

Remove the statue, uphold the Law, heal the people
Le problème
In the central square of Cedars "Sinai" hospital, there stands LIFELESS piece of stone, formed into FETISHISTIC IMAGE of some hero, demon, or greek god returning from mount Olympus to inaugurate the pan-hellenic games, or start a cross-town rivalry with the usc trojan. The statue's face does not shine. This tablets in his hand are blank. Has a mistake been made somewhere? Are these tablets intended to represent the 10 WORDS, aka 10 commandments?
Please sign the petition to have this fetish immediately defaced, eventually removed, and a megalithic stele erected in its place. On the stele should be inscribed the Exodus Decalogue, in at least hebrew and english, in large letters visible from a distance of two city blocks.
We would like to invite the board, executives, and rabbis to convene and participate at a special DEFACEMENT CEREMONY on the 17th of TAMMUZ. We would like the Marketing department to advertise the event and invite the public, and Director of Community Engagement Jason Schrieber to MC and give some words, and record the event. They should collaborate on edited recording of the defacement ceremony, with commentary, and publish it under the title "Why is Moses(sic) no longer in the parking lot". This video can be used for fundraising for phase II of the project - purchasing and emplacing the megalithic stele and engraving the memorial Decalogue. No donor plaques, please. They ought to be ashamed of themselves.
When the scoffer is punished, the simpleton is made wise; and when the man of wisdom is instructed, he receives knowledge. - Solomon, proverbs 21:11
Lest anyone fear that between the epicurians and the talmudists we will get sidetracked into lengthy debates of dubious relevance, lost in explanations of prior case law, and stuck in hopeless loopholes, we already have these halakhic responsa, thanks R. Eliayahu Weissman of Portland, OR. R. Weissman also has a good podcast lesson on the coronavirus response according to torah law, by the way. This is what he says to our petition: "Perhaps a reference to Maimonides Laws of Kings 9,2 will be helpful." It is, and thank you Mssrs. Weissman and Maimonides for getting straight to the point. I trust that the rabbis need no further convincing. But would they please translate and interpret this legal ruling for the donors, the executives, the board, and the other people of the land?
I call on any and all volunteers to visit the site and enhance the "artwork" as soon as possible before the feast of Weeks, Shavuot, which occurs as usual on the day of Pentecost, the 6th of Sivan. This year Pentecost falls on May 29th.
Please place a tallit katan on the fetish's torso and a paper bag over its head. We are not permitted to vandalize non-jewish idols outside the land of Israel. Especially on property that is held by non-jews. So please restrain your inclinations, no acts of vandalism, no matter how rational and well-intentioned. Rabbis - I know we shouldn't smash the thing, but are we permitted to enhance the aesthetic value of the piece through graffitt art? Until they get back to us, please only water based chalk markers on the marble. If you're going to use a black sharpie permanent marker, please duct tape large cardboard signs and do it on the pedestal. Write the following in large lettters:
If thou wilt diligently hearken to the voice of the Eternal One, thy G*d, and wilt do that which is right in his eyes, and wilt give ear to his commandments, and keep all his statutes, I will put none of the diseases upon thee, which I have put upon the Egyptians; for I AM THE ETERNAL ONE THAT HEALETH THEE." Exodus.15:26
Thank you for doing that. Now we can all rest this weekend. With heaven's help, we should be in a state of holiness, and merit to receive the Holy Law this Pentecost, and the many blessings, gifts, and powers from on high, thereunto appertaining which are so desperately needed at this time of the covid-19 plague. May it be His will, that the Holy One would grant our scientists and teachers the wisdom to seek out the Torah of truth and the true laws of nature, our researchers the knowledge and understanding to find and develop a vaccine, and our doctors, nurses, and all staff the skills of healing and administrations. "He has taught his words to Jacob, his statutes and his judgements to Israel. He has not done so for any other nation, his judgements they have not known." Psalm 148. Blessed be the G*d of truth.
And now, we may begin to ask, what was the flawed process by which this came about? What other strange worship is being practiced in this place, darkening our intellects and giving the patients and staff over to superstition, magical thinking, priestcraft, and unnatural desire? If you don't need to know, sign the petition, send it to your friends in the frum community, and help me by tracking down email addresses and sending it to every donor, board member, executive, rabbi, chaplain, faculty member, fellow, resident, research scientist, and medical department head at Cedars Sinai.
If your're ready to take a tour through the DARK REGIONS OF THE SOUL, and to do a not-so brief SELF-EXORCISM, read on.
Further research reveals that this is a replica of Michelangelo's 1505 sculpture of Moses, commissioned for the tomb of "pope" Julius II, it was designed to be placed across from an equal and opposite statue of the apostle Paul of Tarsus, who, though a symbol of grace to christians, would most likely also disapprove of this representation, given his stringent stance against the cult of Aphrodite that provoked a riot by the silversmiths of Ephesus. (somewhere in the book of Acts) or his speech on Athens Mars Hill at the altar of the unknown god (somewhere else in the book of Acts).
Back to the present day, our replica was imported from Italy in 1961 when two hospitals merged and moved to the current campus. Here is a video of Jonathan Schrieber director of Cedar Sinai community engagement, shamelessly explaining to us all why is there a statue of Moses in the parking lot? To their credit, they attempted to deface the statue before placing it on its pedestal, but apparently the brilliant cornea of its magnificent marble countenance arrested their effort, though they managed to get the horns off. Here is a video from a frum reporter who is either practicing strange worship at the statue or else making improv comedy of sublime genius. Its hard to be sure. By the way, I don't understand Yiddish, but I can recognize that by "Moshe Rabbeinu" he means, "Moses, our Rabbi". He is asking Moses, or God, or the statue (not sure which) to "have rock monus". What is "rock monus"? He seems to be asking us all to give a "myser for the rebbe". What is a "myser"? Why should the rebbe get it? Someone please explain this in the comment section. He may be a confused soul, but he is clearly comic genius and therefore we should take note.
The doctors of Cedars Sinai hold life and death in the balance every day. It shouldn't be emotionally difficult to see this idol pass away into a pile of rubble in some landfill. Considering how nostalgic people get over their "artwork", though, we concede that it could be donated it to the Getty Museum to be put in storage alongside the other monuments to failed civilizations. After all, the greeks claim that the the legendary sage Musaeus was the first disciple of Orpheus, the lyricist, and therefore the one who taught them arts of civilization. Hence the muses and the graces. Other accounts have him as orpheus's teacher. And many say that wise Musaeus was actually an incarnation of the egyptian demi-god Thut-Mose, the "scribe" of the gods. And there are some who say that thut-mose himself was actually an apotheosis of .... yeah, you guessed it. On that theory, the Museum is a fitting home for this failure of imagination. Its already been named after him. Curious that it has come to represent everything for which our Moses stands against. Neither Jews nor Greek wish to acknowledge Moses as the source of greek civilization. I see a day of reckoning, an epic matchup, a time for radical installations and performance art, Moses vs. the Museum.
