"Blueprint for Imbalance": Halt the MM 88​.​6 Project and Audit Village Infill Policy

180

Let’s get to 200 signatures!
Petitions with 1,000+ supporters are 5x more likely to win!

The Issue

We, the residents and taxpayers of Islamorada, formally petition the Village Council and the Florida Department of Commerce to stay the award of RFQ 26-01 (The Machado Property).

The Village’s "Blueprint for Balance" is currently being used to justify a 99-year taxpayer-funded subsidy to a private developer while ignoring critical financial and environmental risks. We are demanding an immediate halt based on the following:

• Financial Misrepresentation: The Village is proposing a 99-year lease on the land at MM 88.6 but has excluded the $1.8 million acquisition cost of the land from its public financial models. This hides a massive taxpayer loss to benefit a private developer.

• Replicating a Proven Failure: The Village is rushing to replicate the Southcliff Estates (MM 95) model. As of May 2026, Southcliff remains a "ghost project" with zero residents and zero revenue despite a $7.5M investment.

• Environmental Negligence: The project site at MM 88.6 is a known Manatee Birthing Sanctuary. Proposed docks and high-density runoff threaten this sensitive nursery, violating conservation principles established in 2021 when high-intensity use was previously denied.

• Infrastructure Degradation: Evidence of "old-fashioned" trench digging for water pipes in the area proves that current infrastructure cannot handle the 36-unit density proposed, risking our roads and native hammock trees.

• Violation of Public Trust: The Village has failed to provide required physical signage on the property and has conducted "whiteboard-only" workshops with no technical handouts, sidestepping the public's right to review.

The Demand:

We demand the Village Council pull RFQ 26-01 from the May 12th agenda and perform a full Independent Fiscal Audit and Environmental Impact Study. We seek "Balance" that protects our environment and our tax dollars, not a 99-year giveaway.

The Decision Makers

Islamorada Village Council
3 Members
Islamorada Village Council - Seat 4
Islamorada Village Council - Seat 1
Deb Gillis
Islamorada Village Council - Seat 3
Kimberly Matthews
Islamorada Village Council (Village Manager)

Petition Updates