EVIDENCE TIMELINE SUPPORTING AN INDEPENDENT INVESTIGATION INTO THE DEATH OF Nolan Wells

16

Let’s get to 25 signatures!
Petitions with 1,000+ supporters are 5x more likely to win!

The Issue

 

Prepared by Leavie Scott
This timeline is submitted in support of the petition requesting an independent investigation into the death of 18-year-old Nolan Xavier Wells and the handling of the evidence afterward.

The timeline does not declare any individual guilty. Its purpose is to show where objective records, witness accounts, forensic findings, and official statements appear to leave material questions unresolved.

July 3, 2026: The night before the trip
Nolan Wells reportedly had dinner with his family and later left to stay with friends before the Independence Day trip. [newsnationnow.com]

Evidence that should be preserved and reviewed:

Nolan’s communications from that evening;
Messages planning the trip;
Names of the people expected to travel together;
Transportation and lodging arrangements;
Any discussion about how Nolan would return home.
This evidence could clarify whether Nolan expected to remain with the same group throughout the trip and whether he had independently arranged another ride.

 
July 4, 2026: Trip to Horn Island
Approximately 9:56 a.m.: Boat departs the mainland
GPS data reportedly shows the boat carrying Nolan Wells and his friends departing the mainland at approximately 9:56 a.m. [atlantatribune.com]

Shortly after 11:00 a.m.: Arrival at the island
The same reporting states that the boat arrived at Horn Island shortly after 11:00 a.m. [atlantatribune.com]

This establishes an objective starting point for a reconstruction of the day. Investigators should synchronize the boat’s original GPS data with photographs, videos, phone-location records, messages, and witness accounts.

Approximately 2:17 to 2:18 p.m.: Last reported use of Nolan’s phone
The digital-forensics report states that Nolan Wells’s phone was last used at approximately 2:17 or 2:18 p.m. on July 4. It reportedly remained locked until it was with his family on July 5. [newsnationnow.com], [newsnationnow.com]

This is a critical digital-evidence point.

An independent examiner should determine:

What Nolan’s final affirmative phone action was;
Which application was used;
The last outgoing and incoming communications;
Where the device was located at that time;
When the device became separated from Nolan;
Who physically possessed it afterward;
Whether the screen was activated after Nolan’s last use;
What notifications appeared on the locked screen;
Whether any account activity occurred remotely.
Published reporting does not establish that anyone unlocked Nolan’s phone and manually erased evidence. The available forensic account says that certain Snapchat senders recalled or deleted their own messages remotely. [newsnationnow.com], [newsnationnow.com]

That distinction should remain clear while investigators determine who recalled messages, when they did so, and whether the actions occurred after the senders knew that Nolan was missing or that an investigation was likely.

Approximately 3:00 p.m.: Reported last-seen time
Early accounts placed Nolan’s last confirmed sighting at approximately 3:00 p.m. Witnesses reportedly said that Nolan intended to obtain another ride to the mainland. [newsnationnow.com], [atlantatribune.com]

This statement should not be accepted or rejected without testing it against objective evidence.

The evidence archive identifies an unresolved issue involving how a reported 3:00 p.m. “last seen” time became associated with a 3:00 p.m. boat-departure account. The same archive states that later Apple Maps and Garmin records reflect movement around 4:28 to 4:31 p.m. [justicefor...nwells.com]

Investigators should establish:

Who last saw Nolan at approximately 3:00 p.m.;
The exact location of that sighting;
Who heard Nolan say he would secure another ride;
Whether that statement was documented firsthand or relayed through others;
Whether any video or photograph records Nolan after 3:00 p.m.;
Whether witnesses’ later accounts remained consistent with their earliest statements.
Between approximately 3:00 and 4:31 p.m.: The critical unresolved period
This period deserves the closest independent examination.

The publicly available evidence archive references accounts involving an altercation, an observation gap, a boarding dispute, and the boat emergency. It also identifies an allegedly compressed information chain surrounding the 3:00 p.m. account. [justicefor...nwells.com], [justicefor...nwells.com]

These references do not establish that an assault caused Nolan’s death. However, they create specific investigative questions:

Was Nolan involved in or present during an altercation?
Did Nolan suffer an injury during this period?
Who saw him between 3:00 and 4:31 p.m.?
Was he conscious, mobile, and communicating normally?
Did he attempt to board any boat?
Did anyone prevent him from boarding?
Was a confirmed ride arranged for him?
Did any witness photograph or record him during this period?
When was his absence first recognized?
Why did his phone leave without him?
Every witness account should be plotted on a single minute-by-minute timeline and compared with GPS data, videos, photographs, messages, call logs, and vessel movements.