Back to the present situation, we could give it away or just smash it, but in no case should the statue purporting to represent Moses be sold. Moses himself wouldn't approve. Its actual value is less than worthless, and to take advantage of an ignoramus by selling it to him, would violate the commandment, "thou shalt not defraud thy neighbor or rob him." Leviticus.19.13 This direct quote and translation from the sayings of the REAL MOSES, much better way to honor him, than any monument. Do you wish to honor the memory of great heros of the past? Recite their sayings, like i just did. Do I not represent Moses more faithfully than Michelangelo? And this particular saying calls our attention to the embarrassing fact that, yet again, we have been defrauded by the Italians. Why does this keep happening? Does the DSM still list masochism as a diagnostic category?
Unfortunately, I don't think we can send it back to Italy and get our money back. Their market is saturated; they don't need any more of these things over there. We will probably have to forgive them and just account it a sunk cost.
On second thought, its not fair to accuse the Italian of fraud, because he earnest believes in the statues semi-mystical power and special graces that attach thereto. This is a grave error. After all, its his religion to worship images of "the son of man" while studiously ignoring what that particular man said. I doubt that he OR his holy mother would approve. But thats their folly, and they'll have to work it out with the apostle st. Shimon Peter at the gates of the holy city, if they ever get there. Its our own fault for taking in this sales pitch. We weren't deceived by them, we deceived ourselves. We joined in a conspiracy to defraud our creator and redeemer, and then put a memorial plaque on the effort. Is there no shame? We can't blame this one on anyone else, attractive as the temptation may be. Why does this keep happening? Who makes these acquisitions? Can we start making bids for the arch of Titus instead??
The Getty museum is most likely understaffed on account of covid-19. I doubt that they'll want it anyway; it undermines their whole business model. At this point, there is probably nothing we can do except repent, deplore our own ignorance, and just deface the thing.
I hope the endowment is strong enough to absorb the loss.
On the positive side, this will open up some valuable real estate on which the work of a local artist could be featured. For this, donor sponsorships could be auctioned and to this memorial plaques could be attached. If its impressive and sells plaques, doesn't matter what goes there. What are we worshipping here, Moses, Michelangelo, our endowment, or the romantic notion of "Art" in and of itself? I'm not sure whats worse. Of course it matters what we choose to represent us. The eternal one, the G*d of Israel has already chosen a sign to represent his people. And it is a day. Can a local artist please get to work conceptualizing a monument that represents an event in time, the seventh day?
Donors and fundraisers are partially responsible for creating this whole mess. Therefore NO MEMORIAL PLAQUES, and no more debasing your parents memory while pretending to honor them. By the way, donors, until things change around here, boycott this hospital! If you wish to invest in health and wellness while honoring the eternal covenant, consider the SIGN OF THE COVENANT and donate to a local ministry that provides SABBATH HOSPITALITY while teaching the THE LAW AND THE PROPHETS, providing meals and community for jewish young adults and poor people with no families, and organizes them to visit the eldery, the sick and the shut in. such as picoshul.org. Its called BIKUR HOLIM. Behold your monument!
Here's another piece of conceptual artwork for our patrons: An EMPTY CHAIR. We're all waiting for the messiah to come and sit on the throne of his father David in Jerusalem and judge the nations in equity and the peoples in justice, but until that happens we need the rule of law. I want to know, where are those who sit in Moses seat? The best way to find out is to make an empty chair and wait for someone to sit in it. Lo and behold, my internet research reveals a surprising coup:
Here is chief rabbi Jason Wiener holding a stone tablet of the law that was a prop from Cecil DeMille's 1956 film "The Ten Commandments", along with visiting scholar R. Meir Soloveichik.
To R. Jason Weiner - will you please read the first two commandments for us from the paleo-hebrew script incribed on the tablet your're holding? It would be nice to hear a bilingual reading and explanation of these at a special event. Can we MARKETING AND PR on the project, please? Please record and publish it. And afterward, make and publish a sequel to Schrieber's video telling him and all of us "Why is [a statue purporting to be] Moses in the parking lot? Part II" hint: answer: It shouldn't be!
It must be a difficult job to represent faith in a culture where the gods are, most likely, science, technology, research grants, the degrees, schools, professional distinctions, and they the authority and respect represented by these. They probably don't think very much about where it all comes from, or give thanks. To many of them in the faculty and administration, you are a mere mascot. A good luck charm. A comfort to the patients. But this could change in an instant if you began to take yourself and your teaching seriously. YOU ARE THE ONE WHO SHOULD BE SITTING IN MOSES'S SEAT, not a lifeless piece of stone! I'm sure you know this. Find the courage to make it happen.
Take the image away, leave the stone chair where it is, and go sit in the chair and teach the commandments. For the sake of your own health and safety, as for ours, I recommend that you resign all leadership of communal rituals and all giving of rabbinic opinions, until this obligation is met. First, take the camel out of the pot of soup. Then, strain out the gnats. To do it the other way around leads to obsessive compulsion, and over-absorption in minutiae. Why go down that road when the the teaching you hold has the power to change the world? To enlighten the intellect and elevate the soul of every medical professional and patient, of every ethnicity or faith background should be a primary goal of your ministry. Teach the universal wisdom of Solomon and the teaching given to Adam the first and Eve; the covenant with the sons of Noah and the universal message of the prophets to the nations.
The idol is muscular and good-looking despite its severe and almost demonic aspect. I admit its almost flattering to see it as our hero, but it undermines your witness and your teaching. It has eyes that don't see, and ears that don't hear. And the one who formed the eye, shall he not see? The one who planted the hear, shall he not hear? This is colossal missed opportunity and DESECRATION of the SIX DAYS OF CREATIVE WORK. It calls into question the whole process by which we got to this point. PHARISEES, since many of you are very concerned over desecrations of the Sabbath, where do the rest of you stand on this? Which is worse?
R. Meir Soleveichik since you're standing by R. Wiener, can we get a scholarly legal opinion? How about a word of encouragement and counsel for your colleague?
Since Cedar Sinai operates 24/7, alot of people will be doing work of some kind on the seventh day. Some of them may even be orthodox Jews who are doing good deeds. But many of them restrain themselves because they've been warned against desecrating the Sabbath. The unanimously accepted opinion is that healing is always permissible on Sabbath in order to save a life, even if it require medicine or surgery. They call this "pikuach nefesh". It is a useful phrase to know if you find yourself in a tight spot on Sabado with posse of talmudic scholars. But the explanations and the complexity of case law surrounding this seem to often miss the underlying issue and the real opportunity. What if the condition is chronic and debilitating, even if not immediately life threatening? What if the sabbath is the only day when the visitor can visit his sick friend or relative? If the visitor has the power to heal, should he do it? What if the patient meets the doctor at synagogue, having arrived in a wheelchair or walker? Suppose the doctor is an orthopedist, or yogi, or qi gong practioner, and has the healing art to straighten the bent through verbal instruction and joint manipulation? SHOULD HE PRACTICE HEALING ON THE SABBATH, at synagogue? I think we should consult R. Yonah Bookstein and his friends at Pico shul. He has never explicitly taught me this, but rather demonstrated it by example.
