

Do Not Let Saddleback and IVC Violate Students Privacy
The Issue
South Orange County Community Colleges have asked students to install a Chrome web extension called Proctorio to monitor online test taking and ensure that academic honesty is upheld. While these intentions are in good faith, the execution is abhorrent.
The web extension, which allows instructors to choose a series of tools by which the program will flag students for "suspicious behavior," is extremely intrusive unnecessary. The former way of proctoring online exams through Canvas LMS already allowed teachers to see when a student was suspected of cheating.
The following requirements were copied directly from a test that was given last week through using the Proctorio web extension listing what the extension will access for the entirety of the test taken at home:
Your microphone
Your webcam
Your physical location
Your identity
Your clipboard
Your mouse location
Your browser size
Your browser tabs and windows
Your head movements
Your eye movements
Your mouth movements
Your entire screen
Any website you visit
A scan of your testing environment
Any other applications running
Number of display screens connected
To sum this up, Proctorio can:
READ and CHANGE all the data on a student's web browser,
Modifies students' keyboard functionality,
Monitors and stores KEYSTROKE movements while using the computer,
Captures ALL SCREEN CONTENT on the student's computer,
Manages and CHANGES any downloads on the student's computer,
Identifies ALL devices connected to a student's computer,
Manages ALL apps, extensions, and even themes on a student's computer,
Changes ALL privacy-related settings on a student's computer,
Monitors EYE MOVEMENTS via webcam and saves all recordings,
Records and stores ALL sounds while in use,
Requires initial and periodic ROOM scans.
Proctorio is a direct and abhorrent violation of privacy at every conceivable level. Full and unrestricted access to personal data from students (computers, private physical rooms, and other means of identification/monitoring) is a despicable overreach by SOCCCD. It is unacceptable that students must surrender their civil rights, especially while attending a public institution, to complete their education.
According to Proctorio's data security page, "The exam data is transferred and stored with zero-knowledge encryption and can only be accessed by your exam administrators." While Saddleback and Irvine college states that only instructors (or approved individuals at the university) will be able to view the recorded footage, which can be held on servers for up to six months. The caveat of "approved individuals" means that there are a number of people who can view recordings of the student’s private residents without their knowledge for a period of up to six months.
The company, and others like it, are profiting off of the forced relinquishment of student’s privacy. There are no alternatives for test taking right now since a majority of campuses remain closed due to concerns surrounding the COVID-19 pandemic.
Major universities like Duke University have opted out of using this program citing privacy concerns as their main reason. ( this was written about in a Forbes article that can be viewed below)
Yet the SOCCCD has opted to place students assumed lack of integrity over their privacy rights.
SOCCCD colleges must create solutions to test-taking that do not violate students' right to privacy, especially in their own homes. This manner of proctoring online exams is only a band-aid and is not sustainable. Our colleges and professors are better than stooping to this level of test proctoring.
Please sign the petition to show administration officials at SOCCCD, IVC, and Saddleback schools that this unacceptable.
Petition Closed
The Issue
South Orange County Community Colleges have asked students to install a Chrome web extension called Proctorio to monitor online test taking and ensure that academic honesty is upheld. While these intentions are in good faith, the execution is abhorrent.
The web extension, which allows instructors to choose a series of tools by which the program will flag students for "suspicious behavior," is extremely intrusive unnecessary. The former way of proctoring online exams through Canvas LMS already allowed teachers to see when a student was suspected of cheating.
The following requirements were copied directly from a test that was given last week through using the Proctorio web extension listing what the extension will access for the entirety of the test taken at home:
Your microphone
Your webcam
Your physical location
Your identity
Your clipboard
Your mouse location
Your browser size
Your browser tabs and windows
Your head movements
Your eye movements
Your mouth movements
Your entire screen
Any website you visit
A scan of your testing environment
Any other applications running
Number of display screens connected
To sum this up, Proctorio can:
READ and CHANGE all the data on a student's web browser,
Modifies students' keyboard functionality,
Monitors and stores KEYSTROKE movements while using the computer,
Captures ALL SCREEN CONTENT on the student's computer,
Manages and CHANGES any downloads on the student's computer,
Identifies ALL devices connected to a student's computer,
Manages ALL apps, extensions, and even themes on a student's computer,
Changes ALL privacy-related settings on a student's computer,
Monitors EYE MOVEMENTS via webcam and saves all recordings,
Records and stores ALL sounds while in use,
Requires initial and periodic ROOM scans.
Proctorio is a direct and abhorrent violation of privacy at every conceivable level. Full and unrestricted access to personal data from students (computers, private physical rooms, and other means of identification/monitoring) is a despicable overreach by SOCCCD. It is unacceptable that students must surrender their civil rights, especially while attending a public institution, to complete their education.
According to Proctorio's data security page, "The exam data is transferred and stored with zero-knowledge encryption and can only be accessed by your exam administrators." While Saddleback and Irvine college states that only instructors (or approved individuals at the university) will be able to view the recorded footage, which can be held on servers for up to six months. The caveat of "approved individuals" means that there are a number of people who can view recordings of the student’s private residents without their knowledge for a period of up to six months.
The company, and others like it, are profiting off of the forced relinquishment of student’s privacy. There are no alternatives for test taking right now since a majority of campuses remain closed due to concerns surrounding the COVID-19 pandemic.
Major universities like Duke University have opted out of using this program citing privacy concerns as their main reason. ( this was written about in a Forbes article that can be viewed below)
Yet the SOCCCD has opted to place students assumed lack of integrity over their privacy rights.
SOCCCD colleges must create solutions to test-taking that do not violate students' right to privacy, especially in their own homes. This manner of proctoring online exams is only a band-aid and is not sustainable. Our colleges and professors are better than stooping to this level of test proctoring.
Please sign the petition to show administration officials at SOCCCD, IVC, and Saddleback schools that this unacceptable.
The Decision Makers
Supporter Voices
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on September 7, 2020