Deactivation of the Historical Silver Cup Ridge Trail & Rady Ck Road near Trout Lake BC
The Issue
Urgent request for immediate provincial pause and legal review on the proposed deactivation of the top 4.3 kms of Rady Creek Road. The Trout Lake Recreational Club and the Arrow Lakes Ridge Riders formally request intervention due to significant legal procedural, environmental and public interest concerns.
1. Historical and Public Access Significance - Rady Creek Rd. built in 1901 is an historical 130 plus-year old legacy corridor used for recreation, mining, forestry and wildfire response. It includes 3.5 kilometers of the original miner-built road plus 0.4 kilometers of the Registered Silver Cup Ridge Trail #2372. Irreversible loss of established access.
2. Conflict with Provincial Policy and Planning - FPPR requires public review / comment, (Part1.1, Division 5, ss. 4.32 – 4.36) and supporting assessments (s.4.13). No evidence to indicate these were meaningfully satisfied.
3. Legal implications - Mining Access Rights: Mining Right of Way Act Section 2, 3, 10 Mineral Tenure Act section 11 and 11.1 certainty of access, Mines Act section 10. Deactivation interferes with statutory rights, helicopter only access may deny reasonable access for operators.
4. Failure to Meet Engineering and Professional Standards: Ministry of Forest Engineering Manual 2026 and Road Deactivation Guidelines Chapter 7 require professional oversight, assessments and consideration of future access, safety and values. This aligns with Joint Professional Practice Guidelines.
Critical gap - no disclosed TSFA, Geotechnical Report or Hydrology Report – noncompliance, due diligence failure, liability risk.
5. Environmental and safety risks: FPPR Section 3 prohibits environmental damage. Full contouring with oversized excavators’ risks slope instability, erosion, sedimentation and long-term ecological disruption including mycorrhizal networks.
6. Wildfire Response and Public Safety: Roads are critical infrastructure for access, emergency response and risk management. Deactivation eliminates ground-based options, increases helicopter reliance and reduces preparedness for communities.
7. Procedural Fairness and Consultation Failure: Absence of meaningful consultation and refusal to meet violates FPPR and administrative law principles. Stakeholders denied input before irreversible decisions are made.
8. Failure to Demonstrate Least Impact Option: Engineering manual requires evaluating alternatives (ie. - reduced standard / wilderness Rd, non - status classification, targeted stabilization, FS 1205 maintenance agreements) or section 57 which is on the table. Full deactivation may be unreasonable / disproportionate.
9. BC Outdoor Recreation Strategy: Quotes strategy on sustainable accessible recreation. Rady Creek is a high value for clubs / communities, (section 57 application pending) Trout Lake relies solely on the outdoors.
10. Revenue Comparison: Recreation / Outdoor Tourism $17 billion gross, (2025) Mining $16.4 billion net. Forestry 17.4 billion gross. Highlights balanced importance of Recreation / Tourism to the British Columbia economy.
11. Southern Mountain Caribou Habitat: Our Clubs are leaders in Caribou habitat stewardship via a 7 - year SMA (Stewardship Management Agreement) with the FLNRORD / BC Snowmobile Federation. Responsible management has been demonstrated during this period.
12. Caribou Management Map: Daily refresh map tracks collared caribou; areas are opened/ closed based on caribou location.
13. Deactivation Prescription Concerns: 4.3 -kilometer plan. The narrow historic mine road requires extreme modification / recontouring destruction (excavator is wider than the road). Devastating to the 1901 era mycorrhizal vegetation system.
14. Deactivation Map: Details green - FSR permit, black - mine road for deactivation, yellow - is Silver Cup Ridge Trail, overlap pink – portion of Silver Ridge Trail #2372 scheduled for deactivation.
15. Requested Actions: Immediate pause on the scheduled August 2026 deactivation: complete disclosure, required assessments; FPR compliance and public review, reviewing mining access rights; consider low impact alternatives and direct stakeholder engagement.
16. Conclusion: Not a routine deactivation – It represents a decision with material consequences for statutory access rights, safety, environmental integrity and rural livelihoods. The deactivation must be technically justified, procedurally fair, legally compliant, and in the public interest. Standards appear unmet, a pause is clearly justified.