The Sabbath teaches us to go beyond medicine and surgery, and learn arts of healing that do not depend on the herbs or the knife. Let those be done six days a week, and let the healing arts through the word and the touch be done seven days. What better place than the place where the tree of life grows? What better day, than the day on which the Creator, blessed be he, rested and was refreshed? CAN I GET A WITNESS?]
UPDATE 5/24 19:00PDT This just in from R. Eliayahu Weissman of Portland, OR
Perhaps a reference to Maimonides Laws of Kings 9, 2 might be helpful.
https://documentcloud.adobe.com/link/track?uri=urn:aaid:scds:US:ef3aab38-c38e-4e28-9fc7-5c234ec28ecc
That is the complete text of the email I just received. I think it pertains to the question of the idols, and I assume that the scholars and will find this utterance meaningful. Could one of them please translate and decode this for the people of the land? c.f. the comment section.
By the way many of the healings attributed to the Nazarene took place in synagogues on Sabbath. Why, do you suppose? Was he doing this merely to antagonize the pharisees, and prove a point, which christians subsequently have made a centerpiece of their anti-nominian religion? No, that was merely coincidental. Was it not to draw the sick people near to the manifestation of the holy spirit, which is inherent in the true law? To draw them near to the source of life itself (Don't expect the christians to understand this) What to do they say every sabbath after rolling up and lifting scroll of the law, the revealed WISDOM of the Eternal: she is A TREE OF LIFE for those who grasp her, and those who UPHOLD HER are happy. proverbs 3:19 Without a grasp of the laws of nature, afforded by inquiry of the rational intellect into the causes and purposes of natural phenomena, the medical art would be mired in superstition, magic, ancestor worship. We should be grateful that the holy law forbids these.
This is where christian faith-healers lead their gullible followers, having mistaken the spirit of holiness for a subsidiary separate personality who is almost independent of the Holy One. They attempt to manipulate the powers in various ways through song, dance, ritual, declaration and affirmation of things they hope to obtain in the future, and commanding spiritual powers. As if man could command his creator, while refusing to accept those matters in which the Creator has commanded him. When this fails - as it inevitably does - they often resort to brazen imposture and outright denial of reality. They incorrectly attribute this mockery to the "holy spirit", while simultaneously descrating every truly "holy" matter expressly given as such in the torah, the giving of which was, even by their own witnesses, a manifestation of G*d's holy spirit. They call this phoniness "charisma" and "gifting", while simultaneously rejecting every genuine gift given by the Holy One to those who hear and obey. And they are now receiving, during this coronavirus plague what they so richly deserve, as are we. One positive outcome of social distancing is that there is less imposture and religious fraud going on. We should be thankful that this plague holds the potential to redeem the minds of the faithful, and the reputation of faith among the community of scientific healers, from the mire into which we have made it sink.
CHRISTIANS - turn and repent. Be ashamed of your magical thinking, follow my example and give it up. Next, give up the despair and dogmatic pessimism about human nature. The lifestyle is doctrinally unsound and existentially invalid. Learn what the mark is, and practice until you can consistently hit it. If a military sniper or baseball pitcher can do this, why can't you? Your pessimism is unjustified. And the giving of the law is an act of grace.
At this point the leader who is called into question, who fears being unmasked as an imposter will distract with a red herring followed by a straw man fallacy. Scapegoating jews is reflex reaction. They do it almost sub-consciously, and usually there is no malice aforethought. The evangelist typically does not have a real flesh and blood Jew, or jewish community as its target. Many of them beleive in all sincerity that Jews ceased to exist after the destruction of the temple, or should have. If Jews didn't totally disappear, they at least the ceased to exist as a covenant people. They aren't anti-semitic in the racist sense so much as anti-jewish in the covenantal sense. Jews are a sort of fictional character who can be trotted out for a straw man in disputes with heretics or non-conformists like myself over themes of sin and predestination, law and grace, works and faith. By the way, notice how these terms line up with the negative on the left. The bogey-man "jew" serves as an example of what christian should deprecate or completely reject: the flesh, the world, the law, the works therof, a human messiah, the earthly Jerusalem. So that in order to refute my argument, the evangelist ad hominem types me or my argument as "judaic", possibly approaching "legalism" and then its case closed. Most of his congregation will accept this, without noticing the fallacies. They will probably not fear the grave converse error of "lawless" that Jesus and the apostles repeatedly warn against. Think this was just the middle ages, my Jewish friends? Think again. This goes on in revival gatherings, charismatic houses of prayer, and evangelical churches today all over America. It is properly basic to Lutheran and Calvinist theologies, and the wellspring from which their other distinctive doctrines emerge. To my Christian friends, if I can still call you that, this has become so ubiquitous and fundamental your self-concept, do you even notice it any more? How can this spirit be called "holy", when it is bent on desecrating everything that Jesus himself sanctified?
Ad hominem jew - "what advantage has the Jew? much in every way." (Romans 2-4)
Straw man legalism - the law has been claimed as a guide for life, not as a guarantee of salvation.
Red herring - you didn't answer the question Mr. pseudo-Evangelist. And my point stands. As baseball pitcher practices to hit the mark, so should we. The law is a guide for life, given for the intellectual, moral, and spiritual improvement of humanity, anyone who fails to learn from it has noone but himself to blame. (Maimonides). And shame on you, pseudo-Evangelist, for scoffing at the jews, in order to avoid this conclusion. The very giving of the law is an work of grace, yea, even of mercy. In idolatry, man's foolish mind becomes darkened, they worship the created things rather than the creator, and are given over to unnatural desires. (Romans 1) The law is the antidote to this (Rom 2) and this is why THE JEW HAS MUCH ADVANTAGE. For this reason, mssrs. R.Wiener and R.Soleviechik, et al, we gentiles desperately need you to teach us the law.
If you ever find yourself in a tight spot with a gang of cult goonies, this advance preparation may be helpful. They are not immediately susceptible to logic and evidence, but nowadays thank G*d, you should be able survive through the disputation, alive, and with your basic premises of judaism intact, especially if you know Paul's arguments better than they do.
The scapegoating and jew-hatred has its bipolar aspect in which they believe themselves to be the "spiritual" and therefore the "true" israel. This grave mistake has its root in a fundamental (and I think intentionally prejudiced) misreading of Paul and Peter's epistles. Without ever having been to jewish home for a sabbath kiddush, or to a synagogue to hear the reading of the law, and whats more rejecting it a priori, and refusing to follow Paul's own example, they nevertheless manage to believe that they are heirs to all the promises and prophecies concerning Israel. This delusion is what feeds their mistaken claims and self-affirmations. Unsound assurances about future lead to false hopes. Slandering the law and failing to learn from it, they fear justice rather than loving it as we should (c.f. psalm 96, 98). Misusing grace to escape from justice, they end up enslaving themselves to superstitution. Rather than acknowledging the sovereign G*d as rewarder of righteousness, and punisher of evil, they attribute suffering and punishment to the devil, deny G*d sovereignty, misunderstand the natural cosmos, and fail to learn from their own suffering. The devil or his minions are mistaken for independent subsidiary powers. Christians spend alot of time and energy in spiritual warfare against the devil and his demons, or so they think. In most cases they are actually warring against God himself. Failure, pessimism, and and anti-judaism are inevitable. And in order to get to INTELLECTUAL AND MORAL HEALING, it is necessary to briefly expose these misconceptions.
