
Ban War related materials at primary schools
The issue
We are deeply concerned and calling the Department of Education regarding a BTN news video shown to students at a primary school in Illawarra region NSW on 18/06/2025 about the conflict between two countries. In the class that the video showed, some students are in year 3, and they are just 8 years old.
https://www.abc.net.au/btn/classroom/israel-iran-conflict/105424596
According to the ABC website, BTN episodes are generally for children between 10 and 13 years old. Also, it is mentioned "Some stories may not be suitable for younger children. We suggest that teachers preview the stories to ensure they are appropriate for their students." https://www.abc.net.au/btn/about
The video, which depicted the conflict between Israel and Iran, was profoundly inappropriate for children in primary school for the following reasons:
* Inappropriate Content: The war news and videos are distressing and unsuitable for young children, potentially impacting their emotions, mental health and well-being.
* Lack of Educational Value: The video lacked any demonstrable educational value for children of this age group and was not presented within a relevant curriculum context.
* Misrepresentation and Potential for Bullying: We explain this fact with an example from the mentioned video. The video's reporting focused on the nations of "Iran" and "Israel" rather than the "government of Iran" and "government of Israel" regarding the conflict. The report's use of the terms "Iran" and "Israel" (instead of specifying the government of Iran and the government of Israel) to attribute actions in the conflict is a "critical point".
This nuance is beyond the comprehension of the primary school students' age group, and any students who have a background or connection to any country involved in war could be unfairly associated with the actions of a government in the view of his/her classmates.
* Mental and Emotional Distress:
Exposure to war-related videos can have detrimental effects on children's mental and emotional well-being, potentially leading to anxiety, fear
* Cultural Sensitivity: Wars and conflicts in general are sensitive topics. In a multicultural environment, such as Australian Public Schools, the presentation of war news from news agencies regarding culturally sensitive topics is detrimental to community integration values and could potentially create tension and conflicts between students.
* Lack of Supervision: On the ABC website, it is mentioned, "Some stories may not be suitable for younger children. We suggest that teachers preview the stories to ensure they are appropriate for their students". This is very subjective based on the teacher's personal opinion, and particularly for topics such as conflicts and wars even the teacher's review does not provide content supervision and could be very biased based on the teacher's opinion.
We are requesting that the use of any war concepts, news or related videos be banned at the primary school level to protect students' mental health and general well-being.
40
The issue
We are deeply concerned and calling the Department of Education regarding a BTN news video shown to students at a primary school in Illawarra region NSW on 18/06/2025 about the conflict between two countries. In the class that the video showed, some students are in year 3, and they are just 8 years old.
https://www.abc.net.au/btn/classroom/israel-iran-conflict/105424596
According to the ABC website, BTN episodes are generally for children between 10 and 13 years old. Also, it is mentioned "Some stories may not be suitable for younger children. We suggest that teachers preview the stories to ensure they are appropriate for their students." https://www.abc.net.au/btn/about
The video, which depicted the conflict between Israel and Iran, was profoundly inappropriate for children in primary school for the following reasons:
* Inappropriate Content: The war news and videos are distressing and unsuitable for young children, potentially impacting their emotions, mental health and well-being.
* Lack of Educational Value: The video lacked any demonstrable educational value for children of this age group and was not presented within a relevant curriculum context.
* Misrepresentation and Potential for Bullying: We explain this fact with an example from the mentioned video. The video's reporting focused on the nations of "Iran" and "Israel" rather than the "government of Iran" and "government of Israel" regarding the conflict. The report's use of the terms "Iran" and "Israel" (instead of specifying the government of Iran and the government of Israel) to attribute actions in the conflict is a "critical point".
This nuance is beyond the comprehension of the primary school students' age group, and any students who have a background or connection to any country involved in war could be unfairly associated with the actions of a government in the view of his/her classmates.
* Mental and Emotional Distress:
Exposure to war-related videos can have detrimental effects on children's mental and emotional well-being, potentially leading to anxiety, fear
* Cultural Sensitivity: Wars and conflicts in general are sensitive topics. In a multicultural environment, such as Australian Public Schools, the presentation of war news from news agencies regarding culturally sensitive topics is detrimental to community integration values and could potentially create tension and conflicts between students.
* Lack of Supervision: On the ABC website, it is mentioned, "Some stories may not be suitable for younger children. We suggest that teachers preview the stories to ensure they are appropriate for their students". This is very subjective based on the teacher's personal opinion, and particularly for topics such as conflicts and wars even the teacher's review does not provide content supervision and could be very biased based on the teacher's opinion.
We are requesting that the use of any war concepts, news or related videos be banned at the primary school level to protect students' mental health and general well-being.
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on 30 June 2025