

Demand Full Prosecution and a Lifetime Animal Ban in Peru’s Death
The Issue
Peru was a pit bull mix from Monticello, New York. According to the Sullivan County Sheriff’s Office, a necropsy showed Peru had been stabbed several times in the neck with a barbecue grill fork. Investigators ruled that Peru died of asphyxiation. Peru’s body was later found in a shallow grave near a home on Airport Road in the Town of Bethel.
The case surfaced after Sullivan County Child Protective Services (CPS) contacted the Sheriff’s Office on November 5. On November 10, deputies arrested two Monticello residents. Both are charged with felony Aggravated Animal Cruelty and felony Tampering with Evidence, along with a misdemeanor charge of Endangering the Welfare of a Minor. After appearing in Town of Thompson Court, both were released while they wait for their next court date.
A dog was killed and buried, evidence was allegedly tampered with, and a child endangerment charge came with it. A case like this should never be quietly bargained down. Sheriff Mike Schiff has said his deputies work closely with the District Attorney’s Office to hold animal abusers accountable. Now that commitment needs to hold up in the courtroom.
Sullivan County District Attorney Brian Conaty decides how this case is prosecuted. Supporters of Peru are asking the District Attorney to pursue the felony animal cruelty charge to the fullest extent of the law, without reducing it to a lesser offense, and to ask the court to bar anyone convicted from owning, living with, or caring for animals for life.
According to Sheriff Schiff, anyone convicted of animal cruelty in Sullivan County is placed on the Animal Cruelty Offender List and could face jail time, probation, or a fine. Peru deserves the strongest outcome the law allows, and other animals deserve protection too.
Sign the petition to demand justice for Peru before this case slips through the cracks.
503
The Issue
Peru was a pit bull mix from Monticello, New York. According to the Sullivan County Sheriff’s Office, a necropsy showed Peru had been stabbed several times in the neck with a barbecue grill fork. Investigators ruled that Peru died of asphyxiation. Peru’s body was later found in a shallow grave near a home on Airport Road in the Town of Bethel.
The case surfaced after Sullivan County Child Protective Services (CPS) contacted the Sheriff’s Office on November 5. On November 10, deputies arrested two Monticello residents. Both are charged with felony Aggravated Animal Cruelty and felony Tampering with Evidence, along with a misdemeanor charge of Endangering the Welfare of a Minor. After appearing in Town of Thompson Court, both were released while they wait for their next court date.
A dog was killed and buried, evidence was allegedly tampered with, and a child endangerment charge came with it. A case like this should never be quietly bargained down. Sheriff Mike Schiff has said his deputies work closely with the District Attorney’s Office to hold animal abusers accountable. Now that commitment needs to hold up in the courtroom.
Sullivan County District Attorney Brian Conaty decides how this case is prosecuted. Supporters of Peru are asking the District Attorney to pursue the felony animal cruelty charge to the fullest extent of the law, without reducing it to a lesser offense, and to ask the court to bar anyone convicted from owning, living with, or caring for animals for life.
According to Sheriff Schiff, anyone convicted of animal cruelty in Sullivan County is placed on the Animal Cruelty Offender List and could face jail time, probation, or a fine. Peru deserves the strongest outcome the law allows, and other animals deserve protection too.
Sign the petition to demand justice for Peru before this case slips through the cracks.
The Decision Makers

Supporter Voices
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on November 12, 2026