Christians: TURN AND REPENT of your lawlessness, and the compulsive scapegoating and jew-hatred that you use to justify it. The Sabbath day is a universal sign. The covenant at Sinai is an eternal covenant. The gifts and the calling of G*d are irrevocable. (Rom 11) Paul himself was a pharisee, the son of pharisees, and he taught the Noachide law (Rom 1, 13) THE PHARISEES SIT IN MOSES SEAT, THEREFORE LISTEN TO WHAT THEY SAY AND DO IT. (Sermon on the Mount). I highly recommend that you take the advice of the apostle John the revelator and "come out of her [the harlot who rides the beast] my people, lest you be defiled by her sins".
I trust that this brief exposition is sufficient for the limited purpose of breaking the spell in which these false and demonic doctrines hold so many people. They conclusions drawn can be demonstrated exegetically in a thorough manner when when time permits. While we're still on the broader subject of magic and superstition, lets go to the psychiatry department and find out what's going on with our attachment to Italian Moses. By the way, a Dybukk in Jewish thought is merely a disembodied attachment. It is not an independent spiritual being or agency, in the way that the demons and the djinn are conceived of by christians and muslims. This is a much more rational way of conceiving of our psychic space. "A man should leave his father and mother and cleave to his wife." v yi Davak b'ishto. A dybukk is "that which cleaves". The shadow of personality left by a lost parent or lover or friend, in the soul of the one who remains. In Torah law, it is forbidden or to tattoo or mark oneself for the dead, or to attempt to communicate with them - a process that often results in these "dybukks". On the contrary, Moses calls the sons of Israel, "sons of God". God himself adopts the orphan.
PSYCHIATRISTS - have come to consensus yet about masochism as a diagnosis? Lets reason together using the analytic tools of your worldview. Nowadays people exhibit their sexuality and repress their conscience and our shame. Is that how our donors, board, and executive management brought us to this error? Exhibitionism isn't seen as a problem, even though it is the symptom the presents in this male fetishism. Oppositional-defiant disorder may be an underlying cause. However this is latent and subconscious, though immanently present in most of his conscious waking activities. What is conscious and well known to the patient (and his parents), is that he (and they) engage in ritual acts of self-humiliation once a year (on years when things go bad). This superficial act of propitiation through suffering eases the patients perception of his own guilt, without actual removing, ( through the act of so-called "repentance") the underlying - dare I say it? - "sin" that is causing the guilt. It is a constellation of self-indulgence, guilt, ritual self-shaming, and more indulgence, leading to consequences that become worse as time progresses. I label this syndrome "Masochism". Esteemed colleagues, is this a prescribable condition, or do we need to hire an analyst? I know the parents are going to demand a biochemical explanation so that their role in patient's upbringing isn't into called into question, but I seriously doubt that psychopharmacology is going to be sufficient here. We could of course say, "turn and repent", but thats counter to our business model and anyway the patient probably won't comply. (And quite frankly, that idea doesn't appeal to us personally so we won't recommend it) This is a serious case: call the surgeons and neuroscientists. We need PhDs and MDs and Osteopaths with serious scientific training and experience. Are there any other medical professionals who can help us here? WHERE IS THE SCHOLAR? WHERE IS THE DOCTOR? WHERE IS THE PHILOSOPHER OF THIS AGE?
The other nations symbolize what they honor by making monuments of wood and stone. But the holy one of Israel has given as the sign of his covenant something that is not a thing at all - it is a day. How can we represent an event in time, with the three dimensions of space?
In the years to come, I see a massive stele of granite where the statue now is. A giant cube. There is no figure or likeness on it, except the letters of the alphabet. the aleph beit. the alpha beta. the alfabeto.
It has the 10 COMMANDMENTS incribed on all four sides, in four languages, including hebrew and english. And it should be VISIBLE FROM A DISTANCE OF TWO CITY BLOCKS. That way it will be harder for everyone sitting in board rooms and executive suites and corner offices in the neighboring buildings to ignore it and maintain the conspiracy of ignorance. It could also include some other selected verses that are beneficial to the patients and a propos the SINAI COVENANT:
"If thou wilt diligently hearken to the voice of the Eternal One, thy G*d, and wilt do that which is right in his eyes, and wilt give ear to his commandments, and keep all his statutes, I will put none of the diseases upon thee, which I have put upon the Egyptians; for I AM THE ETERNAL ONE THAT HEALETH THEE."
This petition was begun on 28th Iyar, May 22. The feast of weeks, "Shavuot", falls on 6th of Sivan, which will be May 29th. It is seven weeks counting from the day after Passover, which was on the 15th day, the full moon of Nisan, the month of spring. Hence the common name "Pentecost", fifty days. On this holy day, the sons of Israel remember the giving of the law and the covenant at mount Sinai. It is on Pentecost that they will receive both the law and the many gifts and blessings that come with it, such as the wisdom, understanding, and knowledge necessary for the good life. The intellectual virtue of science consists in the demonstrative knowledge of matters that are universal and unchanging. They need all of this virtue that they can possibly obtain, for their researchers to find the anti-dote or vaccine for this covid-19 plague, and for their doctors and nurses and healing staff to do the work of healing. We will be blessed insofar as they are blessed, and we should expect to receive blessing apart from them. We cannot afford to let a piece of lifeless stone anger their G*d. This will darken the minds of us all, and lead us into ignorance. Is it not evident that we have been given over to ignorance already? That our culture is debased in its conversation and that ignorant now men rule over us? This is very dangerous, possibly even more so than the covid-19 plague. Therefore it is critical that the statue be removed or at least defaced before then.
Is this magical thinking? I think not. On the contrary, it is your attempt to invoke the power of the name "Sinai" and the revence due to the person of Moses, apart from the law and covenant for which they stand, which constitutes magical thinking. It is also incoherent and self-refuting. On a skeptical, purely naturalistic account of human life, and history, the prophetic stance taken in this letter is, perhaps, not an inevitable conclusion from the evidence. At least, not from the evidence immediately available to the skeptic who does not know the history or the text. But the skeptic should admit, at least, that it is not against the evidence either. Moreover, it is coherent. And if you demand evidence, perhaps evidence will be given to you. But it will cost you. Rember how you tested the LORD your G*d in the wilderness.
Board members, executives, governors, donors, and other complicit parties - what is it going to be? Accepting responsibility, will you undertake this work upon yourselves? If you won't deface the statue, at least put a paper bag over its head. Or a tallit. Wouldn't that be easier than shutting down an entire city? Wrath is coming on us through this plague. Must we take we heroic measures to prevent it?

