

Demand Lucas County Sheriff Reveal What Happened to 2020 Cat Abuse Report
The Issue
In June 2020, two separate complaints reached local law enforcement about an online video that appeared to show a teenager hurting a cat. Sylvania Township police saved the video as evidence, and the township prosecutor said the case belonged with the Lucas County Sheriff’s Office. The township closed its file without an arrest and handed it over.
After that, the record goes quiet. The police report doesn’t show what the sheriff’s office did with the case, if anything.
The video resurfaced this fall while the person it appears to show was running for the Ohio House. More than 150 people then emailed public records requests asking what happened to the original complaint. Sheriff Mike Navarre, who took office in 2021, says he only learned about the case recently. He has assigned a detective to reopen it and find out what was done in 2020, what wasn’t, and why.
That’s an important first step. Because the video is believed to be about 11 years old, it’s unclear whether charges can still be filed under Ohio’s time limits of 6 years for felonies and 2 years for misdemeanors. That makes the answer about 2020 matter even more. If a cruelty complaint can sit with no clear follow-up, people in Lucas County deserve to know how that happened and what will stop it from happening again.
Sheriff Navarre told WTOL 11 that the people who sent those emails will want to know the outcome. He should commit to releasing the detective’s findings to the public, explaining what became of the 2020 referral, and sharing any changes to how his office handles animal cruelty complaints from now on.
Animals can’t report abuse on their own. They depend on the neighbors who speak up, and on officials who follow through.
Sign the petition to ask Sheriff Navarre to make the findings public, so the next cruelty complaint in Lucas County doesn’t disappear.
335
The Issue
In June 2020, two separate complaints reached local law enforcement about an online video that appeared to show a teenager hurting a cat. Sylvania Township police saved the video as evidence, and the township prosecutor said the case belonged with the Lucas County Sheriff’s Office. The township closed its file without an arrest and handed it over.
After that, the record goes quiet. The police report doesn’t show what the sheriff’s office did with the case, if anything.
The video resurfaced this fall while the person it appears to show was running for the Ohio House. More than 150 people then emailed public records requests asking what happened to the original complaint. Sheriff Mike Navarre, who took office in 2021, says he only learned about the case recently. He has assigned a detective to reopen it and find out what was done in 2020, what wasn’t, and why.
That’s an important first step. Because the video is believed to be about 11 years old, it’s unclear whether charges can still be filed under Ohio’s time limits of 6 years for felonies and 2 years for misdemeanors. That makes the answer about 2020 matter even more. If a cruelty complaint can sit with no clear follow-up, people in Lucas County deserve to know how that happened and what will stop it from happening again.
Sheriff Navarre told WTOL 11 that the people who sent those emails will want to know the outcome. He should commit to releasing the detective’s findings to the public, explaining what became of the 2020 referral, and sharing any changes to how his office handles animal cruelty complaints from now on.
Animals can’t report abuse on their own. They depend on the neighbors who speak up, and on officials who follow through.
Sign the petition to ask Sheriff Navarre to make the findings public, so the next cruelty complaint in Lucas County doesn’t disappear.
The Decision Makers
Supporter Voices
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on November 11, 2026