4,100
The Issue
Urgent request for immediate provincial pause and legal review on the proposed deactivation of the top 4.3 kms of Rady Creek Road. The Trout Lake Recreational Club and the Arrow Lakes Ridge Riders formally request intervention due to significant legal procedural, environmental and public interest concerns.
1. Historical and Public Access Significance - Rady Creek Rd. built in 1901 is an historical 130 plus-year old legacy corridor used for recreation, mining, forestry and wildfire response. It includes 3.5 kilometers of the original miner-built road plus 0.4 kilometers of the Registered Silver Cup Ridge Trail #2372. Irreversible loss of established access.
2. Conflict with Provincial Policy and Planning - FPPR requires public review / comment, (Part1.1, Division 5, ss. 4.32 – 4.36) and supporting assessments (s.4.13). No evidence to indicate these were meaningfully satisfied.
3. Legal implications - Mining Access Rights: Mining Right of Way Act Section 2, 3, 10 Mineral Tenure Act section 11 and 11.1 certainty of access, Mines Act section 10. Deactivation interferes with statutory rights, helicopter only access may deny reasonable access for operators.
4. Failure to Meet Engineering and Professional Standards: Ministry of Forest Engineering Manual 2026 and Road Deactivation Guidelines Chapter 7 require professional oversight, assessments and consideration of future access, safety and values. This aligns with Joint Professional Practice Guidelines.
Critical gap - no disclosed TSFA, Geotechnical Report or Hydrology Report – noncompliance, due diligence failure, liability risk.
5. Environmental and safety risks: FPPR Section 3 prohibits environmental damage. Full contouring with oversized excavators’ risks slope instability, erosion, sedimentation and long-term ecological disruption including mycorrhizal networks.
6. Wildfire Response and Public Safety: Roads are critical infrastructure for access, emergency response and risk management. Deactivation eliminates ground-based options, increases helicopter reliance and reduces preparedness for communities.
7. Procedural Fairness and Consultation Failure: Absence of meaningful consultation and refusal to meet violates FPPR and administrative law principles. Stakeholders denied input before irreversible decisions are made.
8. Failure to Demonstrate Least Impact Option: Engineering manual requires evaluating alternatives (ie. - reduced standard / wilderness Rd, non - status classification, targeted stabilization, FS 1205 maintenance agreements) or section 57 which is on the table. Full deactivation may be unreasonable / disproportionate.
9. BC Outdoor Recreation Strategy: Quotes strategy on sustainable accessible recreation. Rady Creek is a high value for clubs / communities, (section 57 application pending) Trout Lake relies solely on the outdoors.
10. Revenue Comparison: Recreation / Outdoor Tourism $17 billion gross, (2025) Mining $16.4 billion net. Forestry 17.4 billion gross. Highlights balanced importance of Recreation / Tourism to the British Columbia economy.
11. Southern Mountain Caribou Habitat: Our Clubs are leaders in Caribou habitat stewardship via a 7 - year SMA (Stewardship Management Agreement) with the FLNRORD / BC Snowmobile Federation. Responsible management has been demonstrated during this period.
12. Caribou Management Map: Daily refresh map tracks collared caribou; areas are opened/ closed based on caribou location.
13. Deactivation Prescription Concerns: 4.3 -kilometer plan. The narrow historic mine road requires extreme modification / recontouring destruction (excavator is wider than the road). Devastating to the 1901 era mycorrhizal vegetation system.
14. Deactivation Map: Details green - FSR permit, black - mine road for deactivation, yellow - is Silver Cup Ridge Trail, overlap pink – portion of Silver Ridge Trail #2372 scheduled for deactivation.
15. Requested Actions: Immediate pause on the scheduled August 2026 deactivation: complete disclosure, required assessments; FPR compliance and public review, reviewing mining access rights; consider low impact alternatives and direct stakeholder engagement.
16. Conclusion: Not a routine deactivation – It represents a decision with material consequences for statutory access rights, safety, environmental integrity and rural livelihoods. The deactivation must be technically justified, procedurally fair, legally compliant, and in the public interest. Standards appear unmet, a pause is clearly justified.
Supporter Voices
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on July 10, 2026