Pétition fermée
Le problème
In the central square of Cedars "Sinai" hospital, there stands LIFELESS piece of stone, formed into FETISHISTIC IMAGE of some hero, demon, or greek god returning from mount Olympus to inaugurate the pan-hellenic games, or start a cross-town rivalry with the usc trojan. The statue's face does not shine. This tablets in his hand are blank. Has a mistake been made somewhere? Are these tablets intended to represent the 10 WORDS, aka 10 commandments?
Please sign the petition to have this fetish immediately defaced, eventually removed, and a megalithic stele erected in its place. On the stele should be inscribed the Exodus Decalogue, in at least hebrew and english, in large letters visible from a distance of two city blocks.
We would like to invite the board, executives, and rabbis to convene and participate at a special DEFACEMENT CEREMONY on the 17th of TAMMUZ. We would like the Marketing department to advertise the event and invite the public, and Director of Community Engagement Jason Schrieber to MC and give some words, and record the event. They should collaborate on edited recording of the defacement ceremony, with commentary, and publish it under the title "Why is Moses(sic) no longer in the parking lot". This video can be used for fundraising for phase II of the project - purchasing and emplacing the megalithic stele and engraving the memorial Decalogue. No donor plaques, please. They ought to be ashamed of themselves.
When the scoffer is punished, the simpleton is made wise; and when the man of wisdom is instructed, he receives knowledge. - Solomon, proverbs 21:11
Lest anyone fear that between the epicurians and the talmudists we will get sidetracked into lengthy debates of dubious relevance, lost in explanations of prior case law, and stuck in hopeless loopholes, we already have these halakhic responsa, thanks R. Eliayahu Weissman of Portland, OR. R. Weissman also has a good podcast lesson on the coronavirus response according to torah law, by the way. This is what he says to our petition: "Perhaps a reference to Maimonides Laws of Kings 9,2 will be helpful." It is, and thank you Mssrs. Weissman and Maimonides for getting straight to the point. I trust that the rabbis need no further convincing. But would they please translate and interpret this legal ruling for the donors, the executives, the board, and the other people of the land?
I call on any and all volunteers to visit the site and enhance the "artwork" as soon as possible before the feast of Weeks, Shavuot, which occurs as usual on the day of Pentecost, the 6th of Sivan. This year Pentecost falls on May 29th.
Please place a tallit katan on the fetish's torso and a paper bag over its head. We are not permitted to vandalize non-jewish idols outside the land of Israel. Especially on property that is held by non-jews. So please restrain your inclinations, no acts of vandalism, no matter how rational and well-intentioned. Rabbis - I know we shouldn't smash the thing, but are we permitted to enhance the aesthetic value of the piece through graffitt art? Until they get back to us, please only water based chalk markers on the marble. If you're going to use a black sharpie permanent marker, please duct tape large cardboard signs and do it on the pedestal. Write the following in large lettters:
If thou wilt diligently hearken to the voice of the Eternal One, thy G*d, and wilt do that which is right in his eyes, and wilt give ear to his commandments, and keep all his statutes, I will put none of the diseases upon thee, which I have put upon the Egyptians; for I AM THE ETERNAL ONE THAT HEALETH THEE." Exodus.15:26
Thank you for doing that. Now we can all rest this weekend. With heaven's help, we should be in a state of holiness, and merit to receive the Holy Law this Pentecost, and the many blessings, gifts, and powers from on high, thereunto appertaining which are so desperately needed at this time of the covid-19 plague. May it be His will, that the Holy One would grant our scientists and teachers the wisdom to seek out the Torah of truth and the true laws of nature, our researchers the knowledge and understanding to find and develop a vaccine, and our doctors, nurses, and all staff the skills of healing and administrations. "He has taught his words to Jacob, his statutes and his judgements to Israel. He has not done so for any other nation, his judgements they have not known." Psalm 148. Blessed be the G*d of truth.
And now, we may begin to ask, what was the flawed process by which this came about? What other strange worship is being practiced in this place, darkening our intellects and giving the patients and staff over to superstition, magical thinking, priestcraft, and unnatural desire? If you don't need to know, sign the petition, send it to your friends in the frum community, and help me by tracking down email addresses and sending it to every donor, board member, executive, rabbi, chaplain, faculty member, fellow, resident, research scientist, and medical department head at Cedars Sinai.
If your're ready to take a tour through the DARK REGIONS OF THE SOUL, and to do a not-so brief SELF-EXORCISM, read on.
Further research reveals that this is a replica of Michelangelo's 1505 sculpture of Moses, commissioned for the tomb of "pope" Julius II, it was designed to be placed across from an equal and opposite statue of the apostle Paul of Tarsus, who, though a symbol of grace to christians, would most likely also disapprove of this representation, given his stringent stance against the cult of Aphrodite that provoked a riot by the silversmiths of Ephesus. (somewhere in the book of Acts) or his speech on Athens Mars Hill at the altar of the unknown god (somewhere else in the book of Acts).
Back to the present day, our replica was imported from Italy in 1961 when two hospitals merged and moved to the current campus. Here is a video of Jonathan Schrieber director of Cedar Sinai community engagement, shamelessly explaining to us all why is there a statue of Moses in the parking lot? To their credit, they attempted to deface the statue before placing it on its pedestal, but apparently the brilliant cornea of its magnificent marble countenance arrested their effort, though they managed to get the horns off. Here is a video from a frum reporter who is either practicing strange worship at the statue or else making improv comedy of sublime genius. Its hard to be sure. By the way, I don't understand Yiddish, but I can recognize that by "Moshe Rabbeinu" he means, "Moses, our Rabbi". He is asking Moses, or God, or the statue (not sure which) to "have rock monus". What is "rock monus"? He seems to be asking us all to give a "myser for the rebbe". What is a "myser"? Why should the rebbe get it? Someone please explain this in the comment section. He may be a confused soul, but he is clearly comic genius and therefore we should take note.
The doctors of Cedars Sinai hold life and death in the balance every day. It shouldn't be emotionally difficult to see this idol pass away into a pile of rubble in some landfill. Considering how nostalgic people get over their "artwork", though, we concede that it could be donated it to the Getty Museum to be put in storage alongside the other monuments to failed civilizations. After all, the greeks claim that the the legendary sage Musaeus was the first disciple of Orpheus, the lyricist, and therefore the one who taught them arts of civilization. Hence the muses and the graces. Other accounts have him as orpheus's teacher. And many say that wise Musaeus was actually an incarnation of the egyptian demi-god Thut-Mose, the "scribe" of the gods. And there are some who say that thut-mose himself was actually an apotheosis of .... yeah, you guessed it. On that theory, the Museum is a fitting home for this failure of imagination. Its already been named after him. Curious that it has come to represent everything for which our Moses stands against. Neither Jews nor Greek wish to acknowledge Moses as the source of greek civilization. I see a day of reckoning, an epic matchup, a time for radical installations and performance art, Moses vs. the Museum.
