Daisy’s Law to Recognize Animals as Family, Not Chattel in NY

1,895

The Issue

My heart aches as I share the story of my beloved dog, Daisy, who tragically died due to negligence and malpractice. The pain and suffering my family endured during this heartbreaking period felt immeasurable, yet under current New York law, I couldn't collect any damages related to this emotional distress. This is because Daisy was considered mere property or 'chattel' by the legal system, thus denying us the acknowledgment that our pets are indeed cherished family members. Additionally, there has been no way to hold the veterinarian accountable as the licensing board is so backlogged that any hearing is not in the near future. While no amount of money will bring Daisy back, this is a way to recognize her value and to hold the veterinarian accountable for their actions.

In many households across New York, animals are more than just pets; they are companions, confidantes, and beloved family members. However, the state's legal viewpoint does not reflect this sentiment. Currently, animals are classified as personal property, akin to inanimate objects such as furniture, limiting the rights and protections they and their human families receive.

This outdated classification can lead to grave injustices, exemplified by cases like Daisy's where negligence may occur but accountability is not proportionately recognized. New York State can lead by example, revising existing laws to redefine animals as more than property and approximating their status closer to that of family members in the eyes of the law.

Laws should recognize the intrinsic value of animals, considering the emotional bond they form with their owners. Implementing such changes would not only encourage responsible pet ownership but also ensure that when harm is caused due to negligence, the affected families have proper legal recourse. Similar initiatives have been introduced in other parts of the world, demonstrating the feasibility and positive impacts of such reforms.

By signing this petition, you are advocating for the passage of a law in New York that offers animals the protection and status they rightfully deserve, aligning with the communal acknowledgment of their familial role in our lives. Let's honor our beloved companions like Daisy by ensuring they are protected under laws that consider their importance beyond mere possessions. Sign this petition to transform how our legal system views and values our animal family members.

The Decision Makers

Kathy Hochul
New York Governor
New York State Senate
2 Members
Robert Jackson
New York State Senate - District 31
Andrew Gounardes
New York State Senate - District 26

Supporter Voices

Petition Updates