Approximately 4:28 to 4:31 p.m.: Recorded movement and boat departure
The evidence archive reports an Apple Maps display at approximately 4:28 p.m. and Garmin movement at approximately 4:31 p.m. Separate reporting states that the boat departed the island at approximately 4:31 p.m. without Nolan. [justicefor...nwells.com], [atlantatribune.com]

This creates a material difference between the objective departure time and earlier reporting centered on 3:00 p.m.

Investigators should obtain the native GPS files, device logs, vessel tracks, and associated metadata. Screenshots or summaries should not replace the underlying records.

Return trip and distress call
A recording released through a public-records request reportedly captured someone aboard the returning boat contacting a private towing company because the vessel was taking on water. [atlantatribune.com]

Public commentary has raised questions about different versions of this recording and whether a name can be heard in one version but not another. Those claims do not establish that the audio was intentionally altered or that anyone caused Nolan’s death. [youtube.com], [youtube.com]

An independent forensic-audio examination should compare:

The native recording;
Every agency-retained version;
Every publicly released copy;
Separate caller and dispatcher channels;
File metadata and creation dates;
Export and redaction procedures;
File hashes;
Any edits made for privacy or public release.
Investigators should also determine whether anything heard in the call describes an accident, injury, movement of a person, or purely the vessel emergency.

Approximately 11:00 p.m.: Nolan reported missing
Nolan’s family reportedly learned that he had not returned and reported him missing at approximately 11:00 p.m. [newsnationnow.com]

Investigators should reconstruct the period between the boat’s approximately 4:31 p.m. departure and the missing-person report:

When did the group reach the mainland?
When did each person realize Nolan was absent?
Who first attempted to contact him?
Who had his phone?
When was the family notified?
Why was the family not notified sooner, if a delay occurred?
What messages were sent or recalled during this period?
What information was initially given to law enforcement?
 
July 5, 2026: Search begins
A multiagency search commenced with participation from the Jackson County Sheriff’s Department, the United States Coast Guard, the National Park Service, the Mississippi Department of Marine Resources, and the United Cajun Navy. Weather reportedly shortened the first day’s search. [newsnationnow.com], [thegrio.com]

The independent review should obtain:

The original missing-person intake;
Search maps and assignments;
Aircraft, drone, vessel, and personnel logs;
Dispatch and radio communications;
Weather-related suspension decisions;
Locations searched and times completed;
Witness information provided to search planners;
The stated last-seen location used to establish search boundaries.
If the original 3:00 p.m. account or location was inaccurate, investigators should determine whether that information materially affected the search.

 
July 6, 2026: Nolan’s body recovered
A National Park Service ranger reportedly discovered a body shortly before 8:45 a.m. near the northwestern end of Horn Island. Nolan’s mother later confirmed that the body was her son’s. [thegrio.com]

The final independent autopsy review describes photographs showing Nolan face down on the shoreline with his head in the sand and additional photographs showing him face down in the water. The report does not establish which position came first, whether the body was moved, who may have moved it, or the exact initial discovery position. [justicefor...nwells.com]

This uncertainty requires a formal recovery-scene reconstruction.

Investigators should establish:

The precise GPS coordinates at first discovery;
The ranger’s original observations;
Whether Nolan was first seen in water, at the waterline, or on exposed shoreline;
Whether anyone moved or repositioned him;
The chronological order of every photograph;
Tide, current, wind, and wave conditions;
Whether clothing, sand, vegetation, marks, or debris indicate movement;
Whether the body’s condition was consistent with the government’s proposed recovery scenario.
The evidence currently available does not prove that Nolan’s body was intentionally placed on the beach. It does show that the sequence of the shoreline and water photographs requires clarification.

The sheriff reportedly stated on July 6 that no foul play was suspected. [newsnationnow.com]

An independent review should determine what evidence supported that early assessment and whether officials had already reviewed the recovery scene, witness statements, phone records, injuries, and forensic evidence when that statement was made.