Back to the present situation, we could give it away or just smash it, but in no case should the statue purporting to represent Moses be sold. Moses himself wouldn't approve. Its actual value is less than worthless, and to take advantage of an ignoramus by selling it to him, would violate the commandment, "thou shalt not defraud thy neighbor or rob him." Leviticus.19.13 This direct quote and translation from the sayings of the REAL MOSES, much better way to honor him, than any monument. Do you wish to honor the memory of great heros of the past? Recite their sayings, like i just did. Do I not represent Moses more faithfully than Michelangelo? And this particular saying calls our attention to the embarrassing fact that, yet again, we have been defrauded by the Italians. Why does this keep happening? Does the DSM still list masochism as a diagnostic category?
Unfortunately, I don't think we can send it back to Italy and get our money back. Their market is saturated; they don't need any more of these things over there. We will probably have to forgive them and just account it a sunk cost.
On second thought, its not fair to accuse the Italian of fraud, because he earnest believes in the statues semi-mystical power and special graces that attach thereto. This is a grave error. After all, its his religion to worship images of "the son of man" while studiously ignoring what that particular man said. I doubt that he OR his holy mother would approve. But thats their folly, and they'll have to work it out with the apostle st. Shimon Peter at the gates of the holy city, if they ever get there. Its our own fault for taking in this sales pitch. We weren't deceived by them, we deceived ourselves. We joined in a conspiracy to defraud our creator and redeemer, and then put a memorial plaque on the effort. Is there no shame? We can't blame this one on anyone else, attractive as the temptation may be. Why does this keep happening? Who makes these acquisitions? Can we start making bids for the arch of Titus instead??
The Getty museum is most likely understaffed on account of covid-19. I doubt that they'll want it anyway; it undermines their whole business model. At this point, there is probably nothing we can do except repent, deplore our own ignorance, and just deface the thing.
I hope the endowment is strong enough to absorb the loss.
On the positive side, this will open up some valuable real estate on which the work of a local artist could be featured. For this, donor sponsorships could be auctioned and to this memorial plaques could be attached. If its impressive and sells plaques, doesn't matter what goes there. What are we worshipping here, Moses, Michelangelo, our endowment, or the romantic notion of "Art" in and of itself? I'm not sure whats worse. Of course it matters what we choose to represent us. The eternal one, the G*d of Israel has already chosen a sign to represent his people. And it is a day. Can a local artist please get to work conceptualizing a monument that represents an event in time, the seventh day?
Donors and fundraisers are partially responsible for creating this whole mess. Therefore NO MEMORIAL PLAQUES, and no more debasing your parents memory while pretending to honor them. By the way, donors, until things change around here, boycott this hospital! If you wish to invest in health and wellness while honoring the eternal covenant, consider the SIGN OF THE COVENANT and donate to a local ministry that provides SABBATH HOSPITALITY while teaching the THE LAW AND THE PROPHETS, providing meals and community for jewish young adults and poor people with no families, and organizes them to visit the eldery, the sick and the shut in. such as picoshul.org. Its called BIKUR HOLIM. Behold your monument!
Here's another piece of conceptual artwork for our patrons: An EMPTY CHAIR. We're all waiting for the messiah to come and sit on the throne of his father David in Jerusalem and judge the nations in equity and the peoples in justice, but until that happens we need the rule of law. I want to know, where are those who sit in Moses seat? The best way to find out is to make an empty chair and wait for someone to sit in it. Lo and behold, my internet research reveals a surprising coup:
Here is chief rabbi Jason Wiener holding a stone tablet of the law that was a prop from Cecil DeMille's 1956 film "The Ten Commandments", along with visiting scholar R. Meir Soloveichik.
To R. Jason Weiner - will you please read the first two commandments for us from the paleo-hebrew script incribed on the tablet your're holding? It would be nice to hear a bilingual reading and explanation of these at a special event. Can we MARKETING AND PR on the project, please? Please record and publish it. And afterward, make and publish a sequel to Schrieber's video telling him and all of us "Why is [a statue purporting to be] Moses in the parking lot? Part II" hint: answer: It shouldn't be!
It must be a difficult job to represent faith in a culture where the gods are, most likely, science, technology, research grants, the degrees, schools, professional distinctions, and they the authority and respect represented by these. They probably don't think very much about where it all comes from, or give thanks. To many of them in the faculty and administration, you are a mere mascot. A good luck charm. A comfort to the patients. But this could change in an instant if you began to take yourself and your teaching seriously. YOU ARE THE ONE WHO SHOULD BE SITTING IN MOSES'S SEAT, not a lifeless piece of stone! I'm sure you know this. Find the courage to make it happen.
Take the image away, leave the stone chair where it is, and go sit in the chair and teach the commandments. For the sake of your own health and safety, as for ours, I recommend that you resign all leadership of communal rituals and all giving of rabbinic opinions, until this obligation is met. First, take the camel out of the pot of soup. Then, strain out the gnats. To do it the other way around leads to obsessive compulsion, and over-absorption in minutiae. Why go down that road when the the teaching you hold has the power to change the world? To enlighten the intellect and elevate the soul of every medical professional and patient, of every ethnicity or faith background should be a primary goal of your ministry. Teach the universal wisdom of Solomon and the teaching given to Adam the first and Eve; the covenant with the sons of Noah and the universal message of the prophets to the nations.
The idol is muscular and good-looking despite its severe and almost demonic aspect. I admit its almost flattering to see it as our hero, but it undermines your witness and your teaching. It has eyes that don't see, and ears that don't hear. And the one who formed the eye, shall he not see? The one who planted the hear, shall he not hear? This is colossal missed opportunity and DESECRATION of the SIX DAYS OF CREATIVE WORK. It calls into question the whole process by which we got to this point. PHARISEES, since many of you are very concerned over desecrations of the Sabbath, where do the rest of you stand on this? Which is worse?
R. Meir Soleveichik since you're standing by R. Wiener, can we get a scholarly legal opinion? How about a word of encouragement and counsel for your colleague?
Since Cedar Sinai operates 24/7, alot of people will be doing work of some kind on the seventh day. Some of them may even be orthodox Jews who are doing good deeds. But many of them restrain themselves because they've been warned against desecrating the Sabbath. The unanimously accepted opinion is that healing is always permissible on Sabbath in order to save a life, even if it require medicine or surgery. They call this "pikuach nefesh". It is a useful phrase to know if you find yourself in a tight spot on Sabado with posse of talmudic scholars. But the explanations and the complexity of case law surrounding this seem to often miss the underlying issue and the real opportunity. What if the condition is chronic and debilitating, even if not immediately life threatening? What if the sabbath is the only day when the visitor can visit his sick friend or relative? If the visitor has the power to heal, should he do it? What if the patient meets the doctor at synagogue, having arrived in a wheelchair or walker? Suppose the doctor is an orthopedist, or yogi, or qi gong practioner, and has the healing art to straighten the bent through verbal instruction and joint manipulation? SHOULD HE PRACTICE HEALING ON THE SABBATH, at synagogue? I think we should consult R. Yonah Bookstein and his friends at Pico shul. He has never explicitly taught me this, but rather demonstrated it by example.
