apology, and start HELPING autistic people by educating the public instead of perpetuating harmful ideas about us. They claim to be promoters of social justice, so they shouldn't have a problem with this.

Rob GPetition Starter

Petition Updates