 
July 7, 2026: Identification, official autopsy, and legal representation
Dental records reportedly identified the body as Nolan Wells. An official autopsy was conducted, and the family retained civil-rights attorney Ben Crump. [atlantatribune.com], [thegrio.com]

The full chain of custody should identify every individual and agency responsible for Nolan’s body, clothing, personal effects, biological specimens, photographs, and retained tissues.

 
July 10, 2026: Independent autopsy
The family arranged for an independent autopsy after the original examination. The second pathologist encountered decomposition and limitations because organs had been dissected and certain internal neck structures had been retained during the original examination. [newsnationnow.com], [people.com], [abcnews.com]

The retention of neck structures is not, by itself, proof of misconduct. Medical reporting explains that such structures may be routinely retained for additional radiographic examination. However, the handling limited what the second pathologist could independently assess at that time. [newsnationnow.com]

 
July 16, 2026: Distress-call audio becomes public
Audio obtained through a public-records request captured the reported towing-company call from the return trip. [atlantatribune.com]

This release created a fixed point for comparing public copies against the native government-held recording. Every version should be preserved and independently authenticated.

 
September 14, 2026: Final independent autopsy report
Dr. Roger A. Mitchell Jr. issued the final independent report. The report maintained that the cause and manner of Nolan’s death were undetermined. It identified posterior scalp contusions associated with blunt-force injury and described probable additional bruises based on the original photographs. The mechanism and contribution of those injuries to Nolan’s death remained unexplained. [justicefor...nwells.com]

The final report also states:

Retained neck structures were later examined without acute injury;
The original examiner did not identify water in the airway or gastric contents;
“Airway” does not separately establish whether the lungs contained water;
Photographs showed shoreline and water positions;
The reported ethanol result came from decomposition fluid and could not reliably establish Nolan’s blood-alcohol level at death. [justicefor...nwells.com]
These findings do not establish homicide or accidental drowning. They show why a definitive conclusion has not been reached.

 
September 18, 2026: Grand jury returns no indictment
A grand jury unanimously returned a No True Bill, and no one was indicted. Both forensic pathologists assessed the cause and manner of death as undetermined. [justicefor...nwells.com], [justicefor...nwells.com]

A no-indictment decision must be accurately acknowledged. However, questions remain about what materials were presented, which witnesses testified, whether conflicting timelines were reconciled, and whether the final independent report was fully available for consideration.

This petition does not ask a reviewing authority to disregard the grand jury. It asks an independent authority to determine whether all material evidence was preserved, tested, disclosed, and properly evaluated.

Timeline-based requests for action
Based on this timeline, the petition requests:

A minute-by-minute reconstruction of July 4 using native GPS, phone, video, photo, and vessel records.
Identification and reinterview of everyone who saw Nolan after 3:00 p.m.
Reconciliation of the 3:00 p.m. account with the approximately 4:31 p.m. vessel departure.
Independent examination of Nolan’s phone and account records.
Identification of recalled messages, their senders, and recall timestamps.
Authentication of every version of the towing-company recording.
Reconstruction of the July 6 recovery scene and the order of the shoreline and water photographs.
Independent marine drift analysis using archived environmental data.
Peer review of the original and independent autopsies.
A full audit of evidence and body chain of custody.
Review of the factual basis for the early public statement that foul play was not suspected.
Referral to an independent prosecutor if admissible evidence establishes probable cause of criminal conduct.
Closing statement
This timeline establishes a narrow but important argument: objective time records exist, witness accounts exist, forensic findings exist, and important questions remain unresolved.

It does not establish who caused Nolan Wells’s death.

The proper response is not to declare guilt without due process. The proper response is to preserve the evidence, reconcile the timeline, investigate every material inconsistency, and disclose conclusions supported by verifiable facts.

Nolan Xavier Wells and his family deserve an investigation capable of explaining what happened between his last confirmed phone activity, the reported 3:00 p.m. sighting, the approximately 4:31 p.m. boat departure, the delayed missing-person report, and the discovery of his body on July 6.

Respectfully submitted,

Leavie Scott
Petitioner

avatar of the starter
Lee ScottPetition StarterI work about three jobs I take care of my brother in Chicago which have a mental disorder and I take care of other people as a caregiver and Wisconsin and Chicago. I have a law degree to be a paralegal and studying for real estate.

The Decision Makers

John Ledbetter
Jackson County Sheriff

Petition Updates