The Sabbath teaches us to go beyond medicine and surgery, and learn arts of healing that do not depend on the herbs or the knife. Let those be done six days a week, and let the healing arts through the word and the touch be done seven days. What better place than the place where the tree of life grows? What better day, than the day on which the Creator, blessed be he, rested and was refreshed? CAN I GET A WITNESS?]
UPDATE 5/24 19:00PDT This just in from R. Eliayahu Weissman of Portland, OR
Perhaps a reference to Maimonides Laws of Kings 9, 2 might be helpful.
https://documentcloud.adobe.com/link/track?uri=urn:aaid:scds:US:ef3aab38-c38e-4e28-9fc7-5c234ec28ecc
That is the complete text of the email I just received. I think it pertains to the question of the idols, and I assume that the scholars and will find this utterance meaningful. Could one of them please translate and decode this for the people of the land? c.f. the comment section.
By the way many of the healings attributed to the Nazarene took place in synagogues on Sabbath. Why, do you suppose? Was he doing this merely to antagonize the pharisees, and prove a point, which christians subsequently have made a centerpiece of their anti-nominian religion? No, that was merely coincidental. Was it not to draw the sick people near to the manifestation of the holy spirit, which is inherent in the true law? To draw them near to the source of life itself (Don't expect the christians to understand this) What to do they say every sabbath after rolling up and lifting scroll of the law, the revealed WISDOM of the Eternal: she is A TREE OF LIFE for those who grasp her, and those who UPHOLD HER are happy. proverbs 3:19 Without a grasp of the laws of nature, afforded by inquiry of the rational intellect into the causes and purposes of natural phenomena, the medical art would be mired in superstition, magic, ancestor worship. We should be grateful that the holy law forbids these.
This is where christian faith-healers lead their gullible followers, having mistaken the spirit of holiness for a subsidiary separate personality who is almost independent of the Holy One. They attempt to manipulate the powers in various ways through song, dance, ritual, declaration and affirmation of things they hope to obtain in the future, and commanding spiritual powers. As if man could command his creator, while refusing to accept those matters in which the Creator has commanded him. When this fails - as it inevitably does - they often resort to brazen imposture and outright denial of reality. They incorrectly attribute this mockery to the "holy spirit", while simultaneously descrating every truly "holy" matter expressly given as such in the torah, the giving of which was, even by their own witnesses, a manifestation of G*d's holy spirit. They call this phoniness "charisma" and "gifting", while simultaneously rejecting every genuine gift given by the Holy One to those who hear and obey. And they are now receiving, during this coronavirus plague what they so richly deserve, as are we. One positive outcome of social distancing is that there is less imposture and religious fraud going on. We should be thankful that this plague holds the potential to redeem the minds of the faithful, and the reputation of faith among the community of scientific healers, from the mire into which we have made it sink.
CHRISTIANS - turn and repent. Be ashamed of your magical thinking, follow my example and give it up. Next, give up the despair and dogmatic pessimism about human nature. The lifestyle is doctrinally unsound and existentially invalid. Learn what the mark is, and practice until you can consistently hit it. If a military sniper or baseball pitcher can do this, why can't you? Your pessimism is unjustified. And the giving of the law is an act of grace.
At this point the leader who is called into question, who fears being unmasked as an imposter will distract with a red herring followed by a straw man fallacy. Scapegoating jews is reflex reaction. They do it almost sub-consciously, and usually there is no malice aforethought. The evangelist typically does not have a real flesh and blood Jew, or jewish community as its target. Many of them beleive in all sincerity that Jews ceased to exist after the destruction of the temple, or should have. If Jews didn't totally disappear, they at least the ceased to exist as a covenant people. They aren't anti-semitic in the racist sense so much as anti-jewish in the covenantal sense. Jews are a sort of fictional character who can be trotted out for a straw man in disputes with heretics or non-conformists like myself over themes of sin and predestination, law and grace, works and faith. By the way, notice how these terms line up with the negative on the left. The bogey-man "jew" serves as an example of what christian should deprecate or completely reject: the flesh, the world, the law, the works therof, a human messiah, the earthly Jerusalem. So that in order to refute my argument, the evangelist ad hominem types me or my argument as "judaic", possibly approaching "legalism" and then its case closed. Most of his congregation will accept this, without noticing the fallacies. They will probably not fear the grave converse error of "lawless" that Jesus and the apostles repeatedly warn against. Think this was just the middle ages, my Jewish friends? Think again. This goes on in revival gatherings, charismatic houses of prayer, and evangelical churches today all over America. It is properly basic to Lutheran and Calvinist theologies, and the wellspring from which their other distinctive doctrines emerge. To my Christian friends, if I can still call you that, this has become so ubiquitous and fundamental your self-concept, do you even notice it any more? How can this spirit be called "holy", when it is bent on desecrating everything that Jesus himself sanctified?
Ad hominem jew - "what advantage has the Jew? much in every way." (Romans 2-4)
Straw man legalism - the law has been claimed as a guide for life, not as a guarantee of salvation.
Red herring - you didn't answer the question Mr. pseudo-Evangelist. And my point stands. As baseball pitcher practices to hit the mark, so should we. The law is a guide for life, given for the intellectual, moral, and spiritual improvement of humanity, anyone who fails to learn from it has noone but himself to blame. (Maimonides). And shame on you, pseudo-Evangelist, for scoffing at the jews, in order to avoid this conclusion. The very giving of the law is an work of grace, yea, even of mercy. In idolatry, man's foolish mind becomes darkened, they worship the created things rather than the creator, and are given over to unnatural desires. (Romans 1) The law is the antidote to this (Rom 2) and this is why THE JEW HAS MUCH ADVANTAGE. For this reason, mssrs. R.Wiener and R.Soleviechik, et al, we gentiles desperately need you to teach us the law.
If you ever find yourself in a tight spot with a gang of cult goonies, this advance preparation may be helpful. They are not immediately susceptible to logic and evidence, but nowadays thank G*d, you should be able survive through the disputation, alive, and with your basic premises of judaism intact, especially if you know Paul's arguments better than they do.
The scapegoating and jew-hatred has its bipolar aspect in which they believe themselves to be the "spiritual" and therefore the "true" israel. This grave mistake has its root in a fundamental (and I think intentionally prejudiced) misreading of Paul and Peter's epistles. Without ever having been to jewish home for a sabbath kiddush, or to a synagogue to hear the reading of the law, and whats more rejecting it a priori, and refusing to follow Paul's own example, they nevertheless manage to believe that they are heirs to all the promises and prophecies concerning Israel. This delusion is what feeds their mistaken claims and self-affirmations. Unsound assurances about future lead to false hopes. Slandering the law and failing to learn from it, they fear justice rather than loving it as we should (c.f. psalm 96, 98). Misusing grace to escape from justice, they end up enslaving themselves to superstitution. Rather than acknowledging the sovereign G*d as rewarder of righteousness, and punisher of evil, they attribute suffering and punishment to the devil, deny G*d sovereignty, misunderstand the natural cosmos, and fail to learn from their own suffering. The devil or his minions are mistaken for independent subsidiary powers. Christians spend alot of time and energy in spiritual warfare against the devil and his demons, or so they think. In most cases they are actually warring against God himself. Failure, pessimism, and and anti-judaism are inevitable. And in order to get to INTELLECTUAL AND MORAL HEALING, it is necessary to briefly expose these misconceptions.
