Compromise on Lakeview Cell Phone Policy

834

Let’s get to 1000 signatures!
Petitions with 1,000+ supporters are 5x more likely to win!

The Issue

In Battle Creek, MI, a new cell phone policy is introducing unnecessary stress. It is a policy that many people , including me, find unfair and unjust. I believe that students should have access to their phones in case of emergencies, and the current policy does not accommodate this essential need.

Over the years, cell phones have evolved into indispensable tools for maintaining safety and communication, especially for students in school environments. With increasing concerns over school safety, phones can provide a life-saving mode of communication between students and their families during emergencies. Eliminating the ability to access these devices altogether neglects the safety and well-being of students.

Moreover, consider situations beyond emergencies: parents needing to communicate with their child regarding urgent family matters, a student requiring medication reminders, or even simple schedule changes. Banning phone usage cuts off a vital communication channel between students and their parents.

Lakeview should aim for a balanced policy. Instead of a blanket ban, I propose a compromise wherein students can keep their phones on silent mode and only use them during designated times like lunch or study hall. This approach ensures that students remain focused on their studies while still having access to their cell phones for critical communication.

Multiple schools have successfully implemented such procedures, maintaining both academic integrity and personal safety. By adopting a similar strategy, Lakeview can demonstrate responsiveness to student needs, acknowledging phones as essential tools, not just distractions.

Stand with us to reevaluate and adjust the Lakeview cell phone policy to better accommodate our safety needs. Sign this petition to advocate for a change that respects both educational environments and personal circumstances. Together, we can ensure Lakeview reflects a balanced and fair approach for our students. 

Sign the petition to support a compromise on the Lakeview cell phone policy.

The Decision Makers

Lakeview School Board (Calhoun)
3 Members
2 Responded
Lakeview School Board (Calhoun)
“As president of the Lakeview School District Board of Education, I appreciate the effort by Lakeview students to share their perspective on a recent policy change regarding personal electronic devices in the Lakeview School District. I also appreciate the opportunity, on behalf of the board, to provide additional perspective about how the board arrived at its decision on July 28. To give some background on how this policy came about, a group of Lakeview teachers and administrators approached the school board a couple months ago with a proposed policy change regarding personal electronic devices. They proposed a bell-to-bell prohibition because they have observed a pattern of in-class distractions (cell phone notifications, social media usage, online bullying, etc.) that is creating an overwhelming challenge to Lakeview’s learning environment. Nationally, while school phone policies have changed over the years, many districts are moving in the same direction as Lakeview because teachers – who already have plenty on their plates – are advocating for all-day bans. I saw a statistic recently that, nationally, 83 percent of teachers support an all-day ban on cell phones. Here’s an article with more information on this issue: https://www.nea.org/nea-today/all-news-articles/take-cellphones-out-classroom-educators-say In short, the intent of the policy is to remove the distraction by removing the cell phones. As a result, Lakeview expects to see improvements in focus and interpersonal skills that lead to higher academic performance. And as a school board that cares very much about giving students opportunities for learning across all of Lakeview, we unanimously supported this policy change. Our hope is that, after a transition period at the beginning of the school year, students, teachers and parents all become accustomed to this change and find it to be working as intended. We appreciate students’ comments about how cell phones play a role in stress and communication access, especially in times when safety could be compromised. I don’t disagree that, depending on the individual, keeping a cell phone in one’s pocket can enhance the perception of safety. I also respect that there are differing opinions about this. Here is a blog post from the National School Safety and Security Services, which discusses how the use of cell phones during major emergencies can actually increase risk: https://schoolsecurity.org/trends/cell-phones-and-text-messaging-in-schools/ Additionally, while there are numerous studies and articles about how cell phones and constant connectivity are harmful to our mental health, I found this one interesting: https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-human-beast/202409/why-smartphones-stimulate-anxiety?msockid=260f9d20e0056ef439ee8b09e4056573 Regarding some students’ desire to maintain non-emergency communications (family matters, medication reminders and schedule changes) via cell phone, the Lakeview school board has been assured by administrators that students and parents can still reach each other by phone via the landlines in the offices and classrooms. Any parent who needs to speak with their child during the school day is advised to call the building office, which will then find or connect them directly to their student. This is how parent-to-student communications were accomplished for decades prior to the advent of cell phones. I understand some people disagree with this policy change while others enthusiastically support it. Anyone who wishes to share additional perspective with the board is invited to do so during the public comment portion of our public meetings. We meet every month in the Forum at Lakeview High School; our next meeting is at 6 p.m. Aug. 18, 2025. Eric Greene President Lakeview School District Board of Education”
Lakeview School Board (Calhoun)
“Thank you to the many students and others who have voiced your opinions. Please see the rationale provided by our board president Mr. Greene, who wrote on behalf of the board as a whole. I encourage you to speak during the public comment portion of our next board meeting if you have more to share. It is on August 18 at 6:00 pm in the high school Forum. Thank you, Sara”
Lakeview School Board (Calhoun)

Supporter Voices

Petition Updates