

Close Florida’s Invasive Species Loophole in Animal Cruelty Law
The Issue
Eleven ducklings were killed on a Jacksonville street in April, and prosecutors now say Florida law won’t let the case move forward as a felony. Florida lawmakers must close this loophole so that deliberate, repeated cruelty to any animal can be charged as aggravated animal cruelty, no matter how the species is classified.
Surveillance video from neighbors on Tempest Street shows a car plowing through a mother Muscovy duck and her babies, then circling back to hit them again. The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) said residents begged the driver to stop and she kept going after the birds. According to the Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office, the woman later admitted to a couple that she did it on purpose because the ducks were messing up her yard.
She was arrested on 11 felony counts, one for each duckling. In November, those felonies were replaced with 11 misdemeanors. “The ducks are classified as an invasive species, which prevented the State from moving forward with felony charges in this matter,” the State Attorney’s Office for Florida’s Fourth Judicial Circuit said in a statement. Her defense also argued there was no proof the ducklings lived long enough after impact to suffer.
Muscovy ducks are not native to Florida, and federal rules allow them to be removed. But FWC requires humane live-trapping. Running ducklings down with a car is not wildlife control. A species label should never decide whether intentional cruelty counts as a serious crime.
State Attorney Melissa Nelson should pursue the toughest penalties still available, and the Florida Legislature should update the aggravated cruelty law so the next case ends differently.
Sign the petition to tell Florida lawmakers that intentional animal cruelty is a felony, no matter the species.



325
The Issue
Eleven ducklings were killed on a Jacksonville street in April, and prosecutors now say Florida law won’t let the case move forward as a felony. Florida lawmakers must close this loophole so that deliberate, repeated cruelty to any animal can be charged as aggravated animal cruelty, no matter how the species is classified.
Surveillance video from neighbors on Tempest Street shows a car plowing through a mother Muscovy duck and her babies, then circling back to hit them again. The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) said residents begged the driver to stop and she kept going after the birds. According to the Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office, the woman later admitted to a couple that she did it on purpose because the ducks were messing up her yard.
She was arrested on 11 felony counts, one for each duckling. In November, those felonies were replaced with 11 misdemeanors. “The ducks are classified as an invasive species, which prevented the State from moving forward with felony charges in this matter,” the State Attorney’s Office for Florida’s Fourth Judicial Circuit said in a statement. Her defense also argued there was no proof the ducklings lived long enough after impact to suffer.
Muscovy ducks are not native to Florida, and federal rules allow them to be removed. But FWC requires humane live-trapping. Running ducklings down with a car is not wildlife control. A species label should never decide whether intentional cruelty counts as a serious crime.
State Attorney Melissa Nelson should pursue the toughest penalties still available, and the Florida Legislature should update the aggravated cruelty law so the next case ends differently.
Sign the petition to tell Florida lawmakers that intentional animal cruelty is a felony, no matter the species.



The Decision Makers
Supporter Voices
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on November 16, 2026