Christians: TURN AND REPENT of your lawlessness, and the compulsive scapegoating and jew-hatred that you use to justify it. The Sabbath day is a universal sign. The covenant at Sinai is an eternal covenant. The gifts and the calling of G*d are irrevocable. (Rom 11) Paul himself was a pharisee, the son of pharisees, and he taught the Noachide law (Rom 1, 13) THE PHARISEES SIT IN MOSES SEAT, THEREFORE LISTEN TO WHAT THEY SAY AND DO IT. (Sermon on the Mount). I highly recommend that you take the advice of the apostle John the revelator and "come out of her [the harlot who rides the beast] my people, lest you be defiled by her sins".
I trust that this brief exposition is sufficient for the limited purpose of breaking the spell in which these false and demonic doctrines hold so many people. They conclusions drawn can be demonstrated exegetically in a thorough manner when when time permits. While we're still on the broader subject of magic and superstition, lets go to the psychiatry department and find out what's going on with our attachment to Italian Moses. By the way, a Dybukk in Jewish thought is merely a disembodied attachment. It is not an independent spiritual being or agency, in the way that the demons and the djinn are conceived of by christians and muslims. This is a much more rational way of conceiving of our psychic space. "A man should leave his father and mother and cleave to his wife." v yi Davak b'ishto. A dybukk is "that which cleaves". The shadow of personality left by a lost parent or lover or friend, in the soul of the one who remains. In Torah law, it is forbidden or to tattoo or mark oneself for the dead, or to attempt to communicate with them - a process that often results in these "dybukks". On the contrary, Moses calls the sons of Israel, "sons of God". God himself adopts the orphan.
PSYCHIATRISTS - have come to consensus yet about masochism as a diagnosis? Lets reason together using the analytic tools of your worldview. Nowadays people exhibit their sexuality and repress their conscience and our shame. Is that how our donors, board, and executive management brought us to this error? Exhibitionism isn't seen as a problem, even though it is the symptom the presents in this male fetishism. Oppositional-defiant disorder may be an underlying cause. However this is latent and subconscious, though immanently present in most of his conscious waking activities. What is conscious and well known to the patient (and his parents), is that he (and they) engage in ritual acts of self-humiliation once a year (on years when things go bad). This superficial act of propitiation through suffering eases the patients perception of his own guilt, without actual removing, ( through the act of so-called "repentance") the underlying - dare I say it? - "sin" that is causing the guilt. It is a constellation of self-indulgence, guilt, ritual self-shaming, and more indulgence, leading to consequences that become worse as time progresses. I label this syndrome "Masochism". Esteemed colleagues, is this a prescribable condition, or do we need to hire an analyst? I know the parents are going to demand a biochemical explanation so that their role in patient's upbringing isn't into called into question, but I seriously doubt that psychopharmacology is going to be sufficient here. We could of course say, "turn and repent", but thats counter to our business model and anyway the patient probably won't comply. (And quite frankly, that idea doesn't appeal to us personally so we won't recommend it) This is a serious case: call the surgeons and neuroscientists. We need PhDs and MDs and Osteopaths with serious scientific training and experience. Are there any other medical professionals who can help us here? WHERE IS THE SCHOLAR? WHERE IS THE DOCTOR? WHERE IS THE PHILOSOPHER OF THIS AGE?
The other nations symbolize what they honor by making monuments of wood and stone. But the holy one of Israel has given as the sign of his covenant something that is not a thing at all - it is a day. How can we represent an event in time, with the three dimensions of space?
In the years to come, I see a massive stele of granite where the statue now is. A giant cube. There is no figure or likeness on it, except the letters of the alphabet. the aleph beit. the alpha beta. the alfabeto.
It has the 10 COMMANDMENTS incribed on all four sides, in four languages, including hebrew and english. And it should be VISIBLE FROM A DISTANCE OF TWO CITY BLOCKS. That way it will be harder for everyone sitting in board rooms and executive suites and corner offices in the neighboring buildings to ignore it and maintain the conspiracy of ignorance. It could also include some other selected verses that are beneficial to the patients and a propos the SINAI COVENANT:
"If thou wilt diligently hearken to the voice of the Eternal One, thy G*d, and wilt do that which is right in his eyes, and wilt give ear to his commandments, and keep all his statutes, I will put none of the diseases upon thee, which I have put upon the Egyptians; for I AM THE ETERNAL ONE THAT HEALETH THEE."
This petition was begun on 28th Iyar, May 22. The feast of weeks, "Shavuot", falls on 6th of Sivan, which will be May 29th. It is seven weeks counting from the day after Passover, which was on the 15th day, the full moon of Nisan, the month of spring. Hence the common name "Pentecost", fifty days. On this holy day, the sons of Israel remember the giving of the law and the covenant at mount Sinai. It is on Pentecost that they will receive both the law and the many gifts and blessings that come with it, such as the wisdom, understanding, and knowledge necessary for the good life. The intellectual virtue of science consists in the demonstrative knowledge of matters that are universal and unchanging. They need all of this virtue that they can possibly obtain, for their researchers to find the anti-dote or vaccine for this covid-19 plague, and for their doctors and nurses and healing staff to do the work of healing. We will be blessed insofar as they are blessed, and we should expect to receive blessing apart from them. We cannot afford to let a piece of lifeless stone anger their G*d. This will darken the minds of us all, and lead us into ignorance. Is it not evident that we have been given over to ignorance already? That our culture is debased in its conversation and that ignorant now men rule over us? This is very dangerous, possibly even more so than the covid-19 plague. Therefore it is critical that the statue be removed or at least defaced before then.
Is this magical thinking? I think not. On the contrary, it is your attempt to invoke the power of the name "Sinai" and the revence due to the person of Moses, apart from the law and covenant for which they stand, which constitutes magical thinking. It is also incoherent and self-refuting. On a skeptical, purely naturalistic account of human life, and history, the prophetic stance taken in this letter is, perhaps, not an inevitable conclusion from the evidence. At least, not from the evidence immediately available to the skeptic who does not know the history or the text. But the skeptic should admit, at least, that it is not against the evidence either. Moreover, it is coherent. And if you demand evidence, perhaps evidence will be given to you. But it will cost you. Rember how you tested the LORD your G*d in the wilderness.
Board members, executives, governors, donors, and other complicit parties - what is it going to be? Accepting responsibility, will you undertake this work upon yourselves? If you won't deface the statue, at least put a paper bag over its head. Or a tallit. Wouldn't that be easier than shutting down an entire city? Wrath is coming on us through this plague. Must we take we heroic measures to prevent it?

Les décisionnaires
Message aux signataires
Partager la pétition
Pétition lancée le 22 mai 2020