Bring Mikalya Matthews Back to Mormon Wives: Prioritize Real Stories Over Toxic Drama!
The Issue
To the Executives at Hulu and the Producers of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives,
As dedicated fans of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, we were absolutely devastated by Mikalya Matthews' announcement on September 14, 2026, that she is stepping away from the series. Mikalya has been the grounded, empathetic heart of the #MomTok community since day one. Watching her step away because she feels forced out by a toxic production enviroment is incredibly disheartening, and we are calling on Hulu to fix this.
Mikalya bravely made the choice to protect her peace and uphold her morals. She clarified on social media that her sole reason for walking away from Season 6 production was the network's decision to bring back Taylor Frankie Paul. As Mikalya rightly pointed out, continuing to platform and profit off volatile behavior, severe domestic legal scandals, and actions that impact young children crosses and ethical line. For a survivor like Mikalya, who has openly shared her personal history with childhood abuse, being forced to film in an evironment that rewards accountability-free drama is a compromise she shouldn't have to make.
By prioritizing shocking headlines over cast safety and integrity, the show is losing its most relative star. We watch Mormon Wives to see authentic women navigating complex lives, chronic illness journeys, and real-world struggles. We don't want to watch a show that drives away its most genuine cast members just to enable toxic cycles.
What we are demanding:
- Establish a Safe, Ethical Filming Environment: Hulu and production must implement strict behavioral and ethical standards for the cast so that Mikalya and other members feel safe, respected, and comfortable returning to work.
- Listen to Mikalya's Boundaries: Producers need to negotiate a filming structure or boundary agreement that respects Mikalya's stance on accountability, allowing her to continue her role on the show without forcing her into unethical dynamics.
- Bring Mikalya Back: We want Mikalya Matthews back on our screens as an Executive Producer and main cast member! Her story isn't done, and the show is not the same without her.
No amount of ratings is worth compromising the well-being of the women who built this show. Hulu, do the right thing: hold your cast accountable, protect your creators, and bring Mikalya Matthews back!
Sign this petition to show Hulu that fans demand real substance over toxic drama!
15
The Issue
To the Executives at Hulu and the Producers of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives,
As dedicated fans of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, we were absolutely devastated by Mikalya Matthews' announcement on September 14, 2026, that she is stepping away from the series. Mikalya has been the grounded, empathetic heart of the #MomTok community since day one. Watching her step away because she feels forced out by a toxic production enviroment is incredibly disheartening, and we are calling on Hulu to fix this.
Mikalya bravely made the choice to protect her peace and uphold her morals. She clarified on social media that her sole reason for walking away from Season 6 production was the network's decision to bring back Taylor Frankie Paul. As Mikalya rightly pointed out, continuing to platform and profit off volatile behavior, severe domestic legal scandals, and actions that impact young children crosses and ethical line. For a survivor like Mikalya, who has openly shared her personal history with childhood abuse, being forced to film in an evironment that rewards accountability-free drama is a compromise she shouldn't have to make.
By prioritizing shocking headlines over cast safety and integrity, the show is losing its most relative star. We watch Mormon Wives to see authentic women navigating complex lives, chronic illness journeys, and real-world struggles. We don't want to watch a show that drives away its most genuine cast members just to enable toxic cycles.
What we are demanding:
- Establish a Safe, Ethical Filming Environment: Hulu and production must implement strict behavioral and ethical standards for the cast so that Mikalya and other members feel safe, respected, and comfortable returning to work.
- Listen to Mikalya's Boundaries: Producers need to negotiate a filming structure or boundary agreement that respects Mikalya's stance on accountability, allowing her to continue her role on the show without forcing her into unethical dynamics.
- Bring Mikalya Back: We want Mikalya Matthews back on our screens as an Executive Producer and main cast member! Her story isn't done, and the show is not the same without her.
No amount of ratings is worth compromising the well-being of the women who built this show. Hulu, do the right thing: hold your cast accountable, protect your creators, and bring Mikalya Matthews back!
Sign this petition to show Hulu that fans demand real substance over toxic drama!
The Decision Makers
Supporter Voices
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on September 16, 2026